Front Page
Politics
Economy
International
Sports
Society
Culture
Videos
Newspapers
Ahram Online
Al-Ahram Weekly
Albawaba
Almasry Alyoum
Amwal Al Ghad
Arab News Agency
Bikya Masr
Daily News Egypt
FilGoal
The Egyptian Gazette
Youm7
Subject
Author
Region
f
t
مصرس
Mexico's inflation exceeds expectations in 1st half of April
Egypt's gold prices slightly down on Wednesday
Tesla to incur $350m in layoff expenses in Q2
GAFI empowers entrepreneurs, startups in collaboration with African Development Bank
Egyptian exporters advocate for two-year tax exemption
Egyptian Prime Minister follows up on efforts to increase strategic reserves of essential commodities
Italy hits Amazon with a €10m fine over anti-competitive practices
Environment Ministry, Haretna Foundation sign protocol for sustainable development
After 200 days of war, our resolve stands unyielding, akin to might of mountains: Abu Ubaida
World Bank pauses $150m funding for Tanzanian tourism project
China's '40 coal cutback falls short, threatens climate
Swiss freeze on Russian assets dwindles to $6.36b in '23
Amir Karara reflects on 'Beit Al-Rifai' success, aspires for future collaborations
Ministers of Health, Education launch 'Partnership for Healthy Cities' initiative in schools
Egyptian President and Spanish PM discuss Middle East tensions, bilateral relations in phone call
Amstone Egypt unveils groundbreaking "Hydra B5" Patrol Boat, bolstering domestic defence production
Climate change risks 70% of global workforce – ILO
Health Ministry, EADP establish cooperation protocol for African initiatives
Prime Minister Madbouly reviews cooperation with South Sudan
Ramses II statue head returns to Egypt after repatriation from Switzerland
Egypt retains top spot in CFA's MENA Research Challenge
Egyptian public, private sectors off on Apr 25 marking Sinai Liberation
EU pledges €3.5b for oceans, environment
Egypt forms supreme committee to revive historic Ahl Al-Bayt Trail
Debt swaps could unlock $100b for climate action
Acts of goodness: Transforming companies, people, communities
President Al-Sisi embarks on new term with pledge for prosperity, democratic evolution
Amal Al Ghad Magazine congratulates President Sisi on new office term
Egypt starts construction of groundwater drinking water stations in South Sudan
Egyptian, Japanese Judo communities celebrate new coach at Tokyo's Embassy in Cairo
Uppingham Cairo and Rafa Nadal Academy Unite to Elevate Sports Education in Egypt with the Introduction of the "Rafa Nadal Tennis Program"
Financial literacy becomes extremely important – EGX official
Euro area annual inflation up to 2.9% – Eurostat
BYD، Brazil's Sigma Lithium JV likely
UNESCO celebrates World Arabic Language Day
Motaz Azaiza mural in Manchester tribute to Palestinian journalists
Russia says it's in sync with US, China, Pakistan on Taliban
It's a bit frustrating to draw at home: Real Madrid keeper after Villarreal game
Shoukry reviews with Guterres Egypt's efforts to achieve SDGs, promote human rights
Sudan says countries must cooperate on vaccines
Johnson & Johnson: Second shot boosts antibodies and protection against COVID-19
Egypt to tax bloggers, YouTubers
Egypt's FM asserts importance of stability in Libya, holding elections as scheduled
We mustn't lose touch: Muller after Bayern win in Bundesliga
Egypt records 36 new deaths from Covid-19, highest since mid June
Egypt sells $3 bln US-dollar dominated eurobonds
Gamal Hanafy's ceramic exhibition at Gezira Arts Centre is a must go
Italian Institute Director Davide Scalmani presents activities of the Cairo Institute for ITALIANA.IT platform
Thank you for reporting!
This image will be automatically disabled when it gets reported by several people.
OK
In the hot seat
Jonathan Cook
Published in
Al-Ahram Weekly
on 08 - 11 - 2001
Stripping outspoken Knesset member Azmi Bishara of parliamentary immunity clearly reflects
Israel
's idea of democracy when it comes to the Palestinian minority, writes Jonathan Cook
The
Israeli
leadership was steering a collision course with its Palestinian minority this week when it stripped Knesset member Azmi Bishara, one of the country's most outspoken critics, of his parliamentary immunity in order to put him on trial for treason.
The decision against the National Democratic Alliance (NDA) parliamentarian is seen as a major attack on freedom of speech as it allows Bishara to be prosecuted in the criminal courts for his political comments. There are fears among Palestinian leaders in
Israel
that this new policy will be selectively applied to Arab MKs in order to silence them. Many are concerned that the move is a prelude to outlawing some Arab parties, particularly Bishara's NDA and the Islamic Movement.
On Monday a parliamentary committee voted 14 to six to strip Bishara of his immunity, removing the main obstacle stopping law officers from indicting and charging him for a visit he made to
Syria
in the summer. Bishara, who was not at Monday's committee meeting, said he did not commit any crime and that "removing an MKs immunity for expressing his democratic political views is a mark of shame for the Knesset."
The committee's decision still needed to be ratified by the whole Knesset, which was due to vote on the issue on Tuesday. An agreement between the ruling Likud coalition and the opposition group postponed the vote until Wednesday to allow more MKs to vote, but the boost made little difference. Yesterday, the Knesset voted in two separate ballots to strip Bishara of his immunity. The first, concerning his anti-
Israeli
remarks, was backed by 61 MKs. The second, regarding his organising of trips to
Syria
, was voted through by 65 MKs.
