EGP declines vs. USD at Thursday's close    Euro area inflation rises to 2.0% in October '24 – flash estimates    IF YOU LOVE SOMEONE WHO SMOKES, GIVE THEM THE FACTS    Asian stocks slide as chip sector weakens    Egypt's Minister of Environment highlights biodiversity issues at COP16    Egypt's Agriculture Minister meets Syrian, Bahraini counterparts to boost cooperation in Amman    Al-Qassam Brigades targets Israeli vehicles in eastern Gaza    ACUD, DP World, and GAFI sign MoU to develop free zone in New Capital    Egyptian government encourages increased mutual investment with Bahrain: Finance Minister    A Tale of Two Cities: Alexandria hosts 2nd edition of exhibition celebrating Greek, Egyptian cultural ties    Egypt, Djibouti leaders discuss strengthening ties, regional issues    Egypt's FM affirms commitment to Sahel security, offers support to Niger    Egyptian banking sector support underprivileged communities in Alexandria – CBE    Afghanistan signs $163m deal for cement plant    US tightens tech investment rules for China    Biden unveils $3b investment to strengthen US port infrastructure    Military Production, Environment Ministers inaugurate banana fiber recycling plant    Luxor Museum to host exhibition on 19th century antiquities inspection tours    Nourhan Kamal Wins 2024 Helmi Sharawy Award for African Studies    Egypt observes Intl. E-waste Day, highlights recycling efforts    Egypt's military capabilities sufficient to defend country: Al-Sisi    Al-Sisi emphasises water security is Egypt's top priority amid Nile River concerns    Cairo Opera House hosts grand opening of Arab Music Festival, Conference    Grand Egyptian Museum ready for partial trial run on October 16: PM    Colombia unveils $40b investment plan for climate transition    Kabaddi: Ancient Indian sport gaining popularity in Egypt    Ecuador's drought forces further power cuts    Al-Sisi orders sports system overhaul after Paris Olympics    Basketball Africa League Future Pros returns for 2nd season    Egypt joins Africa's FEDA    Paris Olympic gold '24 medals hit record value    A minute of silence for Egyptian sports    Paris Olympics opening draws record viewers    Who leads the economic portfolios in Egypt's new Cabinet?    Financial literacy becomes extremely important – EGX official    Motaz Azaiza mural in Manchester tribute to Palestinian journalists    Russia says it's in sync with US, China, Pakistan on Taliban    It's a bit frustrating to draw at home: Real Madrid keeper after Villarreal game    Shoukry reviews with Guterres Egypt's efforts to achieve SDGs, promote human rights    Sudan says countries must cooperate on vaccines    Johnson & Johnson: Second shot boosts antibodies and protection against COVID-19    Egypt to tax bloggers, YouTubers    Egypt's FM asserts importance of stability in Libya, holding elections as scheduled    Egypt records 36 new deaths from Covid-19, highest since mid June    We mustn't lose touch: Muller after Bayern win in Bundesliga    Egypt sells $3 bln US-dollar dominated eurobonds    Gamal Hanafy's ceramic exhibition at Gezira Arts Centre is a must go    Italian Institute Director Davide Scalmani presents activities of the Cairo Institute for ITALIANA.IT platform    







Thank you for reporting!
This image will be automatically disabled when it gets reported by several people.



Good News Bad Timing
Published in Almasry Alyoum on 10 - 01 - 2009

This is a piece of good news that got lost amid the cascade of bad news throughout the past two weeks. It came out on the same day the aggression on Gaza started, which is why no one noticed it.
The news says that the Supreme Administrative Court, headed by the State Council Vice-President Ismail Seddik, on Saturday, December 27 ruled to refer Article VI of the martial law to the Supreme Constitutional Court for suspicion that it is unconstitutional.
 
That article authorizes the President to refer any case to the military courts, even if the accused were all civilians, and even if the case had nothing to do with the armed forces.
The martial law is the Code of Criminal Procedure for the military. It regulates the trial procedures of the military that commit criminal offenses during their service, whether by themselves or with civilians. They are quick and decisive procedures due to the nature of the armed forces being a firm institution that can defend the country.
 
The sentences issued by military courts are usually severe and stipulate the maximum penalty once it is settled in the conscience of the judges that the accused is guilty.
 This is what made Abdel Fattah el-Tawil Pasha, the Minister of Justice in the Wafd Party Cabinet before the Revolution, reject a proposal to refer the accused in the case of the fraudulent arms to a military court, although the case had to do with supplying these weapons to the armed forces during the war in Palestine, and although the defendants were from the military as well as civilian.
 Tawil told the person who suggested this: “Have mercy! These courts give the death penalty if someone lost a button of his uniform.”
The government has several times used the emergency law that allows referring civilians to military courts. It happened with the communists in 1959 and 1961. Also, there were courts with civilian and military judges.
But the martial law was amended in 1966 when there was no state of emergency. This made the legislators add Article VI so as to allow the executive power to refer civilians to military courts, even in the absence a state of emergency.
Based on that suspected article, many military trials of civilians took place. Field Marshal Mohamed Fouad el-Degwi was the most famous judge to preside over these courts, while Mustafa Amin, Sayed Qutb and Shoukri Mustafa were the most famous defendants.
When President Mubarak came to office, his government froze that article for years, but then decided to use it again in the face of the frightening escalation of terrorism in the mid-nineties. And the military courts since then issued many death sentences for the terrorists.
 
The abolition of Article VI has been a top priority for the opposition parties that have been calling for democracy. They also demanded the independence of prosecutors and the abolition of the social prosecutor, the Moral Court, the State Security Court as well as all other forms of special courts.
Independence of the judiciary can be achieved only away from any political and religious biases. And defendants have the right to appear before their normal competent judge.
Each time civilians were referred to military courts, their defense appealed to the State Council Administrative Court based on the same argument. Yet the Court used to reject such appeals.
 
It was a surprise that the Court for the first time accepted the appeal regarding Mohamed Khairat el-Shater», the Muslim Brotherhood Deputy Guide, and 40 others, who were referred to a military court on charges of belonging to an illegal organization and of money laundry.
 The court ruled in favor of the appeal. And when the government challenged the ruling, the Court decided on December 27 to refer the matter to the Supreme Constitutional Court for suspicion of Article VI.
If the Supreme Constitutional Court says the article in unconstitutional, the defendants will be retried before a normal court.
This will deter the government, unless it comes up with the Counter-Terrorism Act that allows referring defendants in cases of terrorism to any type of court.
This is a piece of good news in these bad times. It tells the depressed like me that there is still hope.


Clic here to read the story from its source.