Egypt expresses 'deep dissatisfaction' to Netherlands over embassy attack    Global pressure mounts as Gaza fighting intensifies and death toll surges    Egypt, India's BDR Group in talks to establish biologics, cancer drug facility    AUC graduates first cohort of film industry business certificate    At TICAD, Egypt's education minister signs pacts with Casio, SAPIX    Egypt holds special importance for our investments across diverse sectors: Japanese minister    Cairo, Tokyo sign LOI to expand educational cooperation, support for persons with disabilities    Madbouly invites Japanese firms to establish industrial zone in SCZONE    Egypt to tighten waste rules, cut rice straw fees to curb pollution    Al-Sisi meets Qatar PM, Bahrain security adviser to discuss Gaza crisis, regional stability    Indian tourist arrivals to Egypt jump 18.8% in H1-2025: ministry data    Egyptian pound down vs. US dollar at Monday's close – CBE    Egypt's FM, Palestinian PM visit Rafah crossing to review Gaza aid    Egypt prepares unified stance ahead of COP30 in Brazil    Egypt recovers collection of ancient artefacts from Netherlands    Egypt harvests 315,000 cubic metres of rainwater in Sinai as part of flash flood protection measures    Egypt, Namibia explore closer pharmaceutical cooperation    Fitch Ratings: ASEAN Islamic finance set to surpass $1t by 2026-end    Renowned Egyptian novelist Sonallah Ibrahim dies at 88    Egyptian, Ugandan Presidents open business forum to boost trade    Al-Sisi says any party thinking Egypt will neglect water rights is 'completely mistaken'    Egypt's Sisi warns against unilateral Nile measures, reaffirms Egypt's water security stance    Egypt's Sisi, Uganda's Museveni discuss boosting ties    Egypt, Huawei explore healthcare digital transformation cooperation    Egypt's Sisi, Sudan's Idris discuss strategic ties, stability    Egypt to inaugurate Grand Egyptian Museum on 1 November    Greco-Roman rock-cut tombs unearthed in Egypt's Aswan    Egypt reveals heritage e-training portal    Sisi launches new support initiative for families of war, terrorism victims    Egypt expands e-ticketing to 110 heritage sites, adds self-service kiosks at Saqqara    Palm Hills Squash Open debuts with 48 international stars, $250,000 prize pool    On Sport to broadcast Pan Arab Golf Championship for Juniors and Ladies in Egypt    Golf Festival in Cairo to mark Arab Golf Federation's 50th anniversary    Germany among EU's priciest labour markets – official data    Paris Olympic gold '24 medals hit record value    A minute of silence for Egyptian sports    Russia says it's in sync with US, China, Pakistan on Taliban    It's a bit frustrating to draw at home: Real Madrid keeper after Villarreal game    Shoukry reviews with Guterres Egypt's efforts to achieve SDGs, promote human rights    Sudan says countries must cooperate on vaccines    Johnson & Johnson: Second shot boosts antibodies and protection against COVID-19    Egypt to tax bloggers, YouTubers    Egypt's FM asserts importance of stability in Libya, holding elections as scheduled    We mustn't lose touch: Muller after Bayern win in Bundesliga    Egypt records 36 new deaths from Covid-19, highest since mid June    Egypt sells $3 bln US-dollar dominated eurobonds    Gamal Hanafy's ceramic exhibition at Gezira Arts Centre is a must go    Italian Institute Director Davide Scalmani presents activities of the Cairo Institute for ITALIANA.IT platform    







Thank you for reporting!
This image will be automatically disabled when it gets reported by several people.



