Second generation reforms needed    The IT solution on growth    Industrial to residential    EU hopes Boris Johnson wins in UK polls big to get Brexit over with    Trump is fourth U.S. president to face impeachment as Democrats announce charges    Turkey will retaliate against U.S. sanctions, says foreign minister    Lampard keen to strengthen Chelsea's attack in January    Europe shares open mixed as investors await Fed decision, U.S.-China trade news    Afghan blasts kill one, injure scores in attack on key US military base    Saudi Aramco shares climb to hit daily 10% limit as IPO begins trading    Mohamed Salah the most mentioned football player in Egypt on Twitter    Apple's CEO spotted sampling Singapore's foods in neighborhood market    Gold prices stall ahead of Fed policy statement, tariffs deadline    Algeria votes amid protests    French pension reform to impact people entering job market from 2022: BFM    Dark Waters    The legendary Tahia Halim    After 30 years, Russian artist Dmitry Averianov is back at theRussian Cultural Centre    Don't miss "Towards Sustainable Cities" conference at the French Institute of Oriental Archaeology    Living with the enemy    Tidings of comfort and joy    Chelsea advance in Champions League with 2-1 win over Lille    All about the future    Inter out of Champions League after 2-1 loss to Barcelona    GERD: The Washington briefing    Cabinet under fire — again    Egypt's Ahly close to signing former Zamalek, Aves player Kahraba    Here is the full list of Golden Globes 2020 nominations    Egypt's President Sisi urges improving ways to identify sport talents    Health insurance system to be launched in Upper Egypt, South Sinai in March    Even being big, burly one needs his mother    Egypt's Cabinet denies reports on increasing Jan. train fares    Adam Sandler threatens to make ‘so bad' movie if he doesn't win Oscar    Egypt's Tahrir Square among top Reuters photos of a decade    Egypt names 16 new governors ahead of anticipated Cabinet reshuffle    Egypt's MPs back potential return of information minister post in expected reshuffle    Court sentences six to death, 41 to lifetime imprisonment violence related case    Trump says he would release Mideast peace plan after Israeli elections    ACWA Power compares 3 bids to supply production units for Luxor power station    What do you know about gold alloying?    NBE announces EGP 2.5m prizes for handball youth teams for their world achievements    Jennifer Lopez evokes Egyptian outrage post her North Coast performance    Al-Sisi honours Egypt's scholars on Science Day    IS claims responsibility for suicide bombing killing 63 in Afghan wedding    Political parties gear up for parliamentary, senate, local elections    Unprecedented Glory: Egypt win Men's U-19 World Handball Championship    12th National Egyptian Theatre Festival fuel up public theatre art scene    Ministry of Environment has a plan for "black clouds season"    

Thank you for reporting!
This image will be automatically disabled when it gets reported by several people.

