Trump upbeat on Johnson's idea of new Iran deal    Egypt's Sisi discusses regional developments with Italy's premier    Ramadan Sobhi fires Ahly to a winning start in the Egyptian League    Egypt seeks to spread 100 Million Health campaign to African countries: Sisi at UN meeting    Egypt's Rowad Modern Engineering renovates 40% of Manial Palace    Thomas Cook operator in Egypt says 25,000 bookings cancelled following bankruptcy    Egypt media regulator says BBC site 'likely blocked' due to 'inaccurate coverage' of limited protests    Trump Asia expert to become deputy national security adviser    Israel's Arab party support pushes Gantz ahead of Netanyahu    European markets slip after world's most well-known tour operators collapse    Ethiopia to commission Chinese-built 254 MW hydro dam    UK's Johnson believes Iran was behind Saudi oil attacks    Volume of trade exchange between Egypt, China hits $7.69 billion in seven months    The party will decide our Brexit position, says UK Labour's Corbyn    Egypt climbs nine spots in Tourism Competitiveness Index rankings    Gold prices steady amid Gulf tension, trade talk uncertainties    UN agency: Tanzania not sharing details on Ebola-like cases    Valverde worried by Barca's limp away form after Granada defeat    Baby gut study finds bacteria different after C-section births    Live score: Arsenal v Aston Villa (English Premier League)    Zamalek president Mortada Mansour talks Egypt's Super Cup, unveils reasons behind defeat    Grand Egyptian Museum's construction works 93% complete    Egypt's Health Ministry bans all ranitidine medicines    El Gouna Film Festival celebrates 100th birth anniversary of novelist Ihsan Abdel-Quddous    FIPRESCI and Netpack hosted by El Gouna Film festival for the first time    Small protests in Egypt dispersed by police    Ahly wins Egyptian Super Cup after beating Zamalek    Rare protests in Egyptian streets after online call for dissent    Egypt's tuk-tuk start-up Halan to tap Ethiopia before year-end    Cairo Opera hosts closing ceremony of the Cairo International Festival for Contemporary and Experimental Theatre    Allianz Egypt allots $399K to promote UNICEF's vulnerable children initiative    Felix Brych to referee Ahly-Zamalek Super Cup game in Egypt's Alexandria    'Egypt will not allow any country to impose its will on another in Ethiopian dam issue,' FM says    Egypt, Ethiopia at odds as talks over Blue Nile dam resume    Egypt's FM hopes for deal as new round of GERD talks kicks off    Egypt's PM discusses details of Al-Hussein Mosque renovation    Court sentences six to death, 41 to lifetime imprisonment violence related case    Trump says he would release Mideast peace plan after Israeli elections    ACWA Power compares 3 bids to supply production units for Luxor power station    What do you know about gold alloying?    NBE announces EGP 2.5m prizes for handball youth teams for their world achievements    Jennifer Lopez evokes Egyptian outrage post her North Coast performance    Al-Sisi honours Egypt's scholars on Science Day    IS claims responsibility for suicide bombing killing 63 in Afghan wedding    Political parties gear up for parliamentary, senate, local elections    Unprecedented Glory: Egypt win Men's U-19 World Handball Championship    12th National Egyptian Theatre Festival fuel up public theatre art scene    Ministry of Environment has a plan for "black clouds season"    







Thank you for reporting!
This image will be automatically disabled when it gets reported by several people.