Bishara went to Kardaha in June to attend a memorial service for the late
Syrian
President Hafez Al-Assad. Pictures showing Bishara seated with the Hizbullah leader Sheikh Hassan
Nasrallah
and Hamas members outraged the
Israeli
government and public. At the ceremony, Bishara denounced the "warmongering" policies of Ariel Sharon's government and suggested that resistance was a legitimate response to
Israeli
occupation -- comments that were seen in
Israel
as support for Hizbullah.
Israeli
Attorney General Elyakim Rubinstein has been relentlessly pursuing Bishara ever since, even ordering officials to lie in wait with court orders for Bishara when he crossed back into
Israel
from
Jordan
after the
Syrian
trip. Rubinstein has prepared two charges against Bishara. The first, for "incitement to violence" and "expressing support for terrorism," refers to his remarks in
Syria
and to comments Bishara made a year earlier at a rally in northern
Israel
. In that speech, Bishara referred to
Israel
's humiliating withdrawal from south
Lebanon
as the Arabs' "first victory over
Israel
since 1967." He also referred to Hizbullah as a "legitimate liberation movement."
The second charge, "abetting illegal exit from
Israel
," refers to trips Bishara organised for 800 elderly Palestinians to be reunited with relatives in
Syria
they had not seen since the 1948 war that created
Israel
. Although Bishara can travel to
Syria
on his diplomatic passport, it is illegal for ordinary citizens to enter a country with which
Israel
is at war without first receiving a permit.
Bishara claims that his comments were made in his capacity as an MP and that he is therefore covered by a professional immunity that cannot be lifted. As Bishara's speeches concentrated on criticising
Israel
's occupation of south
Lebanon
, and Hizbullah's right to militarily opposition, any trial risks developing into a potentially embarrassing examination of the legitimacy under international law of
Israel
's occupation policies, both in
Lebanon
and currently in the West Bank and Gaza.
Bishara predicted as much when he was presented with draft indictments by Rubinstein in August. "Both indictments pose a large question mark over
Israel
's pretensions to democracy," he said. "If the first indictment [for incitement] comes to court, the discussion will have to revolve around the nature of the occupation and the right to resist occupation."
Of the charge referring to his organisation of trips to
Syria
, he said: "Only heartless bureaucrats could have drafted the second indictment, in which they want to put me on trial for a humanitarian act of the highest degree." Bishara says he did not ask the families to get permits because he believes there is evidence the Interior Ministry uses the process to coerce applicants to become collaborators.
The prospect of an elected politician standing in the dock to defend his opinions -- risking a jail sentence if convicted -- has unnerved even some Jewish MKs. Yossi Katz, the Labour Party chairman of the House Committee that lifted Bishara's immunity, warned his colleagues before the vote not to continue with their course because immunity was the only protection Knesset members had against the curtailment of their free speech.
Jamil Dakwar, of the Arab legal organisation Adalah, which represents Bishara, said: "This is a very dangerous precedent which dramatically narrows the borders of
Israeli
democracy. Now opinions which should be contested in the political arena are being challenged in the courts. It is part of attempts by the government to stifle genuine debate."
It is the first time in
Israel
an MK's immunity from prosecution has been lifted over an expression of political views. Usually it is lifted only in cases where MKs are suspected of committing a crime. The nearest the Knesset has come to such an action was in the 1980s, when it partially lifted the immunity of Mohamed Miari, leader of the Progressive List for Peace. However, in that case the purpose was only to restrict Miari's movements and prevent him from going to the West Bank and Gaza to meet with Palestinian leaders.
The decision on Bishara provoked demonstrations in major Arab towns, including Nazareth, Umm Al-Fahm, Arara, Kfar Kana, Sakhnin and Tira. In Bishara's home town of Nazareth, party activists stood in the main street waving Palestinian flags and handing out leaflets to passing pedestrians and motorists. They threatened to begin widespread protest campaigns.
Bishara is not alone among the 13 Arab MKs in facing legal investigation. In the past year, three other MKs -- Mohamed Barakeh, Ahmed Tibi and Abdel-Malik Dehamshe -- have been accused of incitement. Rubinstein has also accused another, Talab a- Sana, of sedition for his remarks that a Palestinian shooting attack on soldiers at the Ministry of Defence building in Tel Aviv was "a legitimate struggle of the first order for the Palestinians."
Adalah has criticised Rubinstein's selective investigations, which have overlooked inflammatory comments by Jewish Knesset members. One such MK, Michael Kleiner, of Herut, called for Bishara to be put in front of a firing squad.
Arab MKs have been facing other threats in carrying out their duties. Last week Mohamed Barakeh, Issam Makhoul and Ahmed Tibi were attacked by police when they attended demonstrations against land confiscations in Tira in central
Israel
. Tibi and Barakeh both required medical treatment for their injuries.
Recommend this page
© Copyright Al-Ahram Weekly. All rights reserved
Send a letter to the Editor
Clic
here
to read the story from its source.
Related stories
An ominous prelude
Things to come
Azmi Bishara: a brilliant threat
Defining the enemy
Israel hounds brave voice into exile
Report inappropriate advertisement