Egypt's golf chief Omar Hisham Talaat elected to Arab Golf Federation board    Egypt extends Eni's oil and gas concession in Suez Gulf, Nile Delta to 2040    Egypt, India explore joint investments in gas, mining, petrochemicals    Egypt launches National Strategy for Rare Diseases at PHDC'25    Egyptian pound inches up against dollar in early Thursday trade    Singapore's Destiny Energy to invest $210m in Egypt to produce 100,000 tonnes of green ammonia annually    Egypt's FM discusses Gaza, Libya, Sudan at Turkey's SETA foundation    UN warns of 'systematic atrocities,' deepening humanitarian catastrophe in Sudan    Egypt's Al-Sisi ratifies new criminal procedures law after parliament amends it    Egypt launches 3rd World Conference on Population, Health and Human Development    Cowardly attacks will not weaken Pakistan's resolve to fight terrorism, says FM    Egypt's TMG 9-month profit jumps 70% on record SouthMed sales    Egypt adds trachoma elimination to health success track record: WHO    Egypt, Latvia sign healthcare MoU during PHDC'25    Egypt, India explore cooperation in high-tech pharmaceutical manufacturing, health investments    Egypt, Sudan, UN convene to ramp up humanitarian aid in Sudan    Egypt releases 2023 State of Environment Report    Egyptians vote in 1st stage of lower house of parliament elections    Grand Egyptian Museum welcomes over 12,000 visitors on seventh day    Sisi meets Russian security chief to discuss Gaza ceasefire, trade, nuclear projects    Egypt repatriates 36 smuggled ancient artefacts from the US    Grand Egyptian Museum attracts 18k visitors on first public opening day    'Royalty on the Nile': Grand Ball of Monte-Carlo comes to Cairo    VS-FILM Festival for Very Short Films Ignites El Sokhna    Egypt's cultural palaces authority launches nationwide arts and culture events    Egypt launches Red Sea Open to boost tourism, international profile    Qatar to activate Egypt investment package with Matrouh deal in days: Cabinet    Omar Hisham Talaat: Media partnership with 'On Sports' key to promoting Egyptian golf tourism    Sisi expands national support fund to include diplomats who died on duty    Madinaty Golf Club to host 104th Egyptian Open    Egypt's PM reviews efforts to remove Nile River encroachments    Al-Sisi: Cairo to host Gaza reconstruction conference in November    Egypt will never relinquish historical Nile water rights, PM says    Egypt resolves dispute between top African sports bodies ahead of 2027 African Games    Germany among EU's priciest labour markets – official data    Paris Olympic gold '24 medals hit record value    It's a bit frustrating to draw at home: Real Madrid keeper after Villarreal game    Russia says it's in sync with US, China, Pakistan on Taliban    Shoukry reviews with Guterres Egypt's efforts to achieve SDGs, promote human rights    Sudan says countries must cooperate on vaccines    Johnson & Johnson: Second shot boosts antibodies and protection against COVID-19    Egypt to tax bloggers, YouTubers    Egypt's FM asserts importance of stability in Libya, holding elections as scheduled    We mustn't lose touch: Muller after Bayern win in Bundesliga    Egypt records 36 new deaths from Covid-19, highest since mid June    Egypt sells $3 bln US-dollar dominated eurobonds    Gamal Hanafy's ceramic exhibition at Gezira Arts Centre is a must go    Italian Institute Director Davide Scalmani presents activities of the Cairo Institute for ITALIANA.IT platform    







Thank you for reporting!
This image will be automatically disabled when it gets reported by several people.



A state of emergency: comparing Syria and Egypt
Published in Daily News Egypt on 02 - 06 - 2008

