Front Page
Politics
Economy
International
Sports
Society
Culture
Videos
Newspapers
Ahram Online
Al-Ahram Weekly
Albawaba
Almasry Alyoum
Amwal Al Ghad
Arab News Agency
Bikya Masr
Daily News Egypt
FilGoal
The Egyptian Gazette
Youm7
Subject
Author
Region
f
t
مصرس
Dangote refinery seeks US crude boost
Taiwan's tech sector surges 19.4% in April
France deploys troops, blocks TikTok in New Caledonia amid riots
Egypt allocates EGP 7.7b to Dakahlia's development
Microsoft eyes relocation for China-based AI staff
Beyon Solutions acquires controlling stake in regional software provider Link Development
Asian stocks soar after milder US inflation data
Abu Dhabi's Lunate Capital launches Japanese ETF
K-Movement Culture Week: Decade of Korean cultural exchange in Egypt celebrated with dance, music, and art
MSMEDA chief, Senegalese Microfinance Minister discuss promotion of micro-projects in both countries
Egypt considers unified Energy Ministry amid renewable energy push
President Al-Sisi departs for Manama to attend Arab Summit on Gaza war
Egypt stands firm, rejects Israeli proposal for Palestinian relocation
Empower Her Art Forum 2024: Bridging creative minds at National Museum of Egyptian Civilization
Niger restricts Benin's cargo transport through togo amidst tensions
Egypt's museums open doors for free to celebrate International Museum Day
Egypt and AstraZeneca discuss cooperation in supporting skills of medical teams, vaccination programs
Madinaty Open Air Mall Welcomes Boom Room: Egypt's First Social Entertainment Hub
Egypt, Greece collaborate on healthcare development, medical tourism
Egyptian consortium nears completion of Tanzania's Julius Nyerere hydropower project
Sweilam highlights Egypt's water needs, cooperation efforts during Baghdad Conference
AstraZeneca injects $50m in Egypt over four years
Egypt, AstraZeneca sign liver cancer MoU
Swiss freeze on Russian assets dwindles to $6.36b in '23
Climate change risks 70% of global workforce – ILO
Prime Minister Madbouly reviews cooperation with South Sudan
Egypt retains top spot in CFA's MENA Research Challenge
Egyptian public, private sectors off on Apr 25 marking Sinai Liberation
Debt swaps could unlock $100b for climate action
Amal Al Ghad Magazine congratulates President Sisi on new office term
Egyptian, Japanese Judo communities celebrate new coach at Tokyo's Embassy in Cairo
Financial literacy becomes extremely important – EGX official
Euro area annual inflation up to 2.9% – Eurostat
BYD، Brazil's Sigma Lithium JV likely
UNESCO celebrates World Arabic Language Day
Motaz Azaiza mural in Manchester tribute to Palestinian journalists
Russia says it's in sync with US, China, Pakistan on Taliban
It's a bit frustrating to draw at home: Real Madrid keeper after Villarreal game
Shoukry reviews with Guterres Egypt's efforts to achieve SDGs, promote human rights
Sudan says countries must cooperate on vaccines
Johnson & Johnson: Second shot boosts antibodies and protection against COVID-19
Egypt to tax bloggers, YouTubers
Egypt's FM asserts importance of stability in Libya, holding elections as scheduled
We mustn't lose touch: Muller after Bayern win in Bundesliga
Egypt records 36 new deaths from Covid-19, highest since mid June
Egypt sells $3 bln US-dollar dominated eurobonds
Gamal Hanafy's ceramic exhibition at Gezira Arts Centre is a must go
Italian Institute Director Davide Scalmani presents activities of the Cairo Institute for ITALIANA.IT platform
Thank you for reporting!
This image will be automatically disabled when it gets reported by several people.
OK
A spectacular miscarriage
Judit Neurink
Published in
Al-Ahram Weekly
on 21 - 03 - 2002
The integrity of the Lockerbie trial is under question following the denial of Abdel-Basset Al-Megrahi's appeal against his life sentence. Judit Neurink reports from Camp Zeist
Last week, the appeal against the Lockerbie verdict ended in the
Netherlands
. As the condemned
Libyan
bomber's wife wailed, applause rose from the relatives of the victims.
