Euro area GDP growth accelerates in Q1'25    Germany's regional inflation ticks up in April    Kenya to cut budget deficit to 4.5%    Taiwan GDP surges on tech demand    Germany among EU's priciest labour markets – official data    UNFPA Egypt, Bayer sign agreement to promote reproductive health    Egypt to boost marine protection with new tech partnership    Eygpt's El-Sherbiny directs new cities to brace for adverse weather    Cabinet approves establishment of national medical tourism council to boost healthcare sector    CBE governor meets Beijing delegation to discuss economic, financial cooperation    Egypt's investment authority GAFI hosts forum with China to link business, innovation leaders    Egypt's Gypto Pharma, US Dawa Pharmaceuticals sign strategic alliance    Egypt's Foreign Minister calls new Somali counterpart, reaffirms support    "5,000 Years of Civilizational Dialogue" theme for Korea-Egypt 30th anniversary event    Egypt's Al-Mashat urges lower borrowing costs, more debt swaps at UN forum    Egypt's Al-Sisi, Angola's Lourenço discuss ties, African security in Cairo talks    Two new recycling projects launched in Egypt with EGP 1.7bn investment    Egypt pleads before ICJ over Israel's obligations in occupied Palestine    Egypt's ambassador to Palestine congratulates Al-Sheikh on new senior state role    Sudan conflict, bilateral ties dominate talks between Al-Sisi, Al-Burhan in Cairo    Cairo's Madinaty and Katameya Dunes Golf Courses set to host 2025 Pan Arab Golf Championship from May 7-10    Egypt's Ministry of Health launches trachoma elimination campaign in 7 governorates    EHA explores strategic partnership with Türkiye's Modest Group    Between Women Filmmakers' Caravan opens 5th round of Film Consultancy Programme for Arab filmmakers    Fourth Cairo Photo Week set for May, expanding across 14 Downtown locations    Egypt's PM follows up on Julius Nyerere dam project in Tanzania    Ancient military commander's tomb unearthed in Ismailia    Egypt's FM inspects Julius Nyerere Dam project in Tanzania    Egypt's FM praises ties with Tanzania    Egypt to host global celebration for Grand Egyptian Museum opening on July 3    Ancient Egyptian royal tomb unearthed in Sohag    Egypt hosts World Aquatics Open Water Swimming World Cup in Somabay for 3rd consecutive year    Egyptian Minister praises Nile Basin consultations, voices GERD concerns    49th Hassan II Trophy and 28th Lalla Meryem Cup Officially Launched in Morocco    Paris Olympic gold '24 medals hit record value    A minute of silence for Egyptian sports    Russia says it's in sync with US, China, Pakistan on Taliban    It's a bit frustrating to draw at home: Real Madrid keeper after Villarreal game    Shoukry reviews with Guterres Egypt's efforts to achieve SDGs, promote human rights    Sudan says countries must cooperate on vaccines    Johnson & Johnson: Second shot boosts antibodies and protection against COVID-19    Egypt to tax bloggers, YouTubers    Egypt's FM asserts importance of stability in Libya, holding elections as scheduled    We mustn't lose touch: Muller after Bayern win in Bundesliga    Egypt records 36 new deaths from Covid-19, highest since mid June    Egypt sells $3 bln US-dollar dominated eurobonds    Gamal Hanafy's ceramic exhibition at Gezira Arts Centre is a must go    Italian Institute Director Davide Scalmani presents activities of the Cairo Institute for ITALIANA.IT platform    







Thank you for reporting!
This image will be automatically disabled when it gets reported by several people.



