Factbox: List of Wimbledon men's singles champions    Egypt condemns terrorist attack on Somalia's hotel    'Egypt's new NGO law was not result of foreign pressure,' says parliament speaker    African Development Bank: $3.3 bln offered for Egypt national projects since 2015    Egypt-Jordan trade balance jumps to $408.6 mln in 4 months    Egypt's tourism minister meets Beautiful Destinations founder during US visit    Experimental HIV vaccine to be tested in US and Europe    Pepenero: Indulging in Italian dishes in a veranda setting    Ahly sidelines key international trio from training session in Spain camp    Bookmakers expects Egypt's Mo Salah might miss the year's Ballon D'or award    Hong Kong anti-extradition protesters fire up fight in suburbs    Sneferu's Bent Pyramid open in Egypt's Dahshur to visitors    Turkey to drill for gas until Greek Cypriots accept plan – minister    Britain to facilitate release of Iran's tanker if it gets Syria guarantees: Hunt    Egypt's SODIC, NUCA sign land deal in Sheikh Zayed    Sahar Nasr meets with British officials for more investments in Egypt    Blackout disrupts Manhattan, darkens Broadway theaters    Quake of magnitude 6.6 strikes west of Australia's Broome: USGS    Neymar raises new speculation about Barca with social media post    Fired MP detained pending investigations over corruption charges    Total of 400,000 Egyptians removed from subsidised food commodities ration cards    Facebook to be fined $5bn for privacy violations    At least 26 killed in terrorist attack on hotel in Somalia    Net consolidated profits of QNB end of June 2019 reach EGP 4.217bn    Comprehensive plan to develop Nasser Social Bank branches: Waly    Film critic Youssef Cherif Rizkallah dies at 76    Late Dynasty tombs unearthed in Dahshur    Egypt arrests founder of pro-Mubarak Facebook page – source    Why female victims of sexual harassment are often shamed?    Economic empowerment of women among Egypt's top priorities: NCW    Jewellery in Nubian spirit    Egypt sees national population growth rate to halve before 2052    Orange Egypt removes Warda from ad campaign after harassment case    AFCON quarter-finals: Desert Warriors face Ivorian Elephants in early final    Five coaches eliminated early from AFCON    Al-Mashat visits National Geographic's Queens of Egypt exhibition in Washingto    Egypt's parliament votes in favor of extending state of emergency for 3 months    'I Am Sorry President Mubarak' Facebook page admin arrested    Egypt's Sisi appoints new president of Constitutional Court    Egypt's top court upholds death sentences for 4 men convicted of rape    Egypt's Parliament approves removing immunity from MP over bribery charges    Parliament officially approves Trade Union Organization    Alexandria's 17th International Summer Festival kicks off July 26    Return of the Cairo Int'l Biennale for Visual Arts with a large plethora of Egyptian and int'l artists    Egypt's Oks controversial law regulating Bar Association    Hassan Shehata slams Egyptian team, EFA following AFCON exit    Singer Gary Numan expects to be dead, buried long age    Egyptian-British parliamentary group condemns Christie's sale of Egyptian antiquities    

Thank you for reporting!
This image will be automatically disabled when it gets reported by several people.

The struggle over ideological power in the Middle East
Published in Daily News Egypt on 19 - 10 - 2015

