Gaza under Israeli siege as death toll mounts, famine looms    New accords on trade, security strengthen Egypt-Oman Relations    Egypt launches public-private partnership to curb c-sections, improve maternal, child health    Egypt Post discusses enhanced cooperation with Ivorian counterpart    EMRA, Elsewedy sign partnership to explore, develop phosphate reserves in Sebaiya    Opella becomes first global consumer healthcare firm to gain B Corp status    Philip Morris Misr announces new price list effective 1 July    EGX closes in red on July 1st    Gold gains as investors flee to safe havens    Egypt, Iran FMs discuss Gaza truce, nuclear talks revival    Egypt's Environment Minister calls for stronger action on desertification, climate resilience in Africa    Egypt in diplomatic push for Gaza truce, Iran-Israel de-escalation    Egypt teams up with private sector to boost university rankings    Egypt reveals heritage e-training portal    Three ancient rock-cut tombs discovered in Aswan    Egypt condemns deadly terrorist attack in Niger    Egypt, Tunisia discuss boosting healthcare cooperation    Egypt's commodity reserves "very reassuring", some stocks sufficient for 9 months — trade chief    Egypt's FM, China's Wang discuss Iran-Israel escalation    Sisi launches new support initiative for families of war, terrorism victims    Egypt's GAH, Spain's Konecta discuss digital health partnership    Grand Egyptian Museum opening delayed to Q4    Egypt expands e-ticketing to 110 heritage sites, adds self-service kiosks at Saqqara    Egypt's Irrigation Minister urges scientific cooperation to tackle water scarcity    Egypt discovers three New Kingdom tombs in Luxor's Dra' Abu El-Naga    Egypt launches "Memory of the City" app to document urban history    Palm Hills Squash Open debuts with 48 international stars, $250,000 prize pool    Egypt's Democratic Generation Party Evaluates 84 Candidates Ahead of Parliamentary Vote    On Sport to broadcast Pan Arab Golf Championship for Juniors and Ladies in Egypt    Golf Festival in Cairo to mark Arab Golf Federation's 50th anniversary    Germany among EU's priciest labour markets – official data    Cabinet approves establishment of national medical tourism council to boost healthcare sector    Egypt's PM follows up on Julius Nyerere dam project in Tanzania    Egypt's FM inspects Julius Nyerere Dam project in Tanzania    Paris Olympic gold '24 medals hit record value    A minute of silence for Egyptian sports    Russia says it's in sync with US, China, Pakistan on Taliban    It's a bit frustrating to draw at home: Real Madrid keeper after Villarreal game    Shoukry reviews with Guterres Egypt's efforts to achieve SDGs, promote human rights    Sudan says countries must cooperate on vaccines    Johnson & Johnson: Second shot boosts antibodies and protection against COVID-19    Egypt to tax bloggers, YouTubers    Egypt's FM asserts importance of stability in Libya, holding elections as scheduled    We mustn't lose touch: Muller after Bayern win in Bundesliga    Egypt records 36 new deaths from Covid-19, highest since mid June    Egypt sells $3 bln US-dollar dominated eurobonds    Gamal Hanafy's ceramic exhibition at Gezira Arts Centre is a must go    Italian Institute Director Davide Scalmani presents activities of the Cairo Institute for ITALIANA.IT platform    







Thank you for reporting!
This image will be automatically disabled when it gets reported by several people.



