CAIRO: The scene is grim, a blood-stained floor and a grieving mother. This was the seen three years ago when Mona wanted to have her daughter circumcised. The operation was a failure and the 10-year-old girl was killed. The performing doctor fled the scene, Mona says three years later, and “the police did very little at the time to do anything about it. I was devastated.” Female circumcision, or Female Genital Mutilation (FGM), is not a new phenomenon in Egypt, having been conducted for generations, but new legislation had seemingly made the practice diminish. The practice, however, was brought back to the forefront over the weekend after a 13-year-old girl died after a local doctor in the Nile Delta's Menoufiya governorate failed in the operation. Local media said the doctor was arrested soon after when an unknown good Samaritan phoned a hotline service set up to report on female genital mutilation incidents. The doctor, whose name was not revealed in local media reports of the incident, is to stand trial for the illegal operation that led to the girl's death. In June 2007, 12-year-old Badour Shakour died as a result of a circumcision operation. The death sparked a battle within the country over the use of the controversial medical procedure. Her death galvanized women and children's rights groups to action, where they pushed for more stringent penalties against those who carry out female genital mutilation. Shakour's cause of death was an overdose of anesthetic, but her memory was the cause of an awakening that reached to the upper echelons of government. In summer 2008, Egypt's Parliament passed a law that ostensibly bans the controversial procedure. Not that it should have needed to legislate against FGM – it was already officially banned in the country during the mid-nineties – but with doctors continuing to perform the procedure on girls as young as five, Parliament felt it was necessary to intercede. The new law stipulates a fine of 1,000 Egyptian pounds ($185) to 5,000 Egyptian pounds ($900) and a prison term of anywhere between three months and two years if caught performing FGM. A doctor also could lose their medical license. In the case of Shakour, the doctor who performed the procedure languishes in prison after being convicted of manslaughter. But, the rising number of deaths and injuries that have resulted from FGM, including a young girl who was left struggling for her life in November after the procedure, many Egyptians are fighting against the ban. A 2005 report by UNICEF contended that 97 percent of single Egyptian women between 15 and 49 have undergone some form of FGM, although other estimates put the number at 70 percent. Member of Parliament Mohamed Al Omda of a small opposition party, brought his three daughters to the floor of the People's Assembly in protest of the ban last year. One of his daughters carried a sign that read: “No to any attempt to forbid what is divinely allowed. No to any attempt to allow what is divinely forbidden.” Two of his three daughters are circumcised. Many conservative Muslims in the country maintain that the practice is condoned in Islam. The country's Muslim Brotherhood has come under fire over many of their members' denouncements of Parliament's bill. The powerful Islamic group, and many Islamic scholars, argues that the ban is akin to “imposing Western ideals” on Egyptian society, which they maintain is based in Sharia. “Religion does not prohibit or criminalize female circumcision,” prominent Islamic scholar Mustafa Al Shaka said to the local press shortly after the bill was passed. For Mona, the reason for taking her young daughter to have the operation was “to protect her from society and to ensure she would be able to get a husband in the future.” The practice crosses religious lines, as Mona is Christian. In Upper Egypt, the practice is almost knit into the social fabric of the area and despite attempts from women's rights advocates to change perceptions and educate on the dangers of such operations, it continues. Progressive Islamic scholar Gamal Al Banna – brother of late Brotherhood founder Hassan Al Banna – says there is simply no precedent in Islam for this kind of practice. He argues that it was imported into society as a means of forcing women into the background of everyday life. “It didn't exist in Islamic history and those who argue it is Islamic or part of the Sharia are wrong,” the 87-year-old argued. “Religion does not subscribe to this kind of treatment that can cause death and other horrible results. It is un-Islamic.” Al Azhar, the Sunni Islamic world's most notorious religious authority, agrees with the elder Al Banna. In 2007, the Council of Islamic Research issued a statement saying that FGM and cutting are “harmful, have no basis in core Islamic law and should not be practiced.” But Egyptian society remains stratified into opposing camps over the issue, says the National Council for Motherhood and Childhood Secretary General and Minister of Population and Family Planning Moushira Khattab. She believes that although the ban will remain permanent that it will take time to educate the population over the long term effects of cutting a woman's clitoris. “Nobody is going to say no to something that has negative effects caused by the procedure and in time Egyptians will see this,” she begins, “so the punishments that are being handed out against those who conduct this practice is vitally necessary.” UNICEF estimated that three million girls in Africa undergo FGM annually, including in Egypt. The practice is a violation of the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child, adopted in 1989. Although the Egyptian government has banned the procedure, it remains common, especially among the rural communities outside the capital Cairo and Alexandria. A 2005 Egypt Demographic and Health Survey, the majority of FGM procedures have been performed by trained medical personnel. Medical workers involvement in the procedure, human rights groups and doctors in the country, argue is a major reason the procedure continues. “We have to work slowly and cannot expect everything to change in one law. Egyptians are stubborn and if they believe this is part of their religion, then it is very difficult to convince them otherwise, even if they are trained doctors,” said a female doctor at the country's Doctor's Syndicate. She asked not to be named, as the controversy continues inside its doors. With children in danger, the doctor argues that Egyptians must move forward in order to limit these sorts of practices. “We are struggling as a country and until everyone is being educated, it is so difficult to achieve progress on anything, let alone FGM.” Like so many controversial issues facing Egypt today, the seemingly endless battle between secularism and Islam continue to put opposing sides on the defensive. Al Banna believes that issues such as FGM will not be resolved within society until there is an open space for debate on all things, including religion. “We need to be able to debate religion freely or else we will not be able to have people making their own decisions, instead they will follow their local sheikh as if he were the only source for reason.” BM
