Would the global trade come to a standstill as supply chain crisis worsens?    EBRD vice president heads delegation to Egypt to discuss new country strategy    The unvaccinated prohibited from entry to Egypt state institutions starting December 1    Egypt, Cyprus sign deal for electricity grid link    Russia to lift COVID restrictions on flights to Egypt's Red Sea resorts on Nov. 9    Egypt, Greece ink deal for first subsea power link between Europe and Africa    Egypt hosts regional conference of EU refugee agency EASO    SCOHRE sparks discussion on harm reduction, tobacco control    Egypt to receive first of six high-trains from Spain's Talgo in mid-November    Egypt's iron and steel exports jump 197% in 8 months    Ethiopia halts work at its embassy in Egypt for 'economic reasons'    It's a bit frustrating to draw at home: Real Madrid keeper after Villarreal game    Russia says it's in sync with US, China, Pakistan on Taliban    Shoukry reviews with Guterres Egypt's efforts to achieve SDGs, promote human rights    Sudan says countries must cooperate on vaccines    Over 100 officials resign from Tunisia's main Islamist party    Johnson & Johnson: Second shot boosts antibodies and protection against COVID-19    Egypt to tax bloggers, YouTubers    Egyptian court bans use of mosques for political purposes    Brazil calls up 8 EPL players for World Cup qualifying    Refugees in fear as sentiment turns against them in Turkey    We mustn't lose touch: Muller after Bayern win in Bundesliga    Egypt records 36 new deaths from Covid-19, highest since mid June    Egypt sells $3 bln US-dollar dominated eurobonds    Sisi calls on House, Senate to commence second legislative sessions on 3, 5 October    Huawei Technologies has invested $10 mln over 5 years in innovation centres in Egypt    Gamal Hanafy's ceramic exhibition at Gezira Arts Centre is a must go    Italian Institute Director Davide Scalmani presents activities of the Cairo Institute for ITALIANA.IT platform    Qa'a play showing at Lycee El Horreya Theatre, Alexandria is a must go    Orange Egypt Introduces Amazon Prime Video    Tokyo Olympics: Cautious opening ceremony, shy start for Egyptians in competitions    Mallawi Museum in Upper Egypt holds recycling workshop for children during Eid Al-Adha    Egypt keen on stable tax policies to attract more investors: Finance Minister    Sudan declares state of emergency as water goes beyond Merowe Dam capacity    Niagara Falls illuminated in Egyptian flag to mark 23 July Revolution anniversary    Capital flows into EM keep recovering after March 2020 slump: Central Bank of Egypt    1 child orphaned every 12 seconds due to COVID-19-associated death: World Bank    Egypt, Japanese Olympic Committee discuss boosting sports cooperation    US emphasises AU's role in mediating Ethiopian damdispute    Ethiopia ready to resume dam talks with no legally binding agreements: Ethiopian official    Sunken city of Thônis-Heracleion in Egypt's Abu Qir bay yields new archaeological treasures    New films, concerts, and destinations for Eid Al-Adha holidays    Egypt, Oman discuss enhancing bilateral economic, investment relations    Al Ahly v Kaizer Chiefs: Cairo giants eye 10th CAF Champions League title    Tunisia hopes to have a UN role in resolving Egypt-Ethiopia dam dispute    APO Group enters new exclusive agreement with Getty Images on African press releases and images    On International Museum Day, Egypt opens two new museums at Cairo Airport    Old Cairo's Al-Fustat will be revamped on Egyptian President's directives    







Thank you for reporting!
This image will be automatically disabled when it gets reported by several people.