After two years of expensive trials it seems the only people satisfied are the victims' families and the Scottish Crown. The rejection of Al-Megrahi's appeal by five Scottish judges was heralded by the relatives as "a victory for Scottish justice." The defendant was sentenced to life imprisonment last year for the murder of 270 people in 1988. But both Scottish and Arab jurists described the decision as "a bad day" for Scottish justice.
Presiding judge Lord Cullen took only two minutes to announce the verdict last Thursday. Alluding to the 200 -page judgement published on the Internet, he said, "We have concluded that none of the grounds of appeal is well-founded. Accordingly the appeal is refused.'' Al-Megrahi looked dazed in his long, white
Libyan
robes and red fez. His wife Aissa, dressed in black with a black scarf, burst into loud sobs and had to be supported as she left the public gallery.
The five judges were unanimous in their conclusion. They upheld that Al-Megrahi was a
Libyan
agent in
Malta
in 1988 and that he was responsible for blowing up the PanAm Boeing in December of that year. They rejected the new evidence submitted by the defence, that on the day of the crash, a door leading to the baggage loading area at Heathrow Airport was broken open. The defence suggested, therefore, that the bomb could have been brought aboard the flight in
London
, rather than in
Malta
.
Arab legal experts in Camp Zeist were incensed by the verdict. Whilst
Libyan
lawyers spoke of a trial that is politically motivated, Saber Ammar of the Arab Lawyers' Union criticised "the influence of politicians and the press on the judges." Chairman Bechir Essid of the Tunisian Bar Association said he was disillusioned with the Western judicial system. "How can you sentence someone without any proof? This is abuse of justice.,' he said.'
The United Nations' observer, Hans Kchler, an Austrian professor of Jurisprudence, was alarmed by the decision. He described the appeal as "a rather spectacular miscarriage of justice." He was lost as to how a unanimous decision was reached "in the light of some of the analysis presented and questions asked by the judges."
Kchler's objections to the trial procedure are well documented. After the original verdict, his report argued that the trial "was not fair and not conducted in an objective manner." He then argued that "a political element" had been introduced to the courtroom by the inclusion of US state prosecutors in the prosecution team. He concluded "that foreign governments or (secret) governmental agencies may have been allowed, albeit indirectly, to determine, to a considerable extent, which evidence was made available to the court.'' It has been suggested that the trial was a politically driven cover-up to keep other suspects,
Iran
,
Syria
and the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine-General Command (PFLP-GC), out of the limelight.
The UN observer also believes the defence lawyers failed Al-Megrahi. "He had no chance to give them any instructions." Kchler even suggests the defence team was in cahoots with the prosecution. Robert Black, a professor of Scottish Law and one of the architects of the trial, agrees with some of Kchler's criticisms. It was Black who ended years of arguments between
Libya
, the USA and Britain by suggesting the trial of the two
Libyan
suspects under Scottish law in a neutral country.
Black now questions "some of the tactical decisions" of the defence. He was surprised the
Libyan
's lawyers did not protest about the expensive holidays provided by the Scottish police in exchange for the testimony of Tony Gauci, a Crown witness. Black was also concerned about the defence's failure to mention the statement of an ex-CIA agent claiming that
Iran
paid a Palestinian group for the Lockerbie bombing.
But Black, who worked as a part-time judge himself for 15 years, is particularly critical of the original trial judges. He believes it was wrong to pass a life sentence on Al-Megrahi based on weak and circumstantial evidence. "I think it was a fair trial. All the procedures worked fairly well. But the judges made a wrong decision. It seems there are also rogue judges."
The appeal verdict keeps Black on the case. "I would have been relieved if I could bow out after more than 10 years. But now I will have to continue giving advice in the right quarters," he said. To whom, he will not say, but it is fair to assume he will be talking to the
Libyan
and the British governments. Al-Megrahi, who has been transferred from Camp Zeist to Barlinnie jail in Scotland, can still ask the Privy Council, Britain's highest appeal commission, to re-examine his case under the European Convention on Human Rights. If that fails, the European Court in Strasbourg can be approached. Finally, the defendant can also turn to a special (British) Review Commission, which has recently quashed sentences passed on suspected IRA bombers.
Recommend this page
© Copyright Al-Ahram Weekly. All rights reserved
Send a letter to the Editor
Clic
here
to read the story from its source.
Related stories
'The whole truth..'?
Curtain falls on Lockerbie
A word to the wise
Report inappropriate advertisement