Egypt's Sisi discusses development projects with ministers    France reports 10,569 new daily COVID-19 cases    Protesters say localised lockdowns in Madrid discriminate against poor    Son Heung-min, Harry Kane shine as Tottenham beat Southampton in England    Italians vote in regional elections, referendum in test for coalition    Turkey may resume talks with Greece, warns against EU sanctions    'Political paralysis': Lebanese patriarch points at Shia leaders for cabinet delay    Virtual Emmy Awards set bar high with live telecast    Manchester United need better defenders to win Premier League, says Neville    Bale return will give Tottenham massive boost, says Murphy    Nile water levels continue to decline in Sudan after devastating floods: Ministry    Egypt's nominee is out of the race for WTO director-general    Cairo Ring Road to be expanded from 8 lanes to 14: Transport minister    Giza Plateau official denies rumours two highways are under construction at archaeological site    Kuwaiti NBK to launch Meeza prepaid cards in Egyptian market    Egypt's NEA announces results of Senate election run-offs    Climate theories on Sudan    Egypt's culture minister receives UNESCO registration of the Palm on List of Human Heritage    Egyptian insurance companies' premiums 9.6% up in five months    Egypt's President Sisi names new head of anti-corruption watchdog    Egypt's offers 18 bln pounds T-bills on Sunday    EgyptAir offering discounts for some international flights    Egypt records 212 new coronavirus cases, 14 deaths on Saturday    Egypt to require PCR coronavirus tests for airport travelers    Egypt sends 125 tonnes of glass by sea to Beirut    Legend Messi officially wants to leave Barcelona, hands transfer request    Global smartphone sales drop 20% in Q2, yet Apple's iPhone sales steady    Sisi: Egypt keen on establishing development projects with Iraq, Jordan    Egyptian megastar Amr Diab releases new hit music video    Making of Harry Potter will be available for fans at new park in Tokyo    Egypt's Senate elections official results to be announced Wednesday    Netflix Egypt is bringing megastar Amr Diab back with a new original    Egypt reopens Rafah border crossing for first time since April    Egypt's senate elections 2020 trending on social media in few days    African Champions League final will be played on Oct. 16-17, CAF says    No room to delay Egyptian Premier League games – EFA's board member    The Facebook Preacher's Search for Fame, and Egypt's Economy    Egypt calls on UNSC to address oil spill risks off Yemen coast    Egypt economically strong in face of COVID-19, reforms ongoing: International Cooperation Minister    Arafa Holding reports $144,000 COVID-19-related losses in April    Egypt's efforts in Libya to activate free will of Libyan people: Al-Sisi    Hyksos campaigns were internal takeover, not foreign invaders: study    COVID-19 affects Egypt sporting clubs    COVID-19 will soon turn to seasonal like swine flu: Presidential Health Advisor    ‘Egypt's Support' coalition convenes to discuss its Senate election list    Robbery attempt leads to discovery of Ptolemaic monuments in Qena    Flouting international guidance, Ethiopia unilaterally starts filling its Nile dam    Zaha speaks out after online racial abuse    

Thank you for reporting!
This image will be automatically disabled when it gets reported by several people.

