NDB expands to 11 members, raises $16.1bn in 2024, says Rousseff    Egypt, Somalia leaders discuss strategic partnership, counterterrorism in New Alamein    Egypt, UNDP discuss expanded cooperation on medical waste management, human development    CIB finances Giza Pyramids Sound and Light Show redevelopment with EGP 963m loan    EGX closes mixed on July 7th    Gold retreats as investors await tariff clarity    Egypt, UNDP discuss future health projects – Cabinet    Egypt calls for stronger central bank cooperation, local currency use at BRICS summit    Egypt's PM, Uruguay's president discuss Gaza, trade at BRICS summit    Egypt's Talaat Moustafa Group H1 sales jump 59% to EGP 211bn    Egypt, Uruguay eager to expand trade across key sectors    Egypt accelerates coastal protection projects amid rising climate threats    Deadly Israeli airstrikes pound Gaza as Doha talks raise hopes for ceasefire    Egypt, Norway hold informal talks ahead of global plastic treaty negotiations    Greco-Roman tombs with hieroglyphic inscriptions discovered in Aswan    Global tour for Korean 'K-Comics' launches in Cairo with 'Hellbound' exhibition    Egypt teams up with private sector to boost university rankings    Egypt reveals heritage e-training portal    Three ancient rock-cut tombs discovered in Aswan    Egypt condemns deadly terrorist attack in Niger        Egypt's EHA, Schneider Electric sign MoU on sustainable infrastructure    Sisi launches new support initiative for families of war, terrorism victims    Egypt expands e-ticketing to 110 heritage sites, adds self-service kiosks at Saqqara    Egypt's EDA joins high-level Africa-Europe medicines regulatory talks    Egypt's Irrigation Minister urges scientific cooperation to tackle water scarcity    Palm Hills Squash Open debuts with 48 international stars, $250,000 prize pool    Egypt's Democratic Generation Party Evaluates 84 Candidates Ahead of Parliamentary Vote    On Sport to broadcast Pan Arab Golf Championship for Juniors and Ladies in Egypt    Golf Festival in Cairo to mark Arab Golf Federation's 50th anniversary    Germany among EU's priciest labour markets – official data    Cabinet approves establishment of national medical tourism council to boost healthcare sector    Egypt's PM follows up on Julius Nyerere dam project in Tanzania    Egypt's FM inspects Julius Nyerere Dam project in Tanzania    Paris Olympic gold '24 medals hit record value    A minute of silence for Egyptian sports    Russia says it's in sync with US, China, Pakistan on Taliban    It's a bit frustrating to draw at home: Real Madrid keeper after Villarreal game    Shoukry reviews with Guterres Egypt's efforts to achieve SDGs, promote human rights    Sudan says countries must cooperate on vaccines    Johnson & Johnson: Second shot boosts antibodies and protection against COVID-19    Egypt to tax bloggers, YouTubers    Egypt's FM asserts importance of stability in Libya, holding elections as scheduled    We mustn't lose touch: Muller after Bayern win in Bundesliga    Egypt records 36 new deaths from Covid-19, highest since mid June    Egypt sells $3 bln US-dollar dominated eurobonds    Gamal Hanafy's ceramic exhibition at Gezira Arts Centre is a must go    Italian Institute Director Davide Scalmani presents activities of the Cairo Institute for ITALIANA.IT platform    







Thank you for reporting!
This image will be automatically disabled when it gets reported by several people.