Nasser and the '67 defeat'
Published in Ahram Online on 02 - 02 - 2019

A group of interested young people gathered around me after I took part in a panel discussion at the Cairo International Book Fair. One of them brought up the subject Egypt's defeat in the 1967 War, a defeat that has been used to issue a blanket condemnation of the Nasser period as the “age of defeats” and to cast the Sadat era into relief as the age of the October War victory.
I replied, “never in history has there been a leader whose career was an unbroken chain of victories. Even the prophets won some battles but lost others. Napoleon's career ended in military defeat and exile.
But French history and, indeed, world history is not just about that last chapter in the life of that commander who changed the face of Europe and spread his influence to most of the world, just as Nasser changed the face of the Arab world and spread his influence across most of the Third World.”
If we want to assess the Nasser or Sadat experience, or that of any other leader, we have to examine it as a whole. If we home in on a single event, our evaluation is likely to be biased and unscientific.
If, for example, I wanted to condemn the Sadat era, I might say that he was responsible for the spread of the religious fanaticism and terrorism that we face today because he encouraged Islamist political leaders out of the belief that he could use them to counter the leftists.
Eventually, their power increased as their influence spread through a society in which minds were vulnerable to their rhetoric and ruses due to a lack of appropriate education and awareness.
Then, they turned against Sadat and assassinated him, just as they had assassinated dozens of politicians before. But I asked my interlocutor, would our assessment of Sadat be fair or objective if we considered only that aspect? What about the victory in the 1973 War? How could we ignore that? In like manner, if we focused only on that victory, we would be overlooking the isolation that Egypt endured during Sadat's time.
By the end of his rule, Egypt's relations had been severed with the majority of other Arab states, whereas it was precisely from its leadership of the Arab region that Egypt had acquired its weight in the international arena.
Egypt's relations were also broken with the Soviet Union and the countries of Eastern Europe. At one point it seemed that Egypt's membership in the Non-Aligned Movement would be suspended, even though it was a founding member of that bloc of Third World nations.
The 1967 War ended in a devastating military defeat. Nasser owned up to his responsibility and resigned. Nasser asked the late Mohamed Hassanein Heikal to write his resignation speech. Heikal related that the original text read, “I bear my share of the responsibility,” and that Nasser took out his pen and wrote instead, “I bear all responsibility.”
The important question now is what Nasser did after the masses across the Arab world refused to accept his resignation.
Did he continue to govern with the same policies and means as before? In answer to the people's demand that he remain in power, Nasser vowed to make necessary changes. His first step was to dismiss officials who had contributed to making the defeat possible.
Foremost among these was the head of the intelligence agency which Nasser, himself, had described as a state within the state. Salah Nasr, whom some regarded as the epitome of the corruption that had spread through government, was dismissed, brought to trial and sentenced to prison.
The same occurred to the heads of many ministries, especially the Ministry of Information. These dismissals signalled the beginning of a new era.
The biggest change in the post-1967 era occurred in the army which, under the command of Field Marshal Abdel-Hakim Amer, had sustained enormous losses in troops and materiel.
Nasser's pledge to “eliminate the effects of the aggression” was not a hollow slogan. It was a political act that was manifested in the sweeping changes that were introduced into the armed forces at three levels. The first was in the nature of the troops themselves.
Until then, the armed forces were primarily drawn from poor peasants and workers who did not have the “pull” to escape the draft. Henceforward, recruitment would include graduates from universities and other higher educational institutions. The second was at the level of armaments. Nasser concluded a series of arms deals with the Soviet Union that would more than compensate for the weapons lost and that would also equip our forces with much more modern arms. The third change took place at the level of training.
This occurred in a practical way during the War of Attrition, which began with the sinking of the Israeli destroyer Eilat. The War of Attrition lasted a full year during which Israel sustained more losses than it had during the June 1967 War, leading the US to step in with the Rogers initiative. The ensuing ceasefire, in turn, gave Nasser the breathing space he needed in order to build a missile wall in order to protect the Egyptian interior. By the time Nasser died, a fourth element was in place: the plan for the crossing of the Suez Canal. That plan, conceived by General Mohamed Fawzi and codenamed Granite, would serve as the basis of the 1973 October War.
Lastly, we should not forget Nasser's communique of 30 March in which he laid out his future vision for a new political life characterised by a scope of civil freedoms considerably larger than existed under his two successors. Unfortunately, death intervened, taking him from Egypt at the age of 52 before he could see all these commitments through.
The 1967 War was not just a military defeat. It was also an important moment in which Egypt and the Arab world were jolted out of slumber. Perhaps some of the most important victories are those wrenched from the ruins of defeat.
* A version of this article appears in print in the 31 January, 2019 edition of Al-Ahram Weekly under the headline: Nasser and the '67 defeat'


Clic here to read the story from its source.