Egypt's Zamalek undone by stoppage-time strike at Berkane in final first-leg    Meet TUT, Egypt's Nations Cup mascot    President Sisi receives citizens for Iftar at his private residence    Saudi energy minister recommends driving down oil inventories, says supply plentiful    Egypt and Canada's parliamentary speakers discuss bilateral relations    Argentine great Maradona to miss Cannes film premiere after shoulder injury    Scientists in new push to control cancer before curing it    Thales plans to turn Egypt into regional technical hub to provide company's services    FRA considers new amendments to short selling controls    The Netherlands wins the Eurovision Song Contest    Egypt's Sisi follows up on latest preparations for 2019 African Cup    Egypt bids to host AfCFTA's executive office, says legal adviser of AU    Iran is not pursuing war: Revolutionary Guards chief    Saudi crown prince discusses regional developments with Pompeo: Ministry    PM follows up efforts to improve government unified complaints system    UN condemns violence against Sudanese protesters    Policy on Cuba is an embarrassment for United States    MENA's first Vertebrate Palaeontology centre inaugurated in Mansoura University    Egypt ranks 4th among top nationalities visiting Saudi Arabia for Umrah    Suez Canal Bank aims to focus on investment banking services, non-bank financial services    Al-Sisi pardons 560 prisoners convicted in cases from 2013 to 2017    Egyptian museums' revenues increase by 70.5% in 2018: CAPMAS    Egypt's Sisi orders studies to maximize assets, investment returns for religious endowments ministry    Google Doodle celebrates Omar Khayyam, medieval mathematician, astronomer and poet    Hotter weather forecast for Egypt on Monday    Herman Wouk, author of 'The Caine Mutiny' and 'The Winds of War,' dies at 103    President Sisi salutes the martyrs of the armed forces on the 10th of Ramadan victory anniversary    Armed Forces kills 47 terrorists, destroys 29 hideouts in Sinai: spokesperson    Jürgen Klopp wins German Football Ambassador award 2019    Polish minister pops 'what if' question over US gas plans    Presidential decree pardons 560 prisoners    Despite losing EPL title, Salah joins list of back-to-back top scorers    Only one third of world's longest rivers remain free-flowing    Low-category ticket prices for Egypt's matches at AFCON 2019 reduced    Newsreel    No new rent law    Conflict vs dialogue    The alternative economy in Ramadan    Ramadan, Egyptian style    ‘Let there be light'    Algeria steps up arrest campaign    Three-way tie    14 minutes added on    Risks from inflation    Travelling out of the box    Lebanese singer Tania Saleh at the Opera House's Ramadan nights    A present-day Aladdin    Walking a Sufi path    

Thank you for reporting!
This image will be automatically disabled when it gets reported by several people.

Don't Save the Press
Published in Daily News Egypt on 01 - 03 - 2010

LJUBLJANA: Throughout history, political leaders have supported existing communication technologies in order to defend the system in which they rule. Today, too, governments may be tempted to protect newspapers and public TV on the pretext of "saving democracy as we know it. But efforts to block technological change have been futile in the past, and they would be unwise today. Instead, the political system (and the media) must adapt to the new reality.
Faced with an existential crisis as new technologies lure away their readers and viewers, traditional news media - just like bankers, car manufacturers, and solar electricity producers - are increasingly turning to governments for help. But, such is the undertone, their cause is nobler. The media are a cornerstone of democracy. Left to the blogs and tweets, without journalists to report the news, how can citizens decide what politics to support?
Such thinking reflects an age-old fear: as Plato put it, citizens would get "information without proper instruction and, in consequence, be thought very knowledgeable when they are for the most part quite ignorant. It is a fear that has echoed down through history ever since, from the Catholic Church cursing Gutenberg's movable type to the Victorian bourgeois complaining of the newly discovered freedom of the press.
Political rulers, too, have never liked new communication technology, because the political system in which they rule is adapted to the existing technology. Scarcity of parchment required all decision-making to be concentrated in a court consisting of a handful of people. When cheap paper and printing presses - the first true mass-communication technology - challenged this system, the Catholic Church and the monarchs defended the parchment-based monopoly. They failed.
Print, paper, and newspapers enabled the rise of new types of political systems based on expanded popular participation. The transition was not smooth, but those who understood the signs of the times early gained a historical head start. It is not a coincidence that Benjamin Franklin had a background in printing and newspaper publishing. The liberal-democratic political system that resulted from the American Revolution was well aligned with the emerging information technology of the time.
In the "scarce bandwidth media of the past, in which space and time were limited, the media had to select stories worthy of reporting. Mass media could report few big stories in which a few big actors took center stage. In stories about politics, these big actors were political parties.
Indeed, it is not just traditional mass media that are in trouble. High-circulation newspapers correlate with high-circulation political parties. We are right, they are left; we think this, they think that: condensed narratives fit easily on a newspaper's front page or into the tighter constraints of broadcast journalism.
This created a mutually reinforcing symbiosis between the old mass media and old mass political movements, one hostile to the entry of new players. Newspapers and broadcast organizations, like political parties, were expensive to set up, but, once established, they benefited from economies of scale - operating costs remained relatively fixed as circulation (or party membership) grew. They maintain a keen interest in the public's eyes and ears - and thus in each other.
Unfortunately for both, their main strengths - transmitting information and connecting people - happen to be what the Internet does best. Blogs and social-networking platforms encourage seamless, cost-free association - the most efficient form of organization imaginable. No newspaper or broadcast news program can hope to report on what every Facebook group is up to.
So it probably would not take much for politicians to be persuaded that the press is essential to democracy, and that its survival - like that of public television in many countries - depends on government support. Advertising revenue would be replaced by government subsidies, raising predictable questions about the impact on content.
The alternative is to focus on what communication technology cannot do: create rather than transmit a good story or a good policy. There will always be a market for quality. The disruption caused by emerging communications technologies consists in the fact that the best pens may not be on the staffs of newspapers, and that policies need not be formulated only in the corridors of government.
In the 1990s, Bill Gates said, "In the next century, leaders will be those who empower others. Deciding whom to empower, and whom to allow to participate, rather than deciding to save the existing media technology, will determine the future of political parties and the systems in which they govern.
Ziga Turk is a Professor at the University of Ljubljana and Secretary General of the Reflection Group on the Future of Europe, chaired by Felipe González. This commentary is published by DAILY NEWS EGYPT in collaboration with Project Syndicate/Institute for Human Sciences (

Clic here to read the story from its source.