No pressures imposed on Egypt to accept Washington's deal on GERD: Irrigation Ministry    Egypt's young pharaoh, TUT in Australia's Boston exhibition    Dozens injured as security forces clash with protesters in Beirut    Al-Sisi, WB delegation discuss recent developments on GERD's negotiations    Al-Sisi heads to Berlin for Libya's peace talks    EGAS cuts gas exports to Jordan to 140 scf/day    Iran to send flight recorders from downed jet to Ukraine    Nine arrested for smuggling foreign currencies: ACA    Alexandria, Dekheila ports working normally despite medium rain    EgyptAir receives eighth A220-300 plane    Apple reveals worldwide national security requests for customer data    Europe stocks in green as China's GDP grows as expected; Stoxx 600 hit records high    Live score: Brighton & Hove Albion v Aston Villa (English Premier League)    Inter Milan sign wing-back Ashley Young from United    Bale, Ramos ruled out for Real Madrid's clash against Sevilla, Benzema returns    Floods, road closures in Australia as storms lash some bushfire-hit regions    Egypt's tycoon Nassef Sawiris is Africa's second richest person    Egypt's expected to see 5.8% 2020 GDP growth: UN report    Al-Hariri condemns Al Hamra attacks, amid protesters smashing central bank    Egypt's interior ministry says Mostafa Kassem received fair trial, was convicted terrorist    France, US request to join East Mediterranean Gas Forum    Art Alert: Bibliotheca Alexandrina to screen Oscar Shorts and star-studded films from Arab world    Screenwriter and producer Mohamed Hefzy's 'Ras El-Sana' to hit Egyptian cinemas in February    Egyptian actress Magda Al-Sabahi dies at 89    China, U.S. sign initial trade pact but doubts and tariffs linger    Egypt is best tourism destination for 2020 according to BBC    Washington meeting on GERD continues for third day    Egypt will not allow Anadolu's continuous ‘support of terrorism': senior official    Government launches Upper Egypt's first cultural festival    GERD filling will consider Blue Nile hydrological conditions, potential impact on downstream reservoirs: Egypt, Ethiopia, Sudan, US and WB    Egypt names executive head of comprehensive health insurance authority – ministry    New study finds Ocean acidification does not affect behaviour of coral reef fish    Nancy Ajram's husband charged with ‘intentional' murder    6th of October Rotary club trains undergrads for teaching literacy workshops    BBC names Egypt as best tourism destination for 2020    WHO says new China coronavirus could spread, warns hospitals worldwide    Brain freeze: Russian firm offers path to immortality for a fee    Ethiopian Dam talks to continue in Washington on Wednesday : Ministry    Inconclusive GERD negotiations    Mission Africa continues    NBE studies establishment of rowing club in Cairo    Egyptian sports in 2020: challenges and opportunities    Tough Mudder obstacle course race takes place for first time in Egypt    Egypt approves Uber's acquisition of Careem with set conditions    Egypt's Zamalek, Smouha presidents hit with disciplinary sanctions by EFA    Egypt's President Sisi pardons some prisoners on 25 Jan. Revolution anniversary    Egypt's Sami Anan released after near two-year detention    Liverpool's Mohamed Salah optimistic to see Egypt at 2022 World Cup    







Thank you for reporting!
This image will be automatically disabled when it gets reported by several people.





Controversy looms over 40-year-old constitution
Published in Daily News Egypt on 15 - 03 - 2011

