Egypt keen on boosting int'l cooperation in custom matters: Finance minister    Jennifer Lopez evokes Egyptian outrage post her North Coast performance    Balotelli: I have zero fear of failing    Omar, Tlaib to discuss Israel, Palestine travel restrictions    Sudan's ex-president Bashir arrives at corruption trial    German central bank suggests economy may be in recession    UK's Johnson tells Germany and France: do a Brexit deal    Expected interest rate cuts to positively reflect on direct investment indicators end-2020: Pharos    Mediterranean diet tied to lower risk of gestational diabetes    Hometown markets phase I of its work debut in Egypt new capital    Afghanistan blasts wound dozens on Independence Day    Huawei's first 5G phone goes public in China, despite US pressure    Saudi stocks rise, lifted by banking shares    Tennis: Pera, Cornet advance as thunderstorms rumble in the Bronx    Trump, US officials dismiss recession fears, defend trade war    Bayern Munich sign Coutinho on loan from Barcelona    Cairo's historic Tahrir square to be renovated – PM    Political parties gear up for parliamentary, senate, local elections    South Korea, Egypt discuss inking FTA soon    Unprecedented Glory: Egypt win Men's U-19 World Handball Championship    No indication Libya's Zuwara Airport was used in military operations: UN    Al-Sisi honours Egypt's scholars on Science Day    UAE-backed Yemeni southern separatists withdraw from parts in Aden    Declining global interest rates to encourage hard currency borrowing in EM: IIF    12th National Egyptian Theatre Festival fuel up public theatre art scene    28th Citadel Festival for Music and Singing embraces attendees with international troupes    A simple diet change could help live longer, reduce cardiovascular risks by 16%    Personalized cancer treatment wins FDA approval    Afghan wedding suicide bomb kills 63, amid hopes for talks    Serbian Micho to be Zamalek's new coach: Egypt's Mortada Mansour    Cairo University tops 2019 Shanghai Academic Ranking    3 sentenced to death for 2016 killing of 4 Egyptian policemen    Too early to estimate Nile's flooding volume: Irrigation Ministry    Ministry of Environment has a plan for "black clouds season"    Cairo University jumps 100 ranks in Shanghai Ranking    Sudan's key opposition may nominate economist Abdalla Hamdok for prime minister    Disney warrior Mulan star: ‘I support the Hong Kong police, #BoycottMulan trending    Egypt to launch Bike for Every Citizen initiative soon    Egypt's Zamalek equal club record with 7-0 hammering of Somalia's Dekedaha    LA Opera declines details on longtime general director's investigation    Economic, educational legislations will top fifth parliamentary round    Sudan opposition to nominate economist Abdalla Hamdok for prime minister: Sources    Liverpool wins Super Cup after penalty shootout against Chelsea    Egypt produces ‘Fraud' documentary on Muslim Brotherhood history    VIDEO: Egyptian Media Group releases ‘Scam,' documentary on ‘Muslim Brotherhood terrorist history'    Photo of Egyptologist Zahi Hawass to decorate NYC's Times Square to promote tourism to Egypt    Three incredible Egyptian athletes who challenged their disabilities    T. Jefferson Parker tells latest tale in tight, vivid prose    







Thank you for reporting!
This image will be automatically disabled when it gets reported by several people.





