Five investment banks pledge to establish specialised funds to support industrial sector    Egypt moves to secure strategic fuel reserves amid rising regional tensions    OPEC+ agrees to increase oil output following US-Israeli strikes on Iran    Al-Sisi denounces attack on Oman's Duqm port, reaffirms support for Arab sovereignty    Middle East on a Knife-Edge as Israel-Iran Conflict Shows No Red Lines    EGYPTAIR suspends multiple regional flights amid rising tensions    Egypt confirms safe stock of essential goods amid regional developments    Egypt activates Cabinet Crisis Room to monitor regional developments    US-Israel Strike Iran: Egypt's Sisi warns of 'regional chaos' in emergency calls with five Arab leaders    US-Israeli strikes on Iran spark regional escalation, heighten fears of wider war    Egypt uncovers cache of coloured coffins of Amun chanters in Luxor    Egypt plans robotic surgery rollout, pilot programme to launch at Nasser Institute    Egypt Rejects Allegations of Red Sea Access Trade-Off with Ethiopia for GERD Flexibility    Egypt targets 71m meals, 5.5m food boxes in Ramadan social protection drive    Egypt completes 42 sanitary landfills under national solid waste overhaul    Stage as a Trench: Decoding the Poetics of Resistance in Osama Abdel Latif's 'Theater for Palestine'    Egypt's Irrigation Minister underscores Nile Basin cooperation during South Sudan visit    Egyptian mission uncovers Old Kingdom rock-cut tombs at Qubbet El-Hawa in Aswan    Egypt warns against unilateral measures at Nile Basin ministers' meeting in Juba    Egypt sends 780 tons of food aid to Gaza ahead of Ramadan    Egypt sets 2:00 am closing hours for Ramadan, Eid    Egypt reasserts water rights, Red Sea authority at African Union summit    Egypt wins ACERWC seat, reinforces role in continental child welfare    Egypt denies reports attributed to industry minister, warns of legal action    Egypt completes restoration of colossal Ramses II statue at Minya temple site    Sisi swears in new Cabinet, emphasises reform, human capital development    Profile: Hussein Eissa, Egypt's Deputy PM for Economic Affairs    Egypt's parliament approves Cabinet reshuffle under Prime Minister Madbouly    Egypt recovers ancient statue head linked to Thutmose III in deal with Netherlands    Egypt's Amr Kandeel wins Nelson Mandela Award for Health Promotion 2026    M squared extends partnership for fifth Saqqara Half Marathon featuring new 21km distance    Egypt Golf Series: Chris Wood clinches dramatic playoff victory at Marassi 1    Finland's Ruuska wins Egypt Golf Series opener with 10-under-par final round    4th Egyptian Women Summit kicks off with focus on STEM, AI    Egypt resolves dispute between top African sports bodies ahead of 2027 African Games    Germany among EU's priciest labour markets – official data    Russia says it's in sync with US, China, Pakistan on Taliban    It's a bit frustrating to draw at home: Real Madrid keeper after Villarreal game    Shoukry reviews with Guterres Egypt's efforts to achieve SDGs, promote human rights    Sudan says countries must cooperate on vaccines    Johnson & Johnson: Second shot boosts antibodies and protection against COVID-19    Egypt to tax bloggers, YouTubers    Egypt's FM asserts importance of stability in Libya, holding elections as scheduled    We mustn't lose touch: Muller after Bayern win in Bundesliga    Egypt records 36 new deaths from Covid-19, highest since mid June    Egypt sells $3 bln US-dollar dominated eurobonds    Gamal Hanafy's ceramic exhibition at Gezira Arts Centre is a must go    Italian Institute Director Davide Scalmani presents activities of the Cairo Institute for ITALIANA.IT platform    







Thank you for reporting!
This image will be automatically disabled when it gets reported by several people.