CAIRO: As the date for the referendum on the rather controversial constitutional amendments gets closer, opposition groups, parties and activists remain divided over whether to cast a yes or a no vote.
On March 19, Egyptians will have their say about the proposed amendments to the 40-year-old constitution.
Earlier on Feb. 13, the Supreme Council of the Armed Forces, ruling the country since former president Hosni Mubarak stepped down, suspended the constitution.
The army formed a committee of legal experts a few days later to amend a number of articles.
The referendum will be on amendments to Articles 75, 76, 77, 88, 93, 139 and 148, the cancellation of Article 179, inserting a paragraph in Article 189 and the adding two items to it.
Most of the suggested articles have to do with regulating legislative and presidential elections as well as parliamentary and presidential jurisdictions.
Several opposition forces and parities called for drafting a temporary constitution till parliamentary and presidential elections are held later this year, while others considered it a transitional phase that precedes drafting a new constitution.
Lawyer Essam El-Islamboly had filed a lawsuit before the Administrative Court calling for halting the referendum.
On Tuesday, the January 25 Revolution Youth Coalition released a statement saying they objected to the constitutional amendments, calling on citizens to cast a no ballot.
Al-Tagammu Party announced this week that it rejected the amendments, calling on citizens to vote against them in order to preserve the January 25 Revolution and pave the way for turning into a real democratic system instead of an authoritarian one.
Both Al-Wafd and Democratic Front opposition parties also opposed these adjustments for similar reasons.
Earlier last week, opposition leader Mohamed ElBaradei said during a televised interview that he was against the amendments, describing them as “shallow.”
The former International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) chief objected to the amendments proposed on article 75 of the constitution which stipulate that presidential nominee and their parents must be Egyptian citizens, without having ever held a foreign citizenship.
Potential nominees cannot be married to a non-Egyptian.
Other opposition forces, however, welcomed the proposed amendments.
Founder of Al-Karama Party Hamdeen Sabahi said he completely agrees on the amendments “for the time being.”
He said in recent press statements that drafting a new constitution means the transitional phase during which the country is run by the military junta will be extended.
Sabahi had announced his intention to run for president a few months before Mubarak stepped down, launching a presidential campaign.
Among the groups agreeing on the constitutional amendments is the frozen Islamist Labor party.
Assistant Secretary General Naglaa Al-Qalyouby told Daily News Egypt that the party supports the amendments considering the move a transitional phase that Egyptians should accept “until the authority is handed over to civilians and a parliament and president are elected.”
“Drafting a new constitution will take a long time. And we are certain the coming [presidential and parliamentary] elections will be fully supervised by the judiciary,” she said.
The Muslim Brotherhood, the largest opposition group in Egypt, also voiced support for the amended constitution.
“In order to have a new constitution drafted within one year, these amendments have to be enacted so that parliamentary elections are held,” senior group member Essam El-Erian told DNE.
“We have no other choice. If we cast a no ballot, then we must look for a solution,” he added.
Some Brotherhood leaders have previously voiced dissatisfaction, saying these adjustments were not enough.
“We all still accept as true that these modifications are insufficient and we have comments on them. But since a new constitution will be formulated, we will later avoid all these [constitutional defects],” El-Erian said.
Amr Hashim, senior researcher at Al-Ahram Center for Political and Strategic Studies, considers the division over whether to accept or reject the amendments as being a “healthy phenomenon.”
“It is probably the first time that voters cast their ballot without knowing the result beforehand,” Hashim told DNE.
Some legal experts believe the current situation will eventually lead to a constitutional stalemate, arguing that the constitution was automatically terminated after Mubarak stepped down.
“The constitution is no longer active after the regime was toppled,” Cairo University constitutional law professor Raafat Fouda said.
“The army's decision to suspend the constitution is of no use; and so is the call to amend it,” Fouda told DNE.
“The amendment of the constitution is in fact unconstitutional…because it can only be made to something it exists,” he argued.
According to Fouda, “the armed forces had no authority to form a constitutional amendment committee in the first place because they are a guarantor of the revolution not a ruling authority.
“Even if the old constitution was active, the army had no right to rule the country,” he agued.
Based on Article 84, in case of the vacancy of the presidential office, or the permanent disability of the president, the speaker of the People's Assembly (the Lower House of Parliament) shall temporarily assume the presidency.
If the assembly is dissolved, the president of the Supreme Constitutional Court shall take over the presidency on condition that neither one shall nominate themselves for the presidency.
The Egyptian constitution is made of 211 articles. It was adopted in 1971 and amended in 1980, 2005 and 2007.


Clic here to read the story from its source.