Egypt sees 103 new coronavirus cases to reach 1173; death toll up 7 to 78    EGX starts week in red amid Arab, foreign selling    Ahmad Abdalla's Exterior/Night comes fourth on Netflix daily rankings in Egypt    The Minister of International Cooperation launches the results of the Global Partnership for Effective Development Cooperation Survey    South Sudan has 1st virus case, is 51st country in Africa    Disney+ content to make exclusive Middle East debut on OSN    4.3 magnitude earthquake hits East Nueweiba    Worldwide coronavirus cases cross 1 million, death toll passes 64,000    ‘Screens and Streams': Arab Fund for Arts and Culture releases films and music online    'Complete collapse of economies' ahead as Africa faces virus    Pope begins Holy Week events without the public    Art Alert: Cairo Steps and Um Kulthoum are highlights of culture ministry YouTube channel's new releases    Serbian player sentenced to 3 months at home for flouting curfew    Egypt non-oil private sector contracts faster as virus hits -PMI    Kenny replaces McCarthy as Ireland manager    ‘Stay home. Save lives': Google Doodle provides tips to help stop spread of Coronavirus    Egypt's swimmer Osman quarantined in Red Sea resort after returning from US    Tesla cuts contractors from California, Nevada factories: CNBC    17 doctors, nurses at Egypt's National Cancer Institute test positive for coronavirus    Egypt delays launch of mega projects to 2021 due to coronavirus    Sisi: Egypt in solidarity with people of whole world in coronavirus    Japan ready to give coronavirus-hit nations anti-flu drug Avigan for free    Egypt's Zamalek to extend Carteron's contract after end of coronavirus    Amazon to postpone Prime Day sales event due to coronavirus    Comedy puppet Abla Fahita returns to screens during Egypt's curfew    Broadcaster predicts Spain's La Liga restart in July with no fans    Apple to stop taking cut of some Amazon video purchases on App Store    Filling GERD will begin this rainy season: Ethiopian PM    Egypt's Supreme Council of Culture launches three new competitions    Freed from detention    Huawei to explore the ultimate potential on its Huawei P40 series    Egypt, MENA growth forecast at 2.7%, -0.3% respectively: IIF    Prosecution warns of EGP 300k fine or 2-year jail for spreading fake coronavirus news    Al-Sisi discusses joint coronavirus efforts with Abu Dhabi Crown Prince    Saudi Arabia intercepts missiles over Riyadh    CBE temporarily regulates cash deposits, withdrawals    Lagging COVID-19 response to shield frail economy: Rouhani    Farwell to Egyptian comedian George Sidhom    Weekend's virtual concerts, plays, and festivals people can stream at home    Amid coronavirus outbreak, Egyptian Premier League cancellation seems inevitable    Brazilian football stadiums transformed into hospitals to treat coronavirus patients    Stay At Home: Ministry of Culture to publish free books online for public browsing    What to watch to kill time in quarantine?    Ethiopia has not sent Egypt latest designs for GERD: Minister of Irrigation    Nigerien President hails Egypt's diplomatic attempts to reach agreement over GERD    Al-Sisi appreciates Kenya's support to Egypt's stance on GERD    Cairo court acquits Mubarak's sons of stock market manipulation    Egypt's President Sisi pardons some prisoners on 25 Jan. Revolution anniversary    







Thank you for reporting!
This image will be automatically disabled when it gets reported by several people.





Egypt Needs Ambition, Not Just to Muddle through
Published in Amwal Al Ghad on 09 - 10 - 2013

Amid the recurring violence and polarisation in Egypt, it is clear that the society has lost – at least temporarily – a valuable opportunity to forge a process that would benefit from the country's cultural richness, and that the political transition that started with the January 2011 uprising has failed to provide an answer to the vexing question Egyptians have been unable to answer for more than six decades: "What is Egypt?"
This is not the first time that the question has gone unanswered. Muhammad Ali Pasha and Khedive Ismail, the founders of modern Egypt in the 19th century, created the state institutions but deliberately crushed the political representation of almost all Egyptians. The liberal experiment – from the 1920s to the early 1950s – put forward a narrative that many social groups supported, but at the expense of the economic rights of the lower-middle classes and the poor. Gamel Abdel Nasser's Arab nationalism in the ensuing two decades championed – also with popular support – a different narrative, but at the expense of civil and political freedoms. And for the past four decades, Egypt has lacked any national project or serious attempt at confronting contradictions in its social fabric.
Two factors could have made it different this time. The first is demographic. There is a peril in having millions of undereducated, underemployed young men with very little to lose living very difficult lives amid a lack of basic services. That the current transition was started by neither the military nor Islamists but by secular young Egyptians representing the 45m people under 35, heralded immense promise.
However, the polarisation Egypt has been experiencing in the past two and a half years marginalised these forces. The promise of a young generation advancing a new national project at a moment of national unity is postponed for another day.
The second factor is economics. Egypt confronts acute challenges relating to its fiscal structure, competitiveness and educational system. The January 2011 uprising – and the momentum it unleashed, which strengthened ordinary people's sense of having a stake in their country's economy – could have been an opportune time to adopt the economic reforms needed to confront these challenges. There was a sense that their urgency and magnitude would compel the various political forces to come closer towards political compromises. Now, the greater the turmoil, the less possible it seems to create that social cohesion.
Glimmers of hope remain, however. Despite the bloody scenes, Egyptian society still retains its agrarian character, which favours conciliation and compromise. The unrivalled dominance of the military and the unlikelihood of a division in its leadership make prolonged violence untenable, especially given that the state's fight against terrorism in the 1980s and 1990s significantly weakened jihadist groups' operational capacities. And the powerful forces of political Islam may now be carried away by passions and a sense of victimisation; but they will inevitably opt to participate in domestic politics through organised structures and processes. In a country with Egypt's demographic and economic profile, no political actor with any strategic insight can afford a prolonged impasse.
Egypt is also too big to fail: its population constitutes almost a third of all Arabs; it is by far the largest cultural producer in the region; it has for centuries been the intellectual base of Sunni Islamism. It has been the incubator of every significant pan-Arab ideology in the past two centuries and it commands a critical positioning in almost all strategic dossiers on the Middle East.
There is, however, an enormous difference between not failing and succeeding. The former would be the result of a series of stopgap measures, each buying a few months of tranquillity and enabling the country to feed itself – but barely move on. The latter would be founded on an inclusive political and economic transition that takes Egypt towards genuine democratisation and stability. Only that would unleash the potential of a young society with a vast reservoir of talent.
About the Writer
Tarek Osman is the author of ‘Egypt on the Brink'
Source: The Financial Times


Clic here to read the story from its source.