Scenes from a disgraceful fiasco: Bergman's death spurs debate
Published in Daily News Egypt on 31 - 08 - 2007

On August 4, five days after the death of the legendary Swedish filmmaker Ingmar Bergman, The New York Times published an opinion piece by the famous Chicago Reader critic Jonathan Rosenbaum, headlined Scenes from an overrated career.
The occasionally brilliant, often rigid critic presented an unfounded argument about why he believes Bergman legacy is over-glorified; debating his true stature in cinema history.
A few weeks later, Rosenbaum s big bash was greeted with a universal denunciation and, by the critic s own admission, had unleashed a wave of hysteria.
After spending the last three weeks responding to dozens of scornful critics and film directors around the world, Rosenbaum divulged some startling revelations via a statement he posted on Premiere critic Glenn Kenny s blog. His statement raised questions regarding the credibility of The NY Times.
The story broke when the esteemed Chicago Sun Times critics responded to Rosenbaum s attack through an article entitled Defending Ingmar Bergman.
For starters, Rosenbaum bases his case on a comparison between Bergman and two other great filmmakers: The Frenchman Robert Bresson, known for regarding actors as models with emotionless, blank expressions; and the Danish director Carl Dreyer, who constantly explored the relation between cinematic spaces and editing techniques.
Rosenbaum accuses Bergman of possessing what Bresson and Dreyer lacked - a power to entertain, which often meant a "reluctance to challenge conventional film-going habits?
It s difficult to disagree with Ebert when he wonders: In what parallel universe is the power to entertain defined in that way? Not a single film Bergman directed - including his early melodramas, Wild Strawberries and rare comedies - was rendered to be satisfactory or, by current conventions, widely accessible.
In fact, challenging is the most common word used to describe his work. In terms of cinematic innovations, Persona remains one of the most groundbreaking avant-garde movies in history; it redefined the entire concept of film.
Rosenbaum claims that Bergman s films are riddled with wounds inflicted by Mr. Bergman's strict Lutheran upbringing and diverse spiritual doubts, these films are at times too self-absorbed to say much about the larger world.
The esteemed critic s statement defies nearly every modern philosophy reference that cite The Seventh Seal and Winter Light -among Bergman s other works - as the leading existential works that brought the ideas of Sartre, Camus, Hegel and other philosophers to the screen.
In addition, the greatest filmmakers in history, including Bresson and Dreyer, were always haunted by certain personal traumas, ideas and uncertainties that directly spilled over into their entire cinematic oeuvre.
Bresson is the most Catholic of all filmmakers whose films were always concerned with possibility of salvation in a Godless, modern world. The Lutheran Dreyer s most lauded works channeled the difficulty, and ultimate triumph, of faith.
Hitchcock, Bunuel, Kurosawa, Tarkovsky and the aforementioned two were no less wounded than Bergman; and each one of those directors was branded as being self-absorbed at several points in their careers.
The deep flaws in Rosenbaum s allegations about Bergman s importance are disclosed with his claim that Bergman is taught less frequently today than Hitchcock or the French maverick Jean-Luc Godard. Rosenbaum refers to his claim as a fact, yet he never presents numbers or statistics to support his statement and to contradict the reality shared by most film professors in the world.
Rosenbaum s argument crumbles when he says that one of the signs of Bergman s waning significance stems from how he is hard to find on DVD. In reality, 66 of his films are currently available on Amazon.com. In fact, no other non-American filmmaker is more prominently represented on DVD than him.
The backlash against his article forced Rosenbaum to reveal some behind-the-scenes drama surrounding his story.
Apparently, the Times op-ed editor asked Rosenbaum to write an essay that might offer slightly more perspective than the solemn obituaries.
Rosenbaum says he was asked for several rewrites and that it s obvious that some of my original emphases got altered.
Rosenbaum adds that neither the headline nor the pull-quote, which wasn t actually a quote, were his. He confirms that he wasn t happy with either.
I d wanted a more extended [and favorable] treatment of Bergman s mise en scene, in film as well as in theater, he writes. But, according to him, the Times wasn't interested.
This is not the first time the newspaper has pulled such a stunt. Days after the death of great Italian filmmaker Federico Fellini in 1993, the Times published a blunt dismissal of him by Bruce Weber. It enraged none other than Martin Scorsese, who sent them an angry, scolding letter that became the talk of both the American and international culture community back then.
For a paper with such a high stature as the Times - a massive media organization that always brags about its reputation as the champion of honest journalism - this latest act stands as a patent statement about the state of American journalism.
Rosenbaum s piece was one of the most read Times articles in August, drawing more readers to check the op-ed section. Mission accomplished for the op-ed page editor, but at what price?


Clic here to read the story from its source.