Turkey: Safe zone dead end
Published in Ahram Online on 21 - 02 - 2019

“Only Turkey should be present in the safe zone” that Ankara wants to establish in northern Syria, said its Defence Minister Hulusi Akar last Friday while in Germany for the Munich Security Conference.
He insisted that the area had to be cleared of US-backed Syrian Kurdish forces, although he had no objection to “logistical support from allies” after the US troops pull out of Syria. By “allies” he meant the US-led International Coalition in Syria.
At that same conference, US Senator Lindsey Graham called for a “lean, joint military presence” made up of European forces to enforce a safe zone in northern Syria “post destruction of the caliphate”. German Chancellor Angela Merkel backed his call, stressing the need to work with Russia which will have the greatest influence in Syria after the US withdrawal.
Both Graham and Merkel were effectively reiterating Acting US Defence Secretary Patrick Shanahan's appeal to NATO allies, during his meeting with NATO defence ministers in Brussels on Wednesday, 13 February, to create a new international observer force to take the place of US troops in northeast Syria.
As Graham explained in Munich, the purpose of such a joint force would be twofold: to avert an attack by Turkish forces against the Kurdish People's Protection Units (YPG), which form the main fighting arm of the US-backed Syrian Defence Forces (SDF), and to forestall the re-emergence of the Islamic State group.
Although neither Shanahan or Graham gave any indication as to whether or not the US would take part in a joint force in northeast Syria, the head of the US Central Command, General Joseph Votel, told The Wall Street Journal on 15 February that the US has “the flexibility to leave some troops there if President Trump decides to maintain an American presence in Syria as a counter to Iran”.
So, what does all this mean to Ankara? Essentially, that its policies continue to reap failure. It first suggested the creation of a safe zone five years ago, ostensibly to protect civilian refugees, but no one listened.
It continued to reiterate this call periodically only to be greeted by the same silence on the part of all major players in Syria. But when Trump, in December, announced his intention to pull US forces from Syria, Erdogan saw an opening and leaped. In the interests of Turkish security, his government would establish a 30-kilometre deep safe zone inside Syria, he declared, sounding as though he could already feel that territory in his grip.
His Foreign Minister Mevlut Cavusoglu said that, now, there was “no alternative” to Turkey's stepping in to fill the gap created by the US pullout in view of his country's strength on the ground. He jubilated that the era in which Turkey lost its gains on the ground at the negotiating table was now over.
However, the flush of triumph quickly evaporated as the “immediate” troop withdrawal became clouded by uncertainty, confusion and contradictions from within the Trump administration. “Elements of the US administration are saying different things,” Erdogan fumed as he saw the safe zone beginning to slip through his fingers.
But, if he thought he would have better luck with the Russians in Sochi, he was in for a disappointment. Both Putin and Rouhani made it clear that a Turkish presence in northeast Syria would not be possible without Damascus's approval — meaning theirs. In a press conference aboard his plane on his way back from Sochi on 16 February, Erdogan did not rule out the possibility of conducting joint operations (with Russia and Iran). “Joint operations can be held at any time in line with developments.
There is no obstacle in front of these,” the Turkish strongman said. However, he was referring to Idlib rather than to the area on which he set his sights for the “safe zone” and the possible incursion Turkish forces could launch into northeast Syria that he has repeatedly warned could happen at any time.
Indeed, the Sochi summit that convened 14 February did not go very well for Erdogan at all, even with regard to developments in Idlib in the west. Putin pointedly reminded his Turkish counterpart of the need to tackle “terrorist groups” and spoke of the possibility of a joint military operation there while Russian Foreign Ministry Spokeswoman Maria Zakharova, who before the summit insisted that the area east of the Euphrates should be under Syrian government control, said that Moscow expected Ankara to do more to fulfil its obligations in accordance with the Russian-Turkish agreement to liberate Idlib from terrorists and to disarm the Turkish-backed jihadist factions in Idlib, a task Ankara had been expected to accomplish by 15 October last year.
In January, Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov warned that Al-Nusra Front now occupied 70 per cent of Idlib. “It also worries us that in Idlib, contrary to the agreements on creating the demilitarised zone there, Jabhat Al-Nusra dominates and violates the demilitarised zone,” he said during a press conference with his German counterpart, Heiko Maas, in Moscow.
There have been reports that Turkey plans to promote the transformation of the former Al-Qaeda affiliate into a political movement/party — a sort of Sunni equivalent of the Lebanese Hizbullah — and incorporate its fighters into the Syrian National Army.
Rouhani, for his part, backed Putin's insistence that any safe zone in northeast Syria would need the Al-Assad government's approval. Damascus had to be able to assert full control over the country before there could be talk about creating safe zones, he said, while simultaneously underscoring the need to rid Idlib of terrorists.
So, it was two against one in Sochi and all sides against Erdogan's vision for a Turkish-controlled safe zone in Syria.
*A version of this article appears in print in the 21 February, 2019 edition of Al-Ahram Weekly under the headline: .Safe zone dead end

Clic here to read the story from its source.