Egypt's SCZONE posts EGP 6.25 bln revenue in FY2025/26    Egypt's Cabinet approves plan to increase Arab Monetary Fund's capital    Egypt launches joint venture to expand rooftop solar operations nationwide    Housing Minister reviews progress at alternative site for Samla, Alam Al-Roum    FRA launches first register for tech-based risk assessment firms in non-banking finance    Egypt's Health Ministry, Philips to study local manufacturing of CT scan machines    African World Heritage Fund registers four new sites as Egypt hosts board meetings    Turkish firm Eroglu Moda Tekstil to invest $5.6m in Egypt garment factory    Maduro faces New York court as world leaders demand explanation and Trump threatens strikes    Egypt, Saudi Arabia reaffirm ties, pledge coordination on regional crises    Al-Sisi pledges full support for UN desertification chief in Cairo meeting    Al-Sisi highlights Egypt's sporting readiness during 2026 World Cup trophy tour    Egypt opens Braille-accessible library in Cairo under presidential directive    Abdelatty urges calm in Yemen in high-level calls with Turkey, Pakistan, Gulf states    Madbouly highlights "love and closeness" between Egyptians during Christmas visit    Egypt confirms safety of citizens in Venezuela after US strikes, capture of Maduro    US forces capture Maduro in "Midnight Hammer" raid; Trump pledges US governance of Venezuela    From Niche to National Asset: Inside the Egyptian Golf Federation's Institutional Rebirth    5th-century BC industrial hub, Roman burials discovered in Egypt's West Delta    Egyptian-Italian team uncovers ancient workshops, Roman cemetery in Western Nile Delta    Egypt, Viatris sign MoU to expand presidential mental health initiative    Egypt's PM reviews rollout of second phase of universal health insurance scheme    Egypt sends medical convoy, supplies to Sudan to support healthcare sector    Egypt sends 15th urgent aid convoy to Gaza in cooperation with Catholic Relief Services    Al-Sisi: Egypt seeks binding Nile agreement with Ethiopia    Egyptian-built dam in Tanzania is model for Nile cooperation, says Foreign Minister    Al-Sisi affirms support for Sudan's sovereignty and calls for accountability over conflict crimes    Egyptian Golf Federation appoints Stuart Clayton as technical director    4th Egyptian Women Summit kicks off with focus on STEM, AI    UNESCO adds Egyptian Koshari to intangible cultural heritage list    Egypt recovers two ancient artefacts from Belgium    Egypt warns of erratic Ethiopian dam operations after sharp swings in Blue Nile flows    Sisi expands national support fund to include diplomats who died on duty    Egypt's PM reviews efforts to remove Nile River encroachments    Egypt resolves dispute between top African sports bodies ahead of 2027 African Games    Germany among EU's priciest labour markets – official data    Russia says it's in sync with US, China, Pakistan on Taliban    It's a bit frustrating to draw at home: Real Madrid keeper after Villarreal game    Shoukry reviews with Guterres Egypt's efforts to achieve SDGs, promote human rights    Sudan says countries must cooperate on vaccines    Johnson & Johnson: Second shot boosts antibodies and protection against COVID-19    Egypt to tax bloggers, YouTubers    Egypt's FM asserts importance of stability in Libya, holding elections as scheduled    We mustn't lose touch: Muller after Bayern win in Bundesliga    Egypt records 36 new deaths from Covid-19, highest since mid June    Egypt sells $3 bln US-dollar dominated eurobonds    Gamal Hanafy's ceramic exhibition at Gezira Arts Centre is a must go    Italian Institute Director Davide Scalmani presents activities of the Cairo Institute for ITALIANA.IT platform    







Thank you for reporting!
This image will be automatically disabled when it gets reported by several people.