For some reason, there is a popular assumption that within the boundaries of Middle Eastern politics, every internal factor is related to an external one. Although such popular assumptions only attempt to provide simple answers to complicated questions, the Syrian government persistently traces a pattern of relations between external factors and the internal political conditions in the country. Over the last four decades, what has been perceived as the external threat from Israel has been the prime justification for reshaping the domestic political mechanism in Syria.The state of war with a country that Damascus does not recognize as a legitimate state has deeply affected the political dynamics of Syria. Accordingly, the country has been under a "state of emergency since 1963. In theory, a state of emergency is declared when the state has to suspend its normal functions in order to respond to extraordinary incidents such as war, civil unrest or natural disasters. Often, the drastic measures that are taken by the state in such cases have significant implications for civil society. In that light, in Syria the activities of civic agencies have been largely suspended and a meaningful public participation has been denied in order to enable the body of central decision making to address the "problems effectively.However, the intensity of the state of emergency and its side effects has been part of every day life for over four decades now. In accordance to that, for about 45 years the rulers have securitized all possible dimensions of political life in order to legitimize extraordinary means to "respond to a perceived threat. Yet foreign policy for domestic political consumption is nothing new in the region. Time after time states have used the notion of national security to maintain authoritarian regimes in the Middle East. For example, except for an 18-month break in 1980, Egypt has been living under an emergency law since 1967. The Law was imposed during the Six Day War with Israel. But the peace treaty with the Jewish State did not immune Egyptians from living under an ongoing state of war. The law was forcefully re-imposed following the assassination of President Sadat in 1981. The domestic political conditions have been significantly affected by this law and there is no sign of possible termination for this so-called "emergency situation. Ironically the Egyptian parliament recently extended a decades-old state of emergency by two more years, despite previous promises that the law would be replaced by new anti-terror legislation.Similarly in Syria the notion of national security has been on top of the agenda at the expense of public accountability for many decades. Despite the original slogan of the Ba'ath Party, which is "Unity, Freedom and Socialism, there is little tangible political freedom in Syria, particularly when it comes to scrutinizing the president and the security-oriented agencies which influence major decisions in the country. There are multiple security services operating independently of each other to maintain the stability of the Ba'athist regime. Such a political framework enabled former President Hafiz El-Assad to maintain his power for about 30 years. Apart from the so-called "Damascus Spring, a relatively short period of relaxation after his death, everything has remained generally the same under the rule of his son Bashar. Now after many indecisive years of "no war, no peace it seems that Syria is reconsidering its relations with Israel, a move which may finally bring an end to the historic antagonism between the two states. Although, the bilateral negotiations are complex, the demands seem to be straightforward. It is as obvious as the fact that in return for the Golan Heights, Israel would not expect anything less than peace. Nevertheless, for Syria peace with Israel is not only a matter of reshaping foreign policy, it is an external transition with possible internal implications. In other words, Syrian attempts to shift foreign policy towards Israel may have an affect on Syrian domestic political conditions. Hence, one can question whether the Syrian internal political climate will remain the same in the absence of the external threat from Israel. Can Syria maintain the securitized political climate without an external enemy? Although there are no definite answers to such complex questions, it is more than likely that Syria will follow the same route as Egypt, that is, the securitized monopoly over power will remain the same even without an ideological enemy such as Israel. Although, the "state of war has been the main justification for the lack of accountability, there will be no guarantee that peace can pave the way for more political transparency in Syria. It is very unlikely to expect that peace with Israel can coincide with the termination of the "state of emergency. Although officially the state of war with Israel might end, the existing security-oriented conditions will remain the same. Israel may no longer appear as the external threat, but there will be a shift of attention from the threat of the Jewish State to the homegrown opposition. The Syrian opposition consists of Muslim Brotherhood members, Kurds, liberals and communists. However, they are ideologically incompatible and often they unilaterally pursue their own agenda. The only political objective that they may have in common is to overthrow the existing order in Damascus. Some measures have been taken by some of the prominent dissidents such as former Vice-President Abdul Halim Khaddam to unite the opposition. But still the dissenting parties and movements either outside or inside remain fragmented. For that reason, they cannot constitute collective opposition against the government of Bashar El-Assad. Thus despite the weak nature of the opposition the securitized climate will remain the same and no unorthodox voice will be tolerated in the name of "national security. Although, the external threat from Israel has served the consolidation of authoritarianism, the state machinery will persistently excuse the ongoing emergency law even in the absence of the unfriendly Jewish State. As in the case of Egypt, the political by-products of the state of war will persist in Syria even at the time of peace.
Afshin Shahiis a Cairo-based British Iranian PhD candidate of political philosophy specialized in Middle East affairs.

Clic here to read the story from its source.