BP signs agreement to drill five new gas wells in Mediterranean within its Egypt concessions    Turkish president holds sideline meetings with world leaders at Egypt summit    S&P Global Ratings upgrade signals renewed confidence in Egypt's economy: CBE Governor    Finance Ministry announces exceptional tourism investment opportunities in Assiut    Al-Sisi, Meloni discuss strengthening Egypt–Italy relations, supporting Gaza ceasefire efforts    Al-Sisi, Merz discuss Gaza ceasefire, ways to deepen Egypt–Germany relations    Gold prices in Egypt extend modest gains on Monday, 13 Oct, 2025    EGX closes in green area on Monday, 13 Oct, 2025    URGENT: Trump arrives in Egypt for Sharm El-Sheikh summit, escorted by Egyptian F-16s    L'Oréal Egypt's 10th summit draws over 800 experts, focuses on dermatology    Egypt's central bank issues EGP 5b FRN T-bonds    URGENT: Netanyahu skips Sharm El-Sheikh peace summit for holy reasons    URGENT: Egypt's Sisi to award Trump highest honour for Gaza peace efforts    Ministers of Egypt، Slovakia sign MoU on environmental protection، climate change    Egypt's Sisi warns against unilateral Nile actions, calls for global water cooperation    Egypt unearths one of largest New Kingdom Fortresses in North Sinai    Egypt's Health Minister showcases Women's Health Initiative at Berlin Innovation Forum    Egypt unearths New Kingdom military fortress on Horus's Way in Sinai    Egypt Writes Calm Anew: How Cairo Engineered the Ceasefire in Gaza    Egypt's acting environment minister heads to Abu Dhabi for IUCN Global Nature Summit    Egyptian Open Amateur Golf Championship 2025 to see record participation    Cairo's Al-Fustat Hills Park nears completion as Middle East's largest green hub – PM    Egypt's Cabinet approves decree featuring Queen Margaret, Edinburgh Napier campuses    El-Sisi boosts teachers' pay, pushes for AI, digital learning overhaul in Egypt's schools    Egypt's Sisi congratulates Khaled El-Enany on landslide UNESCO director-general election win    Syria releases preliminary results of first post-Assad parliament vote    Karnak's hidden origins: Study reveals Egypt's great temple rose from ancient Nile island    Egypt resolves dispute between top African sports bodies ahead of 2027 African Games    Egypt's Al-Sisi commemorates October War, discusses national security with top brass    Egypt reviews Nile water inflows as minister warns of impact of encroachments on Rosetta Branch    Egypt's ministry of housing hails Arab Contractors for 5 ENR global project awards    A Timeless Canvas: Forever Is Now Returns to the Pyramids of Giza    Egypt aims to reclaim global golf standing with new major tournaments: Omar Hisham    Egypt to host men's, juniors' and ladies' open golf championships in October    Germany among EU's priciest labour markets – official data    Paris Olympic gold '24 medals hit record value    It's a bit frustrating to draw at home: Real Madrid keeper after Villarreal game    Russia says it's in sync with US, China, Pakistan on Taliban    Shoukry reviews with Guterres Egypt's efforts to achieve SDGs, promote human rights    Sudan says countries must cooperate on vaccines    Johnson & Johnson: Second shot boosts antibodies and protection against COVID-19    Egypt to tax bloggers, YouTubers    Egypt's FM asserts importance of stability in Libya, holding elections as scheduled    We mustn't lose touch: Muller after Bayern win in Bundesliga    Egypt records 36 new deaths from Covid-19, highest since mid June    Egypt sells $3 bln US-dollar dominated eurobonds    Gamal Hanafy's ceramic exhibition at Gezira Arts Centre is a must go    Italian Institute Director Davide Scalmani presents activities of the Cairo Institute for ITALIANA.IT platform    







Thank you for reporting!
This image will be automatically disabled when it gets reported by several people.