They won't take it lying down
Published in Al-Ahram Weekly on 20 - 04 - 2006

Judges vow to reply to what they say is the state's attempt to quash their pro-reform colleagues. Mona El-Nahhas reports
During an emergency meeting of the Cairo Judges Club held Tuesday evening, judges staged a sit-in to protest against the disciplinary measures the state intends to take against two pro-reform judges.
Other measures will be taken, the club board said, if the state "does not stop its aggression against honourable judges". The board asked President Hosni Mubarak to intervene, otherwise they warned "consequences will be very serious."
The meeting was held just two days after Justice Minister Mahmoud Abul-Leil ordered that judges Hesham Bastawisi and Mahmoud Mekki be referred to a disciplinary judicial council to decide whether they are qualified to continue their judicial career. If not, Bastawisi and Mekki, who are the Cassation Court's deputies of the chief justice, may be either dismissed or transferred to an administrative job.
The trial of the two judges before the council, which was Abul-Leil's decision taken in accordance with a request submitted by Prosecutor- General Maher Abdel-Wahed, will start on 27 April. The council is headed by judge Fathi Khalifa, chairman of the state-appointed Supreme Judiciary Council.
Khalifa, like many pro-government judges, has attacked reformist judges, describing them as a minority who harm the image of the judiciary.
Such criticism were reasons why judges argued Khalifa's chairmanship of the disciplinary council would not guarantee a fair trial for the judges.
The current judiciary law, which judges are struggling to amend, gives the justice minister the right to refer judges to a disciplinary judicial council if prosecution investigations prove they have committed flagrant violations.
For nearly a year, Bastawisi and Mekki have been leading a campaign to reform the judiciary. They have been pressing for the endorsement of a draft law prepared by the Judges Club since the early 1990s to replace the current judiciary law which curbs judiciary authority according to the majority of judges.
The new law aims at achieving total independence of the judiciary by separating it from the executive authority, represented by the Justice Ministry.
The two judges were also outspoken in revealing electoral fraud which marred last year's parliamentary and presidential elections. They filed several complaints to the prosecutor-general asking him to conduct an investigation into those responsible for the rigging. The names of several judges were included in the complaints.
Instead of investigating those suspected of rigging, Abdel-Wahed asked the permission of the judiciary council to question Bastawisi, Mekki and four other judges who revealed rigging practices.
The six judges were charged with harming the image of the judiciary after publishing in newspapers a blacklist including the names of judges who were suspected of taking part in the rigging of votes.
The Judiciary Council responded to Abdel-Wahed's request, however, investigations with the six judges have not yet begun, leading prominent judges to doubt the legitimacy of the minister's decree.
A lawsuit was filed before the administrative court to annul the minister's decree. His decision was viewed as offering clear-cut proof of the lack of true independence of the judiciary.
"If the judiciary were independent, the minister would not be able to interfere and discipline judges who do not follow orders," judge Ahmed Saber, a board member of the Cairo Judges Club, said.
The measures taken against Bastawisi and Mekki were also viewed as an insult to the judiciary and a prelude to a new massacre of judges reminiscent of the 1969 incident when nearly 120 judges were dismissed for political reasons.
"It doesn't matter if I lose my job so long as I don't lose my self-esteem and the people's respect for me," Mekki said concerning the minister's decree.
Bastawisi said the aim behind such measures was to silence judges and stop them from exposing electoral fraud. "Acting in this way, they hoped to give some sort of legitimacy to elections. And this will never happen," Bastawisi said.
He added that such irresponsible acts will do nothing but increase the current state of political rage and rekindle the conflict between the state and reformers.
The judges in question said the minister's decision was not surprising. "We expected from the very beginning that the state would do everything to resist real judicial reform," Bastawisi said, adding that their struggle for reform and independence will never stop.
Human rights groups, appalled at the minister's decree, warned of liquidating honourable judges.
A statement issued by the Arab Centre for the Independence of the Judiciary expected that other prominent judges, especially members of judges clubs' boards, will meet similar fates as that of Bastawisi and Mekki.
The statement described their case as a serious development which shows the state persecuting judges who are reform advocates.
The escalating tension provoked a storm of protest in the People's Assembly on Monday when nearly a fifth of MPs, the majority of whom belong to the Muslim Brotherhood, asked the People's Assembly speaker Fathi Sorour to question the justice minister. Sorour turned down the request, saying the People's Assembly should not interfere in the affairs of the judiciary which, he said, enjoys total independence.


Clic here to read the story from its source.