Libya's Haftar seeks support in Greece ahead of peace meeting    Three Egyptians on Forbes Africa's Billionaires' top 10 list    Ghosn lawyers rebut new Nissan claims against fugitive exec    UK expands Hezbollah asset freeze, targets entire organisation    China population now over 1.4 billion as birthrate falls    Iran's top leader: Trump is 'clown' who will betray Iranians    Ronaldo, Barcelona top online influence charts in China: Report    Tennis: Djokovic the man to beat, again, at Melbourne Park    Inter agree deal to sign Man United captain Young: Reports    Art Alert: Bibliotheca Alexandrina to screen Oscar Shorts and star-studded films from Arab world    Screenwriter and producer Mohamed Hefzy's 'Ras El-Sana' to hit Egyptian cinemas in February    Egyptian actress Magda Al-Sabahi dies at 89    China, U.S. sign initial trade pact but doubts and tariffs linger    Asian stocks trade mixed as US-China sign phase-one deal    European shares edge higher after US-China trade deal    Most major Gulf stocks were up; Qatar trades flat    Egypt is best tourism destination for 2020 according to BBC    Rising sea levels threaten sovereign credit ratings in Egypt & other countries    Egypt will not allow Anadolu's continuous ‘support of terrorism': senior official    Washington meeting on GERD continues for third day    Government launches Upper Egypt's first cultural festival    GERD filling will consider Blue Nile hydrological conditions, potential impact on downstream reservoirs: Egypt, Ethiopia, Sudan, US and WB    Egypt names executive head of comprehensive health insurance authority – ministry    New study finds Ocean acidification does not affect behaviour of coral reef fish    Optimism among energy investors amid demands to accelerate tenders, projects    Nancy Ajram's husband charged with ‘intentional' murder    Trump, British PM Johnson agree on a ‘Trump deal' for Iran    Egypt Prosecutor General orders autopsy and investigation over Egyptian- US prisoner death    6th of October Rotary club trains undergrads for teaching literacy workshops    Iran arrests suspects in Ukrainian airliner downing, Rouhani promises to investigate thoroughly    Sudanese PM renews confidence in army, amid limited protest    BBC names Egypt as best tourism destination for 2020    Brain freeze: Russian firm offers path to immortality for a fee    WHO says new China coronavirus could spread, warns hospitals worldwide    Smooth mid-year    Ethiopian Dam talks to continue in Washington on Wednesday : Ministry    Inconclusive GERD negotiations    Mission Africa continues    Parliament approves three-month extension of state of emergency    Berlin Film Festival announces retrospective programme    NBE studies establishment of rowing club in Cairo    Egyptian sports in 2020: challenges and opportunities    Tough Mudder obstacle course race takes place for first time in Egypt    Egypt approves Uber's acquisition of Careem with set conditions    Egypt's Zamalek, Smouha presidents hit with disciplinary sanctions by EFA    Egypt's President Sisi pardons some prisoners on 25 Jan. Revolution anniversary    Egypt's Sami Anan released after near two-year detention    Liverpool's Mohamed Salah optimistic to see Egypt at 2022 World Cup    

Thank you for reporting!
This image will be automatically disabled when it gets reported by several people.