Bread and power in Pakistan
Published in Al-Ahram Weekly on 24 - 01 - 2008

Violence and political assassinations are not the only reasons Pakistanis have had it with their government, writes Graham Usher in Rawalpindi
On a rain-drenched road in Rawalpindi men, women and children stand patiently behind a truck. It's a few kilometers from the park where Pakistan opposition leader Benazir Bhutto was slain four weeks ago. And the street is covered in sodden party political paraphernalia proclaiming elections next month. But voting and Bhutto are the last things on these people's minds. Like much of the country they are queuing for bread.
"A 20 kilo bag used to cost 250 Rupees; now it's 295," says Rashid Nabil, a sack of flour on his shoulder. "I have to buy one of these three times a month to feed the eight people in my family. I earn 4,000 Rupees a month. That's a lot of your income to be spending on bread".
He shifts the load from one shoulder to the next. "Whatever [Pakistan leader Pervez] Musharraf has done, he's done for the army or for the rich, not for the poor. What's the point of building new roads when you can't feed the people?"
Pakistan is in the midst of its worst bread famine in 40 years. The shortage has been exacerbated by massive power and gas outages. Coupled with the pall cast by Bhutto's assassination -- and what seems an endless toll of political violence (the latest being the murder of 12 people by a suicide bomber at a Shia mosque in Peshawar on 17 January) -- the mood among Pakistanis is as leaden as the winter sky.
The government says these are passing clouds that blot out an enduring sun. Flustered spokespersons say the flour and power crises are seasonal hiccups compounded by the "politically inspired" disorder that followed Bhutto's death. The explanation would be risible were the situation not so grave.
Most know why there is a bread shortage in Pakistan, including the poor. Smugglers and hoarders, capitalizing on record global wheat prices, have found it more profitable to send wheat and flour abroad than to meet domestic needs at home. This is why you will find Pakistani flour in Kabul and Delhi but not in Peshawar. Despite a bumper crop the government was compelled to import wheat, jacking up prices still more.
"The political crisis (caused by Bhutto's assassination) aggravated the economic one -- it didn't cause it," says A R Kamal, an economist. The same mismanagement is responsible for the collapse in power, he says. "The government has continually paraded a seven percent growth rate in the economy. But this growth has been driven by banking and telecommunications. Industry, agriculture and the power sectors have been stagnant. So, despite growth, not one megawatt has been added to the country's power capacity. The government and World Bank waited for the private sector to build power plants. The private sector waited for the state to provide subsidies. And the government crowed about growth. But in manufacturing, agriculture, power -- the industries that matter to the poor -- there wasn't growth; there was neglect".
Neglect is what Iqbal Town feels like. It's a barren, derelict wasteland beside the Rawalpind- Islamabad highway. Three years ago churches and other charities gave loans to the poor so they could leave their barrios in the cities and purchase land to build a home for their families. The government didn't spend a cent. There are no schools or gas supplies and the roads are mud. Water is stolen from pipes supplying richer neighborhoods. And sometimes power is cut for up to eight hours in a day.
Javed Hansraj is a bank teller and, at night, a supplementary schoolteacher. He hopes he can transmit to his class of ten boys and girls enough learning for them to be able to up and leave places like Iqbal Town. Most nights he teaches his wards by candlelight. He's 35. He has never seen his country this bad.
"This year the problems have piled up on one another. There are water shortages, power outages and now suicide bombings. You feel you dare not leave your home or go to crowded places like markets. The whole country is scared. And no one takes responsibility or seems to be in control. If they cannot protect Benazir Bhutto, how can they protect us? The government ought to be changed".
Of Pakistan's 160 million citizens, 65 million live beneath a poverty line of $2 a day and another 65 million live barely above it. Most hale from rural villages but some, like Rashid Nidal and Javed Hansraj, eke out livings on the margins of cities. Historically the poor don't vote in Pakistan. But will the crises "piling up on one another" compel a change?
Nidal shrugs his shoulders. "All the parties promise to reduce prices when in opposition, but when in government nothing happens. Elections don't mean anything to people like us. We will stay poor whoever's in power". But "people are angry," he admits, hauling his sack of flour down the wet road to his family. "May be they'll vote."


Clic here to read the story from its source.