SIS lambastes BBC over posting report against Al-Sisi    Metito Egypt, Orascom Construction to develop EGP 1.8bn wastewater treatment plant in New Alamein City    Al-Sisi asserts Egypt's keenness on boosting relations and cooperation with Switzerland    UK's May: Parliament support too low for 3rd Brexit vote    For first time: rocket hits central Israel, wounding 7 people    Egypt halts trial online exams after severe problems    Lebanon says US Golan decision undermines peace    USAID administrator visits Egypt, praises religious pluralism    Egypt MPs give comments on proposed constitutional amendments in internal dialogue    Egypt's Sisi discusses economic, military cooperation with Chinese defence minister in Cairo    Forgiveness: The Secret of Peace    Alganesh: finding hope in abyss    Private sector's participation in implementation of Egypt's Vision 2030 should be increased: Cityscape    USAID, local partners discuss development of Egypt's livestock production systems    Thousands of visitors line up to explore Tutankhamun's life    On pleasing audience: Mahmoud Hemeda gives acting masterclass during Luxor African Film Festival    Two smuggled statues retrieved from Switzerland    Expanding services in oil sector is essential to maximising value: Petroleum minister    Zimbabwe confirm death of fan before Cup of Nations qualifier    Ethiopian Airlines CEO promises to get to bottom of flight 302 crash    Southgate says youngsters will handle hostile Montenegro atmosphere    Tennis: Djokovic beats Delbonis, stays on track for seventh Miami title    Egypt's Parliament expected to conclude dialogue over constitutional amendments in April    Not German Christian Democrats    Gap between rich, poor in Egypt shrinking, middle class doing worse: LSE Director    Euro 2020 qualifying: Germany look to emulate neighbors in period of evolution    Irrigation Minister asks Egyptians to be ‘more concerned' over water scarcity    Jadon Sancho is the type of player England has and Germany wants    Passengers airlifted from cruise ship stranded off Norway    Pope accepts resignation of Chilean cardinal accused of covering up abuse    Meet Egypt's youngest female football coach    Tutankhamun goes to Paris    Disney closes $71B deal for Fox entertainment assets    International Universities to start its next academic year in the New Capital    Darts for all    Greta    To be continued    A Broken Window play is the latest at Taliaa Theatre, don't miss it    Mustafa Al-Razzaz's art is on show at the Gezira Arts Centre    Don't miss Asmaa Waguih's photography show at the AUC Photographic Gallery    New horizons    Diaa Rashwan    Christchurch terror    Another year for Syria?    National dialogue begins    Egypt parliament provisionally approves bill on protecting personal data    Uganda releases 14 Egyptian expats after embassy intervention    Right man for the right job    







Thank you for reporting!
This image will be automatically disabled when it gets reported by several people.





After tribal clashes, is Sinai militancy turning into proxy war?
Tribes coordinate with the army in fighting extremists, according to military source
Published in Daily News Egypt on 20 - 05 - 2017