Humanitarian aid vs political reform
Published in Ahram Online on 11 - 08 - 2020

Following last week's explosion in Beirut Port, state estimates showed that Lebanon needs from $10 to $15 billion to rebuild damaged areas. The donors conference arranged by French President Emmanuel Macron collected only 253 million Euros ($298 million) in humanitarian aid.
Those who offered support during the conference include global institutions such as the International Monetary Fund, World Bank, UN bodies and the European Union. For countries, the list includes African, Asian, North American and European states.
Lebanon, therefore, is living a social and economic nightmare the concluding act of which remains unknown. The blast left 300,000 people homeless and 200 others dead. The number of those injured reached 6,000.
But Lebanon experts believe that domestic politics is the reason behind the reluctance of international actors to offer further backing to Lebanon.
Robert Rabil, former chief of emergency for the Red Cross in Beirut, told Al-Ahram Weekly that he doesn't think that Lebanon is “going to have now more than humanitarian aid till reforms are made”.
“You are not going to have big reconstruction, but instead individual fixing of homes. This is not the kind of reconstruction where you see billions of dollars poured in. This is because of the absence of faith in government,” Rabil, now a political science professor at Florida Atlantic University, said.
He said that people count on “each other” to fix homes, which is why it is “going to take time”.
The Lebanese people, he explained, depend on money coming from relatives, people in the diaspora — including those who work in Arab states such as Saudi Arabia and Kuwait — and millionaires and billionaires who also live abroad and transfer cash to the country.
Lebanon has recently seen a huge deterioration in local conditions. The Lebanese pound has lost around 60 per cent of its value against the dollar and the country has a debt-to-GDP ratio of more than 150 per cent.
Thousands of business owners are suffering in the import-based economy and more than a third of the population of six million is jobless. A garbage crisis, continuous power cuts and increases in the prices of basic goods such as bread are also present. As well as coronavirus.
After the explosion, members of parliament and the ministers of justice, information and environment — in addition to top diplomat Nassif Hitti, who resigned ahead of last week's tragedy citing the absence of an effective will to achieve “comprehensive structural reform which our society and the international community have urged us to do” — officially left their posts.
Hizbullah-backed Prime Minister Hassan Diab resigned Monday afternoon, gaining caretaker status till a new cabinet is formed. All of these developments were taking place amid anti-government protests, which turned violent and saw clashes between security forces and demonstrators.
Deen Sharp, an expert who works for the Washington-based Middle East Institute, said that donors are “walking into a political minefield and they must be attentive to where they tread”.
“What entity in Lebanon should receive money? There is no easy answer to this question. Lebanon desperately needs humanitarian aid but it does not need aid that just fills the boots of the elite that put them in this crisis in the first place,” Sharp said.
He noted that all donors have to understand the “highly complex political geography of Lebanon and recognise that the narrow elites that created this mess will target any incoming aid revenues as new streams of money they can tap into”.
Lebanese elites have refused any reform and they are likely to even refuse to undertake the minimal conditions set by the IMF, Sharp stressed.
Almost all donors seem to understand this message clearly. For example, USAID said Sunday that $15 million in assistance will go to medical authorities at the American University in Beirut and the American Lebanese University.
Even before the explosion, many of Lebanon's old friends were not ready to back it due to the fact that Hizbullah is in power: the premier is supported by the group, and Parliament Speaker Nabih Berri and President Michel Aoun are its allies.
UAE Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs Anwar Gargash said in June that “Lebanon is partly paying the price” of “a deterioration of Lebanon's Arab relations and Gulf relations over the past 10 years”.
On Sunday, Saudi Foreign Minister Prince Faisal Bin Farhan said that, “the continued destructive hegemony of the terrorist organisation Hizbullah worries us all, and we all know this organisation's history of using explosive materials and storing them among civilians in several Arab and European countries and in north and south America.”
Diab's coalition had mainly counted on Hizbullah and allies of the Shia, pro-Iran armed group. Saad Al-Hariri, a pro-West Sunni leader and head of the Future Movement, refused to form a coalition late in 2019 with Hizbullah after both sides failed to reach an agreement.
The strongly anti-Hizbullah Christian Lebanese Forces Party and Druze leader Walid Jumblatt's Progressive Socialist Party also followed Al-Hariri's path. Hence, Hizbullah and Aoun nominated Diab to replace Al-Hariri.
Leader of the Christian Lebanese Forces Party Samir Geagea called for early parliamentary elections Monday, while Diab — ahead of his resignation — said he will stay in office for two months till reforms are made.
Yet, Rabil said that, “I myself have lost complete faith in all warlords and all those who constitute the majority of the political system”, seeing the need for an international investigation to look into “what really happened” in the blast, while unsure whether the government will allow it.
Rabil sees Lebanon is divided between two camps. While the first represents civil society that “needs help from outside”; the second involves all political forces, including the 14 March Coalition led by Al-Hariri and the 8 March Coalition led by Hizbullah.
“This is not two camps, but one camp. Despite some opposition to Hizbullah, throughout the years, this mafia gives political cover for Hizbullah, and Hizbullah covers their corruption. How can civil society compete against them? For me, this is really difficult,” he said.
Secondly, Rabil explained that thousands of Berri's and Hizbullah's members work in state institutions. “Where do you think the parliament speaker gets his power? It's because of Hizbullah,” he said.
“Given the history of Lebanon's party politics, if elections are held, a good number of people will vote for Jumblatt, Hizbullah and others. This is a very huge problem.”
Rabil thinks that Hizbullah is “stronger than the state”, having no doubt that it is going to be in the next parliament. “I don't mind this, but not with a majority, so Hizbullah has the final say in decision-making,” he argued.
Hizbullah, according to a Reuters report, has 12 MPs in the 128-seat parliament. But, when adding those independent MPs and those affiliated to parties who back it, the Shia group ends up having the support of at least 70 MPs.
“All of them means all of them” was the main slogan for protests against all political forces in Lebanon last year that erupted when Al-Hariri was still in power.
The same slogan has been reportedly used again during ongoing protests in the streets of Beirut.
So far, Egypt has sent three planes carrying aid to Lebanon including, according to the military, “large quantities of medical supplies and foodstuffs.”
Clothes are also part of Egypt's aid package to Lebanon.
The Egyptian Embassy in Lebanon said a plane carrying 14 tons of medical aid and flour was sent, the latter to support bakeries and keep bread production in place.
After the port explosion, Lebanon was left with less than a month in reserves of grain.

*A version of this article appears in print in the 13 August, 2020 edition of Al-Ahram Weekly

Clic here to read the story from its source.