Veiled dependency?
Published in Al-Ahram Weekly on 08 - 01 - 2004

Al-Azhar is under fire after its Grand Imam issued a controversial edict on France's anti-hijab bill, reports Gihan Shahine
Last week's statement by Al-Azhar Grand Imam Sheikh Mohamed Sayed Tantawi regarding French proposals to ban the hijab in state schools and government offices ignited a high profile controversy involving Islamic scholars, Islamist groups and the Muslim public.
While conceding that the hijab is a religious obligation for Muslim women Tantawi stressed that it is also the right of a non-Muslim country like France to ban it. Tantawi made the statement during a press conference following a meeting with French Interior Minister Nicolas Sarkozy. Arguing that no country has the right to interfere in French lawmaking, Tantawi said that if the French government forced women to take off their veils, they would not be committing a sin.
Many interpreted Tantawi's statement as giving France the go-ahead to ban the hijab and the Grand Imam was seen to be expressing a political, rather than religious, opinion. Critics argue he should have defended France's veiled Muslims by opposing the ban on the grounds that the hijab is not a symbol, but rather a religious obligation and a human right.
Three days later, on 2 January, crowds of worshippers gathered in front of Al- Azhar mosque to protest Tantawi's edict, and call for his resignation. The outlawed Muslim Brotherhood also held a public rally following Friday prayers on the same day, lambasting Tantawi as "a government official" who "compromises the principles of Islam [for the sake of] state policies".
In doing so, they argued, Tantawi has forfeited much of Al-Azhar's credibility in the Islamic world.
Brotherhood MP Mohamed Mursi joined 16 other MPs to issue a statement calling on Al-Azhar scholars to challenge those of Tantawi's edicts that "contradict the teachings of Islam as established in the Qur'an and Sunna".
The controversy grew when Brotherhood MP Hamdi Hassan sent a written statement to Prime Minister Atef Ebeid requesting the appointment of "a new imam who will maintain Al-Azhar's esteem, and regain its credibility". The statement characterised Tantawi's stand as "suspicious".
"Tantawi's statement was like a bombshell for Muslims both inside and outside Egypt," said Hassan. "The way [Tantawi] insisted on repeating that 'it is [France's] right' to ban hijab in a confident voice to please Sarkozy was extremely shocking.
Sarkozy sought a green light from Sunni Islam's foremost authority and ended up obtaining it."
Islamist Mohamed Abdel-Quddous, who heads the Press Syndicate's Freedoms Committee, maintains Tantawi's hijab statement "has actually given an Islamic identity to a secular opinion". He described Tantawi's "edicts over the past year" as being "the worst ever".
Doctors' Syndicate Deputy Head Essam El-Erian believes "Tantawi should have remained silent since he did not possess the courage" to speak against the proposed hijab ban. El-Erian -- a leading Brotherhood member -- said it would have been better for the imam to refer the issue to the European Council for Islamic Affairs, where scholars are better acquainted with the European Islamic community's problems.
Tantawi's comments exposed a growing schism within Al-Azhar where senior clerics immediately announced that his statement represented "personal views" rather than the opinions of Al-Azhar scholars. Sheikh Abdel-Sabour Marzouq, secretary- general of Al-Azhar's Higher Council for Islamic Affairs and a member of the Islamic Research Academy (IRA), told the press that Tantawi had not consulted IRA scholars on the matter, and had reneged on a promise to organise a meeting between the group and Sarkozy.
"He does not represent Al-Azhar or Islam," a disgruntled Marzouq told Al- Jazeera satellite channel, warning that, given anti-Islamic sentiments currently rife in Europe, the anti-hijab law might mark the beginning of a series of bans on Muslim rituals. Marzouq maintained that Tantawi should have at least argued that the French government should not ban the hijab, in the same way that most Muslim countries do not force non-Muslim women to put on the veil.
Egypt's Mufti Ali Gomaa condemned the proposed ban as "a blatant interference in Muslim rituals and doctrine". In an earlier edict Gomaa had explained that, unlike the cross and skullcap, the hijab is a religious obligation firmly established in the Qur'an and Sunna. True secularism, Gomaa argued, does not impose restrictions on religious practice and thus should not force Muslim women to disobey God. "I fear that French Muslim students will later be asked why they refuse to eat pork, or why they pray and fast," Gomaa said. "[This] law indicates that [France] does not accept the other."
But Gomaa also refuted claims that Al- Azhar had given France "the official green light" to pass the anti-hijab bill, arguing Tantawi had already made it clear that hijab was an obligation on Muslim women.
Former Mufti Nasr Farid Wasel also tried to soften criticism of Tantawi, saying his statement only meant that removing the veil would not be a sin if the French government decided to impose a ban on the hijab.
Tantawi's edict, which follows an earlier decision by the Grand Imam to retract a fatwa issued by a senior Al-Azhar cleric urging Muslim and Arab states to boycott the Iraqi Governing Council, has increased questions over his independence. Tantawi abjured the earlier edict, which bore Al-Azhar's official seal, 10 days after it was issued and, perhaps more damaging, immediately after meeting with US Ambassador David Welch. "No Egyptian cleric has the right to pass verdicts on the affairs of another country," Tantawi said by way of explanation.
According to El-Erian "Tantawi has turned himself into a government mouthpiece. Even when [he] remains silent on a certain matter he does so to please the government."
By not consulting other Al-Azhar scholars before issuing his hijab statement El- Erian says he left his colleagues no choice but to publicly oppose him, thus further tarnishing the reputation of Al-Azhar.


Clic here to read the story from its source.