Elders, campaigners dominate scene in Kerdasa polling stations    What do experts think about celebrations in front of polling stations?    Egyptians cast votes on last day in referendum    Turnout in Egypt's referendum doubled nationwide on Monday: International observers    Egypt's Sisi meets Sudanese head of National Intelligence and Security    250 archaeological missions from 25 countries work in Egypt: Minister    Tottenham focused on Brighton and not Ajax, says Pochettino    President instructs enhancement of MSMEDA activities    Saudi security forces arrest 13 accused of planning attacks: SPA    Egypt, Somalia seek bilateral cooperation    CIB-Egypt establishes representative office in Ethiopia    Bundesliga: Bayern Munich turn the screw in a reminder of champions past    The main differences between Catholics and Protestants    Spring Affair Returns for Second Season of Shopping, Charity    Tod's bring back Alber Elbaz to Fashion Scene    ACUD, Petroleum Ministry ink deal to provide government district with natural gas    Karlovy Vary to honour cinematographer Vladmir Smutny    Youssef Chahine remembered at Karlovy Vary    Cannes festival reveals short film collection    Voting in 3rd day of referendum on constitutional amendments going on normally, says NEA    Volume of trade exchange between Egypt, China jumped to USD 13.8 bn in 2018    Mbappe's title, but PSG need to breathe new life into Qatari project    Iraq says any action to raise oil output won't be unilateral: Ministry spokesman    Sudan's military council warns against road blocks as protests continu    Palace have no intention of selling 'happy' Zaha, says Hodgson    Egyptians cast ballots in 3rd and last day of referendum voting    Trade exchange between Egypt, Tunisia to increase to $500m    Airstrikes hit Tripoli, Mitiga airport reopened    Al-Sisi receives Abbas, voices support for Palestinian legitimate rights    Egypt considers establishing freight, maritime transport company with Africa    Cairo Copts celebrate Palm Sunday    Chess world champion Magnus Carlsen wants to keep winning streak going    New attack on Ebola center in Congo; 1 militia member killed    Sleep myths may hinder good sleep and health    The final draft    Towards the referendum    Sudanese demand ‘legitimate change'    Caught in the middle?    Escaping expenses    ‘I don't want sympathy'    Expected exit    Spectacular scene, favourable draw    Flight prices go sky high    Reining in inflation    Bundeli Kala Parishad troupe's Indian folk dance show at Al-Gumhouriya Theatre is a must go    Paris' Notre Dame    Screen blues    Vatican willing to offer technical know-how to help restore Notre-Dame    

Thank you for reporting!
This image will be automatically disabled when it gets reported by several people.

