Louvre, France's most visited museum plans to re-open its doors in early July    Ethiopia passes supplementary budget to help absorb virus impact    Egypt's health ministry using app, drug deliveries to follow up with coronavirus patients isolating at home    AC Milan president opposes plan to restart with Cup matches    Russian league to allow soccer fans in stadiums    UEFA to fasttrack competitions in one venue, says Getafe president    European head of WTO would be "wonderful" says EU trade chief    Sudan army officer dies, soldiers hurt in attack by Ethiopian militia: SUNA    New report alleges killings, mass detentions in Ethiopia    'It's like a return to life', despite an empty auditorium: Paris orchestra plays Strauss in COVID-19 era    Twitter attaches disclaimer to Trump's Minneapolis tweet for 'glorifying violence'    South Korea seeks to import anti-viral remdesivir as new virus cases emerge    Egypt's enemies try to discredit state's anti-pandemic efforts, achievements: Al-Sisi    Maait aims to turn Covid-19 plight into power to promote human resource development    Ethiopia says it won't accept Egypt's ‘historic rights' to Nile water    Minneapolis mayor calls for arrest of police officer who knelt on George Floyd's neck    Al-Sisi ratifies financial, technical cooperation agreements with Germany    Spain says it will do all it can to reverse Nissan closure, workers protest    Salah did not pressure administration to include players on team: Ghazal    Huawei CFO loses key court fight against extradition to US    UK PM Johnson to go to Brussels next month for Brexit talks    How did Egypt use the internet during Ramadan?    Egypt removes 484 illegal constructions and encroachments on Nile    Health Ministry urges retired medical staff to join coronavirus fray    173 illegal constructions on waterways in Damietta referred to military prosecution    China approves Hong Kong security law as tensions with U.S. rise    MACIC celebrates World Day for Cultural Diversity with webinar    Grand Museum receives 346 artefacts from Old, Middle Kingdoms    Unique late Ancient Egyptian cemetery discovered in Minya Governorate    European football set to restart despite coronavirus    Budget airlines put squeeze on airports in coronavirus cost drive    Afrobeat, rap, house and more: Apple Music is launching its first radio show in Africa    AfDB approves $500,000 in emergency coronavirus pandemic aid for Egypt    Egypt's stock Exchange back to regular trading hours on Sunday    Dubai government offices to resume work with 50% employees next Sunday, 100% on June 14    Disney unveils plans to reopen in mid-July    WHO: There is no evidence hydroxychloroquine helps treat coronavirus    Egypt confirms record jump of 910 coronavirus cases on Wednesday    Sisi congratulates Egyptians on occasion of Eid Al-Fitr    Egypt's Sisi congratulates Egyptians on the occasion of Eid El-Fitr    Egypt's interior ministry gives gifts to families of policemen killed or injured in the line of duty    Egyptian police kill 21 terrorists who plotted attacks on Eid El-Fitr    Italy's football federation sets August 20 as deadline for finishing season    Egypt's decision to resume sports activities breathes life into hopes to restart league    Egyptian Premier League final decision to be taken before May-end: minister    Egypt's 12 MPs came into contact with coronavirus infected parliamentarian    iRead launches new activities, competitions to pread the passion for reading    British Council in Egypt makes its digital library for free amid coronavirus    

Thank you for reporting!
This image will be automatically disabled when it gets reported by several people.

Water effects of the dam
Published in Ahram Online on 24 - 03 - 2020

In April 2011, Ethiopia announced its intention to proceed with the construction of the Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam (GERD) on the Blue Nile in the Benishangul-Gumuz region of the country about 30km from Ethiopia's border with Sudan. The main purpose of the dam is to generate electricity, with an expected capacity of 6,000 MW.
Egypt and Ethiopia have yet to reach an agreement on the specifications of the dam, the rules for filling its reservoir, the rates at which the stored water will be used for energy production or irrigation, and how to manage the operations of the dam and the amounts of water it releases in coordination with downriver dams. Nevertheless, Ethiopia has announced that the dam will go into operation at full capacity in 2022, making it the largest energy producer in Africa.
Egypt, with available water resources of 610 m3 per capita as of 2019, is among the countries that fall below the water poverty line that the UN has estimated at 1,000 m3 per capita. Egypt also suffers from a large food-production deficiency, forcing it to import about 55 per cent of its current food needs. This figure is expected to climb to 75 per cent after the GERD is complete because of the huge quantity of water held back during the filling of the reservoir, which has an estimated capacity of 74 billion m3 of water.
Ethiopia has said that it plans to fill the dam in only three years. That would cut 25 to 33 billion m3 from Egypt's annual quota of Nile water which, in turn, would yield a five to six billion acre loss in cultivable land given Egypt's climatic conditions and the current average of 5,000 m3 of water that the Ministry of Agriculture allots per acre of agricultural land. Even if the filling period of the dam were doubled to six years, that would result in a 12 to 17 billion m3 reduction in the amount of water that reaches Egypt. That too would be difficult for Egypt to sustain, as it would put about 1.5 acres of land out of cultivation.
Egypt is expected to fall even further below the UN water poverty line due to population growth on top of the reduction in the flow of Nile water to the country after the construction of the GERD. By 2022, the per capita quota will decline to 409 m3, bringing Egypt to the point of water paucity. If Egypt is to lose quantities of water equivalent to the GERD's reservoir capacity due to the filling of the dam, which could come to 67 billion m3 at full capacity, then it needs to know about both the quantity and the timing in advance so that it can take the appropriate precautions in order to avert a severe water crisis when the dam first goes into operation.
Hydrology experts are also worried by the mere size of the GERD's reservoir, which is situated in an earthquake zone. They warn of catastrophic damage to Sudan and Egypt in the event of seismic movement and the effect of the enormous weight of water and silt behind the dam.
Egypt wants the initial filling period of the reservoir to be spread out over ten years with allowances made for years of drought. Addis Ababa had initially insisted on three years, and Egypt then proposed to increase these to five. However, more recently, a new impasse reared its head when Ethiopia refused to sign a draft agreement prepared by the US acting as an intermediary in the negotiations on the dam.
Some analysts believe that a dam with such a huge reservoir capacity is not in Ethiopia's interests and that its purpose is primarily political and serves the interests of outside powers. They say a series of smaller dams would better serve Ethiopia's energy and agricultural needs. Smaller dams would cover a wider area more efficiently and cost-effectively, make it possible to optimise the use of the high levels of rainfall on the Ethiopian Plateau, and increase the quantities of stored water. The experts also believe that mega-dams are not suited to the geological circumstances of the GERD due to tremors, the nature of the subterranean bedrock, and other environmental factors.
It is hoped Nile Basin countries will realise before it is too late that regional cooperation is a safer, more cost-effective, and more peaceful way to realise their sustainable development goals than unilaterally pursuing mega-projects that threaten their neighbours' welfare.

The writer is an associate professor of economics at Cairo University.
*A version of this article appears in print in the 26 March, 2020 edition of Al-Ahram Weekly

Clic here to read the story from its source.