Of merits and demerits
Published in Al-Ahram Weekly on 08 - 05 - 2008

MIXED MESSAGES FOR FILM INDUSTRY: Questions over political motives behind the awards at last week's National Festival for Egyptian Cinema and a decision by the head of the Actors Union to limit opportunities for Arab actors in Egyptian films have focused attention on what has sometimes seemed a beleaguered industry, while a Paris tribute to the career of French film producer Humbert Balsan is drawing attention to the benefits of foreign cooperation in Egyptian cinema
Of merits and demerits
The National Festival for Egyptian Cinema closed last week with what seems to have been a set of politically motivated awards, writes Hani Mustafa
Merit is supposed to be the main criterion for the selection of the award-winning films at any film festival, though merit is sometimes not enough to reap the top awards.
Festivals are seldom free of political or other messages sent out by the organisers or by members of the jury. In 1997, for example, the special golden jubilee award of the Cannes Film Festival went to Youssef Chahine for what French actress Isabelle Adjani said at the awards ceremony was his "courageous stand" against Islamist activists who had attacked Chahine over his film Al-Muhajir (The Emigrant), a fictionalised version of the biblical story of Joseph.
Also at Cannes, in 2004 the Palme d'Or went to American filmmaker Michael Moore for his documentary Fahrenheit 9/11, which vehemently attacked the US administration over the invasion of Iraq one year before.
Both theseawards were designed to send out clear messages independent of the artistic merit of the films concerned, and theNational Festival for Egyptian Cinema, which closed last week, is no exception to any other festival in respect of the desire among organisers and jury members to make statements through the choice of prize-winning films
The film that reaped the festival's five top prizes, for example, was Heen Maysarah (Until Better Times),gathering the prizes forBest Film, Best Director,Best Male Supporting Role,Best Female Supporting RoleandBest Set, and there is a suspicion that these accolades were prompted in large part by the fierce debate this film has given rise to in the newspapers and on satellite TV channels.
Perhaps even more important has been the attack on the film from Islamist activists like Professor Abdel-Sabour Shahin, who was also instrumental in the hisbacase against the academic Nasr Hamid Abu Zayd in 1995, declaring his marriage null and void on the grounds that he had committed apostasy.
Upon the release of Heen Maysarah last year Shahin asked that an official investigation take place into all those involved in the film, accusing them of "promoting homosexuality and moral corruption." "American and Zionist hands" were behind the film and other works of the same sort, Shahin said, describing it as "deviant" and threatening social morality.
However, it has not only been Islamists who have attackedHeen Maysarah: the film, directed by Khaled Youssef and scripted by Nasser Abdel- Rahman, has been seen as oppositional enough for it to be attacked both by those who ally themselves with the regime and with those who are allied to the conservative Islamist opposition.
Though the film is certainly worth watching, it remains the case that it is primarily a kind of political statement, and this has been the source of the controversy and media interest that has swirled around it. In awarding Heen Maysarah the prizes for Best Film and Best Director, the festival jury was sending out a clear message against reactionary forces who want to curtail freedom of expression.
In dealing with the inhuman conditions suffered by people living in informal housing areas, Heen Maysarah also condemns living conditions in Egypt in general. Indeed, one of the film's drawbacks is that it offers a kind of panorama of all the problems that have been dealt with in the news recently, including street children, the ministry of the interior's handling of alleged Al-Qa'eda infiltration, and the use of torture and threats of rape during police interrogations.
Another film rewarded at the festival wasdirector Sherif Arafa's Al-Jazeera (The Island),which, though coming third in the Best Film category, received five other prestigious awards, including Best Actor (Ahmed El-Saqa), Best Actress (Hend Sabry), Best Cinematography, Best Special Effects and Best Score.
This film, viewed by many critics as one of the most artistically executed Egyptian films of 2007, also has political overtones. Depicting the real-life story of Ezzat Hanafy, an arms and drugs dealer who led a fierce struggle against the security forces in Upper Egypt, Al-Jazeera shows the rise and fall of a man who at one time had strong connections with people inside the security apparatus.
Hanafy was executed in 2006, after having been found guilty in a lengthy trial. The film about his life shows the alleged involvement of top-ranking police officers in creating such drugs barons. One of the characters in the film is a corrupt police officer who encourages the main character, played by Ahmed El-Saqa, to cooperate with the police in arresting suspected terrorists in return for the officer's turning a blind eye to his illegal arms and drugs trade.
There is also a love story between the character played by El-Saqa and a pretty woman, played by Hend Sabry, in Romeo-and-Juliet fashion. While El-Saqa deserves his prize as this is probably the best role he has played to date, the same cannot be said about the otherwise highly gifted Hend Sabry. This is not one of her best roles, and she was not the most deserving actress in the competition. Many would agree that Ghada Adel's role in Shaqat Masr El-Gedida (The Heliopolis Flat) far surpassed Hend Sabry's performance in Al-Jazeera.
It seems likely thatthe much-debated decision of the chairman of the Actors Union, Ashraf Zaki, to limit the participation of Arab actors in Egyptian productions had an influence on the jury's decision to give Hend Sabry the Best Actress award.
This decision, limiting the participation of Arab or foreign actors in Egyptian films, affects Sabry, since she is a Tunisian national and is therefore targeted by Zaki's gesture. This has been condemned by many in the cinema industry, including the minister of culture, Farouk Hosni, who is currently negotiating with the Union to reverse the decision.
Questions were raised in the entries in the festival's features category by the decision to exclude Youssef Chahine's Hiya Fawda (It is Chaos) from the running. Surely Khaled Saleh's performance in this film deserved an award? The political element in Hiya Fawda is not so very different from that found in Heen Maysarah, though Chahine's film presents the same problems in a more subtle way and is definitely more tightly scripted.
Perhaps members of the jury thought that Youssef Chahine should be excluded from the competition, or perhaps the film was not included because 90% of the film was directed by Khaled Youssef, and not by Chahine, who has been suffering from illness.
Whatever the case may be, there is no escaping the fact that at this year's festival political considerations were allowed to come at the expense of artistic merit.
Director Mohamed Khan's Shaqat Masr El- Gedida is a clear example of this since although this film received the Second Best Film award, it was far superior to Heen Maysarah.
Mohamed Khan and Ghada Adel also deserved the awards for Best Director and Best Actress, respectively.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Awards at the National Festival for Egyptian Cinema:
Best Film: Heen Maysarah
Best Actor: Ahmed El-Saqaa in Al-Jazeera
Best Actress: Hend Sabryin Al-Jazeera
Best Cinematography: Al-Jazeera
Best Screenplay: Shaqat Masr El-Gedida
Best Editing: Shaqat Masr El-Gedida
Best Set: Heen Maysarah
Best Score: Al-Jazeera
Best Special Effects:Al-Jazeera
Best Male Supporting Role: Heen Maysarah
Best Female Supporting Role: Heen Maysarah
Second Best Film: Shaqat Masr El-Gedida
Third Best Film: Al-Jazeera
Ghada Adel in Shaqat Masr El-Gedida


Clic here to read the story from its source.