'Fraud, not freedom'
Published in Al-Ahram Weekly on 03 - 05 - 2007

An Administrative Court ruling prohibiting Copts who had converted to Islam from returning -- officially at least -- to their original faith has provoked uproar, reports Gihan Shahine
A Cairo Administrative Court ruling last week that the Ministry of Interior is not obliged to issue new identity documents for 45 Coptic Christians who converted to Islam and then decided to return to their original faith has sparked a heated public debate. Many Copts lambasted the ruling as discriminatory, and a violation of basic human rights and freedom of the creed enshrined in the constitution.
Coptic human rights activist Naguib Gabriel, involved in several reconversion cases, characterised the ruling as "unprecedented and regressive". It marked, he said, "a black day in the life of Copts".
Anba Daniel, bishop of the Maadi and Maasara diocese, argued the ruling "contradicts all principles of democracy, human rights and citizenship". Both Gabriel and Anba Daniel linked the ruling with Article 2 of the constitution which enshrines Islamic Sharia as the main source of legislation in Egypt.
"Had this article been abolished during the recent constitutional amendments, we would not be facing the dilemma we are in today," said Gabriel. "All talk of equal citizenship has been rendered meaningless by this ruling which exposes the kind of religious state in which we are living."
A majority of Islamic scholars, however, say there is no compulsion in religion under Islamic Sharia law. They point to the 2006 Administrative Court ruling allowing two young Coptic women, whose father had converted to Islam when they were infants, to retain their original religious identity. The court declared that it was "not in any way acceptable that the civil authorities take advantage of their influence to force the plaintiffs to embrace Islam". The same court, under presiding Judge Farouk Abdel-Qader, ruled in favour of 45 other cases of reconversion to Christianity in June 2006. This time, however, it seems the court did not view the issue as one of freedom of the creed, but rather as manipulation of religion.
Gabriel told Al-Ahram Weekly that most of those converting to Islam and wishing to return to their original faith were not doing so out of "any religious conviction". Rather, says Gabriel, they were seeking to resolve personal status dilemmas. Some were Coptic men seeking to marry Muslim women; others were Christians seeking a divorce. Yet others had converted, in an attempt to change their official identity to avoid indictment in minor criminal cases.
The Coptic Church rarely grants divorce, and allows divorcees to remarry only under very strict conditions. These include a marriage being terminated due to adultery or one partner converting to another religion. "I was very unhappy with my marriage and a friend told me that the only way out was to convert to Islam," one man told the audience on Dream 2 satellite channel. When he obtained a divorce, the man said he had returned to his original faith but has been unable to record his reconversion officially.
This television confession sparked outrage among many guest speakers on the programme. "This is an issue of fraud not freedom," thundered journalist Magdi Mehanna. "The issue is very serious: such people are playing with fire and use these issues to receive foreign assistance. The church should intervene to solve their social problems."
Another guest speaker, lawyer Mokhtar Nouh, agreed with Mehanna, arguing that the whole issue had been "blown up to pressure the regime to abolish any reference to Sharia in the constitution -- which has nothing to do with the real issues". Former head of the State Council Amin Mahdy points to several similar rulings, passed in 2001, 1982 and 1984, noting that they had passed almost unnoticed among Copts. Coptic thinker Rafiq Habib insists that the most recent ruling "should not have sparked all this anger on the part of Copts" since "it is totally unacceptable for people to use religion and claim they belong to a certain creed, simply to solve personal dilemmas".
Gabriel, though, remains concerned with the "uncertain fate" of 350 petitioners seeking to revert to their original Christian identity on official papers. Among such cases, says Gabriel, are children of fathers who converted to Islam when they were infants, and who now want to regain their religious identity as Christians, in order to sit for exams or get married. "There are also those nearing death and who are panicking that they will be unable to be interred in Coptic cemeteries without official papers proving they are Christian."
According to unofficial estimates, out of the 350 cases, 100 converted to Islam in order to obtain a divorce, 70 embraced Islam to marry a Muslim spouse and 50 changed their Coptic identity to avoid indictment in minor criminal cases such as forgery.
Habib does not preclude the possibility of court rulings in favour of the plaintiff, in future cases of reconversion. "The recent ruling, after all, did not say that the law prohibits converts from returning to their original faith though the judiciary, perhaps, wanted to send a message that it would not allow people to manipulate religion for their own ends." Gabriel, though, argued it is not "the court's business to look into the reasons why people converted. Courts should just apply the laws and principles of the constitution."
Gabriel deplores the judge "using his own interpretation of Sharia, essentially branding those reverting to their original faith as apostates -- something which may constitute a threat to their lives."
Gabriel claims that it is easier for Copts to convert to Islam than the other way round, since "Muslims wishing to embrace Christianity would automatically be considered apostates".
Mohamed Hamed El-Gamal, former head of the State Council, told the Weekly he believes the court should have granted the defendants the right to record their original faith on official papers, since it is not in the national interest to create such a fuss over the issue. He agrees with Gabriel that it is beyond the mandate of administrative courts to look into the reasons why people are converting.


Clic here to read the story from its source.