Using religious frameworks in political contestation and mobilisation has become more eminent in recent decades, spiralling an intricate debate on the conceptualisation and implementation of such references in the Middle East and North Africa (MENA) region. The contradiction, it is argued, mainly lies in the compromising nature of politics and the relatively dogmatic nature of religion. Boosted by inaccurate media coverage and primordial analytical frameworks, it has become tempting to see religion as responsible for conflicts and underachievement in the MENA region.
In the conventional sense, Islamic movements are often held responsible for implementing religion towards political ends. However, this is not always true as non-democratic states in the MENA region and elsewhere in the Muslim majority world had constantly attempted to control ideological power – Islamic religion and its organisations in this case – before Islamic movements even came to exist in the form we know today.
By the end of 2010 and the beginning of 2011, uprisings across the Arab world toppled long-lasting dictators starting from Tunisia's Zine El-Abidine Ben Ali to Egypt's Hosni Mubarak, Libya's Muammar Al-Gaddafi and then Yemen's Ali Abdullah Saleh. These changes altered the political systems in these countries brining new overlapping, intertwined, and intersecting networks of relations, by which new political actors and temporal dynamics have emerged.
Islamic factions, Salafists and the Muslim Brotherhood and their shades did not join the revolutionary momentum in Egypt from the very beginning, yet they played a major role after the 25 January Revolution, winning 351 seats from 498, around 70%, of the Egyptian parliament. The conservative Islamic Freedom and Justice Party owned 45.7% while the ultra conservative Salafi Al-Nour Party 23.6%, according to the Official Elections Portal of Egypt.
The Egyptian uprising was not per se a social revolution aiming at changing the social structures, but rather a political one aiming at deposing a 30-year rule of dictatorship. Yet there was a shift in power balance altering the ideological power relations with other power organisations. It pushed Islamic factions to the top of the political pyramid to appoint a president – Mohamed Morsi – at one time. It shifted back to elect a coup-installed regime under Abdel Fattah Al-Sisi, who accordingly called for an Islamic revolution and reformation of religious discourse at another time. How can one account for such dramatic divergences in trajectories within less than five years?
By acknowledging that political contestation and mobilisation processes in the state of Egypt, or any other state for that matter, cannot be reduced to only ideological dimensions. The increase of political instrumentalisation in politics owes not to the nature and features of the Islamic religion, but rather to the constant power struggle between the elites of the ruling blocs to practice dominance over ideological power networks and sources in order legitimatise, mobilise, persuade, contest, control, lure, coerce, and eliminate.
This power struggle within military, security, political, and religious institutions could pave the way for political instrumentalisation of Islam and trigger elimination and outbidding processes instead of democratic contestation. Elimination processes create new network-like formations on the periphery and interstitial to official power networks relying (as we see in Egypt) on religion's transcendence and socio-spatial extensive organisation.
Seizure of power or change of its distribution is more likely to trigger new forms of relations and perhaps networks, variable in their efficiency and capacity, following a division of labour between those who control security, the military, political institutions and those who control ideological networks. This division of labour necessitates new emergent social relations to satisfy these actors' needs. Precisely somewhere at the beginning of this process, a space for political instrumentalisation of Islam could occur to seize power.
Interstitial forms of extensive interactions, increasingly out of the official control emerge attracting more diffused masses of people, such as the Muslim Brotherhood's followers, to become part of these interstitial networks. Thus, power struggle to have a good grip on ideological power emerges from its distinctive form of social organisation to legitimatise specific forms of authority and to solve contradictions in society.
Ideology is a source of power exercised by an ideological network like other political, military and economic powers. However, ideological power can be more resilient if it is shared, divided, organised, reorganised and mobilised by other power networks. While ideological power enjoys a level of autonomy, which impels its networks to serve their own interests individually if possible, it can be stretched over other power organisations passing on a space for dangerously religious outbidding game and a cynical use of religion. That is why ideological power plays a decisive role in the power struggle in the Middle East. Thus, it is not the nature of the religion, but rather the usefulness of the ideological power for integrating, stabilising and mobilising social life.
Hakim Khatib is a political scientist and analyst works as a lecturer for politics and culture of the Middle East, intercultural communication and journalism at Fulda and Darmstadt Universities of Applied Sciences and Phillips University Marburg. Hakim is a PhD candidate in political science on political instrumentalisation of Islam in the Middle East and its implications on political development at the University of Duisburg-Essen and the editor-in-chief of the Mashreq Politics and Culture Journal (MPC Journal)

Clic here to read the story from its source.