Bought democracy
Published in Al-Ahram Weekly on 28 - 05 - 2009

Lebanese election spending was regulated under a law passed last year. In Tripoli, nobody appears to have noticed, Lucy Fielder reports
Abdullah has just a few days to decide who to work for in the coming general elections: majority leader Saad Al-Hariri or opposition leader former Prime Minister Omar Karami. He supports the former, but that is irrelevant. It is all down to who pays the most. As a coffee shop owner in one of Tripoli's most deprived areas, he says he is offered up to $2,000 to hang posters and influence customers. "Then, a few weeks later, the other side pays me to take those down and put up their posters," he says in his flat, where he has agreed to speak anonymously about the dirty business of Lebanese elections. So far, he says, he has pocketed about $4,000 ahead of the 7 June poll.
Clustered on a hill rising steeply from the Abu Ali River, the poor districts of Tripoli form a gallery for the battling billionaires. Thousands of posters of the zaims, or strongman leaders, cover balconies, roofs and walls; some are four storeys high. Inside the winding streets of Bab Al-Tabbaneh, one of Lebanon's most deprived areas where few state services reach, it is easy to see, amid the rotting piles of rubbish, why residents will accept $100 to hang a poster.
"I call it the photography studio," says a woman who has allowed me onto her apartment block roof to take in the view. The ancient, feudal practice of clientelism is alive and well in all of Lebanon, nurtured by the sectarian system. But it is most stark amongst such poverty.
Abdullah's coffee shop has become an "office", an informal centre for distributing services and free coffee and swaying voters with cash. About 10-15 youths work for him. "We work with the members of parliament," he says. "They pay us and we help them buy votes. This year, the price of a vote has reached $500." And that's just an individual vote. More commonly -- Tripolitans and observers say -- votes are bought in blocs.
Nasir Warwar, a trader in Bab Al-Tebbaneh's vegetable market, says he supports Karami, and as a senior member of a fairly large family holds sway over about 100 votes. "Yesterday, another zaim 's people came to me and offered me $5,000 to switch sides and bring my votes with me," he says, in his flat in Tripoli. "But I won't sell my vote."
Vote buyers say they expect the real work to start mid- afternoon on 7 June, about three hours before poll-stations close. That's when many of the undecided can be persuaded to auction their ballot to the highest bidder. "They pay more for the last voters," Abdullah says.
Last year's election law, a cobbled-together compromise that was part of a deal hatched in Doha to end 18 months of violence, attempted to curb campaign spending, and with it corruption. But it encouraged voting along sectarian lines by creating small electoral districts, thereby increasing the likelihood that people vote mainly for seats reserved for their sect, given that co-religionists tend to live in clusters or dominate whole regions. Observers say it thereby fuelled clientelism and corruption, and undermined platform-based politics.
And along with the difficulty of enforcing spending limits in lawless Lebanon, there were several loopholes. "The main loophole is bank secrecy," explains Ammar Abboud, policy advisor to the Lebanese Association for Democratic Elections, a Beirut-based non-government organisation. "A candidate now has to open an account that can be monitored, but his private accounts remain private."
And campaigners lost the battle to push through another simple but crucial reform, the pre-printed ballot paper. Parties, zaims and the vote-buying mafia remain able to print, or even hand-write, their own ballots on any piece of white paper. So a "key voter", someone who can bring a bloc of votes with them, such as a community leader or family head, will be given a ballot printed with a particular font, say, or with the names in a particular order.
"During vote-counting, the campaign machines of each candidate not only count votes, but also the different templates they distributed," Abboud says. "So they can track how everyone has voted and pay the exact sum. If there was a pre-printed ballot, those who want to buy votes would have to do so without having any guarantee that those they paid did actually vote for them." As is, if a vote-buyer like Abdullah is paid up front but fails to deliver the agreed votes to the right leader, he can be found out.
Clientelism in Lebanon is not always in the form of outright vote buying. This year's vogue among political parties is buying plane tickets to bring expatriate Lebanese home, on condition of casting a favourable ballot. Most voters are swayed more subtly, through the provision of services where the state falls short. Mahmoud Al-Aswad runs another electoral "office" in Bab Al-Tebbaneh. Counting prayer beads, he describes how he works with deputies to "help" the people. "If there's an MP we trust, who we think will work with us throughout his four-year term, we cooperate with him on the basis of offering people services," he says. He explains that usually people bring hospital bills and he stumps up most of the sum on the politician's behalf. Local residents often save their requests, where possible, for election time, knowing they are much more likely to be answered.
Above him, Najib Mikati smiles from a gilt frame. He is one of the richest of the city's leaders and widely seen as the most popular and influential zaim among Tripolitans, above even Al-Hariri. Many expect Mikati to be Lebanon's next prime minister if the opposition coalition led by Hizbullah wins the elections, which are expected to be close. Clientelism is common practice both among opposition forces and those who hold the current parliamentary majority, the pro-Western "14 March" movement.
Al-Aswad refers to this arrangement as being "like a charity". But he is under no illusions concerning the city's strongmen.
"We're the poor, the downtrodden, and we're just numbers in the elections," he says. "People don't want help, they want jobs, health services, education." But for politicians who profit from providing "charity" to the poor in the run up to the elections, there is little incentive to reform the system and improve people's lot. "Don't forget it's the politicians who corrupted the people, not the other way round," Al-Aswad says. "They've got us all used to running around chasing $100 bills."


Clic here to read the story from its source.