At least 13 people were killed from the tribe of Al-Tarabin, including Salim Abu Lafi, a prominent leader of the tribe, in the recent clashes that occurred in the south of Rafah last week between the Al-Tarabin tribe and the extremist group Sinai Province––previously known as Ansar Beit Al-Maqdis—which joined the Islamic State in 2014, according to tribal sources.
The clash was not the first of its kind. Two years ago, a similar fight broke out in Al-Barth market, which is controlled by the tribe of Al-Tarabin, where militants affiliated to Sinai Province killed a member of the tribe on the pretext that he was working with the Egyptian army.
Al-Tarabin responded by killing a militant and preventing others from passing, closing the market until there was a reconciliation agreement between them and calm returned. Later, clashes broke out after tribal elders announced a war against Sinai Province and called for members of the tribe to take up arms and help Egyptian security forces in the war against the militant group.
In the beginning of May, Al-Tarabin announced the alleged killing of eight militants from Sinai Province in clashes with its members, while two tribesmen were injured. The clash between the two sides came after a woman was killed and her husband and two of her sons were kidnapped from Rafah two weeks ago by militants suspected to be from Sinai Province.
Moreover, on 24 April, Al-Tarabin allegedly burned a militant alive, which was shown in a leaked video. The video showed members of the tribe burning a man believed to be a militant affiliated to Sinai Province.
In return, militants beheaded locals accused of collaborating with the Egyptian armed forces, and they recently stepped up their attacks against the peninsula's Christian minority, forcing hundreds to flee following a string of killings in Al-Arish in February.
On Monday, another prominent Sinai tribe, Al-Sawarka, declared war on Sinai Province and asserted its support to the Egyptian armed forces in the battle against the militants. Also announced was the formation of a central joint leadership for the tribes in order to coordinate with the armed forces and change the rules of engagement.
"Al-Sawarka was at the forefront of the battle against extremists since the military started the battle; and the first civilian martyrs were from Al-Sawarka," the tribe said in a statement.
Al-Sawarka announced that it will rely on media mobilisation, which will be run by experts belonging to the tribes, and establishing an official institution to support the families of the ones killed or injured with stable funding.
In 2015, Al-Tarabine called for a arming the tribes during the conference of Sinai tribes union for supporting the armed forces
(Photo from Sinai Tribes)
"The collaboration between the military and tribes is not new, and there is a department in the Egyptian General Intelligence that deals with tribal affairs," Al-Tarabin spokesperson, Mousa Al-Delh, told Daily News Egypt. "36 tribal leaders had been killed by terrorists after being accused of collaborating with the army," he added.
Al-Delh added that tribes in North Sinai have been fighting extremists since 2015, but due to the ensuing controversial discussions about arming tribes, Al-Tarabin stopped the fight and "the cooperation was limited to providing the army with information."
He explained that "the extremist group launches its operations in terrain that is very tricky to maneouvre in, which makes fighting in it very difficult. We [the tribes] know the region very well; it is the place in which we live."
"We are not alone. There are other tribes fighting alongside Al-Tarabin against the terrorists, such as Al-Sawarka and Al-Remailat," Al-Delh said.
Rejecting accusations of fighting for their own interests, Al-Delh said, "we are not fighting for personal gain, nor for smuggling. We are officially fighting beside the armed forces."
When asked about the tribe's weapons, he refused to talk about the source through which they receive them, but he asserted that arms are only to be used for self–defence and that all forms of weapons will disappear after defeating the terrorists and clearing Sinai from all extremist forms.
A military official, who spoke on condition of anonymity, told Daily News Egypt that tribes are coordinating with the military in the battle against extremists. He further asserted that "the situation [in Sinai] is under control."
Sinai tribes have a long history of collaborating with the armed forces. One of these situations was during the Israeli occupation of Sinai after the 1967 War, when the tribes refused suggestions and talks by Israeli occupation forces to separate Sinai from Egypt. Another example is when tribes assisted the Egyptian intelligence apparatus in the process of gathering information.
Salem Abu Lafi (wearing a cap)
(Photo from Sinai Tribes)
Military expert Khaled Okasha expressed his concerns and rejection to arming Sinai tribes, and he described tribal claims about the coordination with the armed forces as a "media trick". The army does not need any help from the tribes, he added.
"It's a conflict over [Sinai's] fortune and power" between militant groups and Al-Tarabin, which erupted almost two years after the group had killed a member of the tribe and Al-Tarabin killed a militant. The conflict had partially ended with conciliation between the tribe and the terrorists, Okasha explained.
In 2015, Al-Tarabin called for arming tribes during the Sinai Tribes' Union Conference for supporting the armed forces, but the call had failed because the conference was convened by Al-Tarabin. Other tribes, such as Al-Remailat and Al-Sawarka, refused to mandate Al-Tarabin to lead the tribal scene, according to the military expert.
In contrast to Okasha's perspective, another military expert, Abdel Rafe' Darwish, welcomed the coordination between the armed forces and some Sinai tribes in fighting extremist groups. From his point of view, Darwish believes that flexibility is needed in such a situation and that "necessity knows no law. The Syrian regime cooperates with the Lebanese militia of Hezbollah to fight extremists," Darwish told Daily News Egypt.
He had no concerns or doubts about arming tribes because he believes that "they will hand their arms over to the army after defeating terrorists."
Mousa Al-Delh
Prominent British writer Robert Fisk said in an article published in the Independent on 4 May that "the Egyptian army is following the same contaminated path as many of its neighbours, by using a killer-militia in its war against Isis in Sinai."
Most armies have "proxy allies" who can act as informants, such as the Syrians, the Iraqis, the Turks, and the Israelis when they co-opted with their own Lebanese militias between 1976 and 2000, and the Americans in Iraq. All ended up shamed by the cruelty of their supposed allies, Fisk explains.


Clic here to read the story from its source.