Putin's diplomatic triumph
Published in Al-Ahram Weekly on 19 - 05 - 2005

The Russian president made much political capital out of commemorations marking the 60th anniversary of the end of World War II, writes Immanuel Wallerstein*
Was it really United States President George W Bush who was the guest of honour at the celebration of the 60th anniversary of V-E Day in Moscow on 8 May, 2005? Did he really stand on Red Square next to Russian President Vladimir Putin to review goose-stepping Russian troops carrying hammer-and-sickle banners with the image of Lenin while Russian jets roared overhead?
I think the world press has underplayed the monumental character of this event. How is it that the major event of this 60th anniversary was celebrated in Moscow, and not in Washington, London, Paris, or anywhere else? How come everyone came?
By everyone, I mean the presidents of France, China, Israel, the prime ministers of Germany, Italy, Japan, India, South Korea, the secretary- general of the United Nations, and assorted other representatives of some 50 countries. The only major world figure not to come in person was the prime minister of Great Britain (too busy perhaps with salving his wounds after a narrow electoral victory that was less than glorious). Also missing were top echelon figures from North Korea (perhaps anxious not to be forced into a meeting on the side of the six-nation group discussing nuclear armaments).
Furthermore, Putin rubbed salt into the wounds of the US. He took the opportunity to give an interview to the US press criticising US world policy, and more important to have a summit with leaders of the European Union in order to sign four "roadmap" accords on the economy; freedom, security, and justice; external security; and research, education, and culture. This follows the 11 April accord with Germany on economic cooperation in eight major areas including nano- and bio-technologies and oil and gas transportation. And since Jacques Chirac also came and stood at Putin's right (while Bush was at his left), Putin accompanied Chirac to inaugurate the monument to Charles De Gaulle.
The US press made much of the fact that three countries refused to come to the celebrations (Estonia, Lithuania, and Georgia), and that President Bush sandwiched his trip to Moscow with a visit before to Riga (where he met the presidents of the three Baltic states) and one after to Georgia, where he gave fire-eating speeches about democracy and received the crowd's cheers for being critical of Putin and Russia about both the present and the past. Why then did Bush go to Moscow at all? In November 2001, Putin visited Bush in Crawford, Texas, and Bush famously talked of trusting Putin, because he "looked him in the eyes". In May 2005, Bush got into Putin's somewhat ancient private automobile and drove Putin around, both of them with broad smiles on their faces, so that every photographer could see how close they were. What's the point of all of this?
This is old Cold War technique on both sides. The US was using lots of rhetoric about freedom, but the bottom line is to do nothing, just as the US used rhetoric to denounce the Soviet repression in Hungary in 1956 and in Czechoslovakia in 1968 but essentially did nothing. The US did nothing then because they needed the Soviet Union to keep the lid on nuclear conflict. And today, despite Bush denouncing the Yalta accords, the US still needs Russia. But there is one difference. In the Cold War days, the Soviet Union also needed the US. So they too used a lot of rhetoric but essentially did nothing. Today, however, the US needs Russia more than Russia needs the US. It's no longer such a balanced equation.
That the US needs Russia today will be a surprise to most Americans but not to analysts elsewhere in the world. The US needs Russia for a lot of things. It needs Russia so that it wouldn't be diplomatically isolated in the world as it currently is. It needs Russia not to move too close to France and Germany. It needs Russia not to give so much support to Iran. It needs Russia to cooperate on various intelligence matters. One has to say that it is not getting very much along any of these lines from Russia. What does Russia need from the US? Well, the one thing it doesn't really want is to start up an expensive arms competition, once again. The US keeps threatening this. The question is does it have the money to do it, really?
Well, one can say the US also wants to gain diplomatic and political support among the countries of the former Soviet Union. That's true. And these countries are often ready to play the game. But they want more than words. And the question is, how far is the US ready to go in Georgia to get Russia to withdraw its troops. In the end Saakashvili needs to come to terms with Putin, not with Bush. And Bush will continue to put Putin ahead of Saakashvili. It's a question of priorities.
Of course, both Bush and Putin have to worry about their home audiences. Hence the rhetoric, especially on the side of Bush. But those who really want some anti-Russian action in the United States are already getting wary of Bush -- all talk and not much action. And money, money, money!
On 10 May, the Ottawa Citizen in Canada had a political cartoon which sums up the situation: It shows a diminutive Bush walking beside an extremely tall Putin. Bush's head only reaches the top of Putin's legs. And he is saying: "Wow... I can still see into your soul from here, Vladimir!" Putin, who no doubt is having some trouble at home these days, is compensating by doing quite well in the geopolitical arena. As an old KGB officer, he must be smiling a sweet smile.
* The writer is director of the Fernand Braudel Centre at Binghamton University (SUNY), New York.


Clic here to read the story from its source.