Obstacles to reconciliation
Published in Ahram Online on 14 - 09 - 2021

Egyptian commentators say there has been no significant breakthrough in the resumption of Egyptian-Turkish relations. Two exploratory rounds of negotiations have been held in the last four months, one in Cairo in May, the second in Ankara in the first week of September. The meetings convened at deputy foreign minister level, with Hamdi Loza heading the Egyptian delegation and Sedat Önal the Turkish delegation. The protocols and agenda were much the same in the two rounds.
In interviews with Bloomberg, Egyptian Prime Minister Mustafa Madbouli and Foreign Minister Sameh Shoukri underlined three important elements in assessing the progress of the talks and their future prospects.
Most important is Turkey's involvement in Libya. It is clear that Turkey is not taking serious action on two core requirements of the Berlin Process: the removal of the mercenaries and foreign fighters Turkey introduced into the country, and the reduction of Turkey's own military presence in western Libya. A plan to implement these points was discussed in the second Berlin Conference and provided for phased, proportionally reciprocal withdrawals by both Russia and Turkey. It was never put into effect.
Cairo supports the position of the Libyan 5+5 Joint Military Committee (JMC) on this issue. The JMC, an output of the first Berlin Conference, maintains that the continued presence of mercenaries and foreign forces threatens the Libyan political process. Turkey continues to cite the agreement it struck with the former Tripoli-based Government of National Accord (GNA) as grounds to maintain its military presence until a new, elected government comes to power and determines the fate of the agreement. Ankara's refusal to implement its obligations under the Berlin process naturally affects prospects for the resumption of relations with Cairo which has been working to help restore stability to Libya.
The second element is the timeframe Madbouli mentioned. Madbouli has said Egyptian-Turkish relations could be restored by the end of the year if outstanding issues are resolved. As upbeat as the statement sounds, it implies a process of confidence building. And Libya, where elections are scheduled for mid-December, will be the main testing ground. Will Turkey alter its policies so as to smooth the pathway to that crucial juncture?
Madbouli's belief that exploratory talks cannot go on indefinitely appears to be shared by the Turks might be thinking along the same lines. In remarks to Turkish media, Turkish Foreign Minister Mevlut Cavusoglu indicated that progress needs to be made in the talks before the two sides are in a position to exchange ambassadors.
The third element is political will. How strong is Cairo's and Ankara's resolve to normalise relations? According to the closing statement of the last meeting, the two sides agreed to continue consultations and affirmed their desire to achieve progress "to facilitate the normalisation of bilateral relations". Foreign Minister Shoukri also told Bloomberg that Cairo was "keen to find a solution" and reach a formula for restoring normal relations.
It is clear that Cairo's foreign policy outlook differs from Turkey's. Cairo's vision for regional stability is one in which all countries of the region attain their interests through peaceful political practices. It is the antithesis of the militarised foreign policy adopted by non-Arab regional powers in the past decade. The latest application of the Egyptian foreign policy outlook is to be found in the Egyptian-Iraqi-Jordanian cooperation mechanism that emerged from the Baghdad Conference for Cooperation and Partnership in August. This tripartite mechanism was established as a fulcrum for regional development and the realisation of the participants' mutual interests. One of the lessons it offers is that diplomacy is a more effective way for countries to attain their interests than militarisation, whether through conventional means such as building military bases abroad or unconventional means such as transporting mercenaries and other irregular foreign fighters to assist proxies in other countries.
Egypt's official statement also mentioned Iraq, Syria and Palestine, all of which fall within the scope of Egypt's immediate national security. It is no coincidence the three countries were singled out by name. Egypt's relations with all three have grown significantly closer, and Egyptian gas will soon pass through Jordan to Syria and from there to Lebanon. The increasing realm of shared interests between Egypt and its neighbours in the Levant can only bear fruit in a stable climate, and that requires Turkey to change its foreign policies and attitudes towards the region.
A major outstanding concern is Turkey's continuing harbouring of the Egyptian Muslim Brotherhood. Will Turkey agree to extradite suspects wanted on security-related charges? The isuue was raised before the last meeting, but so far no information is available. The Turkish authorities are likely to hand over a few individuals implicated in criminal cases but for the most part will refuse Egypt's demand, arguing that the charges are "political". A related issue is the Muslim Brotherhood affiliated media in Turkey which Egyptian authorities say Ankara promotes. An anti-Egyptian message also persists in Turkish state media, even though some of the more vocal pundits have softened their tone or had their volume temporarily muted.
What is motivating Turkey to restore its relations with Egypt to normal? Turkish investments in Egypt have not been significantly affected by the intergovernmental friction. Most observers believe that Ankara's shift in its relations with Egypt is driven by domestic discontent arising from President Recap Tayyip Erdogan's crisis-generating policies which have isolated Turkey as never before, both in the West and the Arab region.
Others point to Ankara's desire to cooperate with Egypt over arrangements in the Eastern Mediterranean. Turkey claims that the maritime boundary it drew in the Eastern Mediterranean does not harm Egypt. Whether or not this is the case, Egypt's allies, Cyprus and Greece, have objected to the unilaterally imposed boundary that Ankara based on an MoU with an interim government in Tripoli. Ankara needs to understand that any normalisation in Egyptian-Turkish relations will not come at the expense of the Egyptian-Greek-Cypriot alliance.
Egypt made this clear when the Cypriot president came to Cairo to participate in a meeting of the bilateral intergovernmental committee in the week preceding the second round of Egyptian-Turkish exploratory talks. During the visit Egypt reiterated its position on the dispute Turkey precipitated with Cyprus and Greece. Egypt opposes Ankara's unilateral imposition of a maritime border and its provocative drilling activities in areas Greece and Cyprus claim fall within their territorial waters. International law and legitimacy, the respect for other nations' sovereignty and non-intervention in others' domestic affairs must remain the governing principles of international relations.
It appears that, despite some cautious optimism, contacts between Egypt and Turkey have not moved beyond the "exploratory" and "testing" phase. It is also too soon to assess the results of this phase. Still, it is an important step in the much-needed efforts to reduce regional tensions and end the cycle of conflict.

*A version of this article appears in print in the 16 September, 2021 edition of Al-Ahram Weekly


Clic here to read the story from its source.