Bedouins open new front
Published in Al-Ahram Weekly on 06 - 05 - 2015

The announcement by the Tarabin, the largest of Sinai's bedouin tribes, that they would enter the fight against terrorism alongside the government and against Ansar Beit Al-Maqdis, changes the course of the battle that erupted following the fall of the Muslim Brotherhood. Sinai's tribes have mostly tried to remain neutral in the hope of avoiding the wrath of a terrorist organisation that murders tribal members it has accused of cooperating with security agencies. It was a situation that could no longer be tolerated, Abdallah Jahama, a leading Tarabin tribal member, told Al-Ahram Weekly.
Many Sinai bedouins view the development as an awakening triggered by the broadening of clashes between Ansar Beit Al-Maqdis and Sinai's larger tribes. Others, however, say the “transformation” has been exaggerated and “doesn't merit the commotion it has caused in the press” says Ahmed Sweirki of the Sawarka tribe, Sinai's second largest. A third body of opinion believes the Tarabin announcement is an extension of tribal customs. Abdallah Mubarak, also from the Sawarka tribe, points out that “tribal law does not tolerate any assault against the tribe, even by its own members. Should this occur, the tribe strips that member of its protection and regards him as an outcast.”
The Tarabin initiative is not the first of its kind. In July last year, the Romeilat tribe announced that it was contemplating forming brigades to take revenge against terrorists after Ansar Beit Al-Maqdis killed a number of tribal leaders. Army officials quickly discouraged the initiative, insisting no party could bear arms on behalf of the state. This time, however, the government's response appears more favourable, though it has not openly showed support.
The development raises numerous questions. What prompted the Tarabin to make the move? Does the government, the military or military intelligence in Sinai have anything to do with it? Have precise scenarios of the potential repercussions emanating from this step been worked out? Is there a degree of hyperbole surrounding the development? Is the initiative the work of one branch of a large tribe that is connected with the government and is lending itself to propaganda efforts? What are the responses of other Sinai tribes to the Tarabin announcement? Will this be a prelude to similar declarations from them? Are Sinai's tribes, increasingly frustrated at the government's inability to defeat the militias, taking revenge into their own hands? Who will arm the Sinai tribes for the battle? Will the government agree to them taking up arms?
The story began with a statement posted on a social networking site announcing that the Tarabin had decided to join the fight against Ansar Beit Al-Maqdis. Abdallah Jahama, a prominent member of the Tarabin and the tribe's official spokesman, questioned the authenticity of the statement though he did not dispute its substance. “[The tribes] will not remain silent in the face of the terrorist organisation. They will support the state in its confrontation against it,” he said, without indicating the nature of that support. “There is agreement with the president and the army command on this matter.”
No sooner had the statement been publicised than Ansar Beit Al-Maqdis added its signatories to its hit list. It struck first at Ibrahim Al-Arjani a prominent businessman from the Tarabin, bombing his home for supporting “the army of apostates.” They then hijacked his car after murdering one of his assistants, and went on to broadcast threats against other leading members of the tribe.
Special interests: General Alaa Ezzeddin, director of the Armed Forces Centre for Strategic Studies, argues that the
initiative represents the confluence of several motives. There is, he says, an ongoing blood feud between the Tarabin and Ansar Beit Al-Maqdis. There is also an outpouring of patriotism from some members of the Tarabin, especially those connected with the government. “I cannot say whether this patriotism aspect applies to all,” says Ezzeddin, but it is an important factor.
Ezzeddin dismisses the possibility that the new director of military intelligence has plans that include a role for bedouin tribes. “There has been no change of strategy. The military commander listens to his men and to a large number of advisors around him, and then takes the decisions he believes are right. No one in the military would condone the creation of a bedouin militia.”
Interestingly, Ibrahim Al-Arjani told Al-Ahram Weekly that the Tarabin will soon delineate their tribal territory which is to be “free from terrorism”. This suggests a bid to establish a Tarabin “province” in northern Sinai.

A useful and temporary alliance: Military expert Talaat Musallam frames the issue differently. “In view of current developments and the entrance of the tribes into the picture, coordination — a temporary alliance between the tribe and the state — is likely. The tribes have weapons. They do not need the government to supply them with more and they know that the government would not do so. Developments on the ground in Sinai all point to the same thing, that Sinai's tribes cannot remain on the side-lines when terrorist organisations are targetting tribal leaders.”
He added that “if there is one thing the government and the tribes agree on, it is the fight against terrorism. The tribe is there, licensed to carry arms, and undertakes actions in the framework of tribal customs that benefit the state. Five people have already handed themselves in to the Tarabin in accordance with tribal custom. They receive guarantees for their safety in exchange for leaving the terrorist organisation on condition, of course, that they were not involved in acts of violence. I believe that the Tarabin want to cooperate with the government because the tribe's existence and reputation are at stake.”
The Tarabin may have taken up the banner of cooperation but how do Sinai's other tribes fit in? There are at least 10 major Sinai tribes. The Sawarka, which consists of at least 13 clans, has a record of good relations with the government, not least during the 1973 War. The third largest tribe is the Masaeed, followed by the Samaena, Saadiyin, Bayadiya, the Akahrsa, Abaida, Romeilat, Riyashat and Howeitat.
According to a reliable source from the Sawarka it is difficult to predict which other tribes will join the Tarabin initiative. The tribes are extensive groupings consisting of clans, each with their own sheikh and elders. He expects the conference that the Tarabin is convening in Al-Hasana next week “to settle the question of whether or not there will be a tribal alignment.”

Clic here to read the story from its source.