MPs oppose the protest law
Published in Al-Ahram Weekly on 17 - 05 - 2016

Several members of parliament have voiced frustration over a court verdict that sentenced more than 500 young people to between two to five years in prison for protesting against an Egyptian-Saudi Red Sea maritime border demarcation deal.
Anwar Al-Sadat, chairman of parliament's Human Rights Committee, said the ruling against the youths was like a “medal on their chests” that represents their allegiance and loyalty to their homeland and the defence of its property.
On 14 May, Cairo's Qasr Al-Nile court ordered that 166 young people be sentenced to between two to five years in jail for protesting in downtown Cairo on 25 April without prior approval and in violation of the protest law. “Not only did they violate the protest law but also incited citizens to commit acts of violence and sabotage,” the prosecution said.
But MP Al-Sadat, who is also chairman of the liberal Reform and Development Party, insisted that the protesters expressed their opinion “in a peaceful manner without sabotage or violence”.
He also expressed discontent that the verdict was issued quickly, “while there are other trials that take years for a verdict to be issued”.
He added that such verdicts lead to a loss of confidence in the judiciary. “The judiciary is one of the pillars of stability in this country and lack of confidence in it would lead the nation to chaos.”
Al-Sadat said the verdict against young protesters “shows that there is a pressing need that the protest law be amended”.
Joining forces, MP Akmal Qortam, a businessman and chairman of the Conservatives Party, said some of the protest law's articles should be amended. “These articles violate the constitution which grants citizens the right to organise demonstrations,” said Qortam, urging that the law must be amended “to strike a balance between freedom and national security”.
Said Qortam, “Protests are a major face of democracy and freedom and as long as they are organised peacefully, they should be allowed.”
He insisted that most youths in jail had not participated in violent acts. “Yes, we should respect the law and judicial verdicts, but also wise politics says that the state should refrain from antagonising its young people,” said Qortam.
Qortam urged the Supreme Constitutional Court (SCC) to issue a quick and final say on whether the protest law is constitutional. “The SCC has been reviewing an appeal against some of the articles of the law since 2014 and we hope it will give a final say on them very soon.”
Al-Sadat and Qortam also urged President Abdel-Fattah Al-Sisi to invoke his constitutional powers in favour of pardoning young political activists.
“While President Al-Sisi designated 2016 the year of youth, we see that security forces arrest young protesters to face harsh prison sentences,” said Mohamed Badrawi, the parliamentary spokesman of the Egyptian National Movement Party. He urged parliament's Human Rights Committee to submit a new draft of the protest law.
“This draft law should discriminate between peaceful protesters who want to convey a democratic message and radical Islamist protesters who incite violence and sabotage,” said Badrawi.
In a debate in parliament's Human Rights Committee on Monday, members of the National Council for Human Rights (NCHR) agreed that the protest law was one of a number of pieces of legislation that go against the constitution, human rights and freedoms.
“The protest law includes a lot of harsh penalties that should be amended because they are not in keeping with the constitution,” said NCHR member Monsef Suleiman.
High-profile political activist and NCHR member George Ishak described the verdict against the young protesters of 25 April as “shocking” and “horrible”. “It is highly ironic that these terrible verdicts come in what President Al-Sisi calls the year of youth,” said Ishak, adding, “This should be called the year of imprisoning youth.”
Ishak argued that the defendants were arrested in Cairo's Dokki and Agouza districts on 25 April simply for protesting against the government's decision to acknowledge Saudi Arabia's sovereignty over the two Red Sea islands of Tiran and Sanafir. “Although this verdict can be appealed, it should alert parliament to the dangers of the protest law,” said Ishak.
He urged parliament's Human Rights Committee to speed up amending the law to meet Article 73 of the constitution, which grants citizens the right to organise peaceful street demonstrations, public gatherings, processions and all other forms of peaceful protests.
Ishak indicated that Article 155 of the constitution also states that “a general pardon” can be issued only upon the approval of two-thirds of MPs.
Ishak said most of the defendants are school and university students “who will face a bleak future when they will leave prison after five years”.
MP Suzi Nashed said 10 per cent of the total number of MPs — 60 — can submit a proposed amendment of the protest law to parliament's Constitutional and Legal Affairs Committee.
“We do not want the rift between the state and young people to widen, and in this respect another draft law can be submitted to issue a general pardon for all those who were imprisoned for political and protest offences,” said Nashed. “This pardon could even have a retroactive effect, helping political activists who had been imprisoned in the last five years to be pardoned and released.”
Al-Sadat said that he and other MPs will discuss the possibility of sending a letter to Al-Sisi, calling on him to issue a general pardon for all political prisoners in line with his constitutional powers.
Another camp of MPs, however, refused to join the chorus. Mustafa Bakri, an independent MP and a high-profile journalist, said he is against “criticising judicial verdicts”. “The prosecution-general was clear that the 25 April protesters were by no means peaceful and that they were involved in violence and acts of sabotage,” said Bakri.
“The president of the republic cannot issue a pardon for a certain kind of prisoner as long as the verdicts are not final.” He continued, “The verdict against the 25 April protesters can be appealed and in this case the president cannot exercise his powers.”
Ilhami Agina, an independent MP, slammed the National Council for Human rights, insisting that its members adopt foreign agendas. “We do not know how the members of this council were selected and how they serve the agenda of human rights in Egypt,” said Agina. “All we know about the members of this council is that they just like to appear on TV to attack policemen, prosecutors, judges and adopt the chaos agenda of Western human rights organisations.”
Said Agina, “They also want that the release of the 25 April protesters even if the prosecution and judicial authorities agree that they were involved in violence and sabotage.”
Mohamed Farag Amer, a businessman and chairman of parliament's Sports and Youth Committee, urged MPs and members of NCHR to respect the court's verdict. “We can defend the rights of young people but without criticising judges and prosecutors, and we can help release these young activists only after they use their right to appeal,” Amer said.

Clic here to read the story from its source.