Front Page
Politics
Economy
International
Sports
Society
Culture
Videos
Newspapers
Ahram Online
Al-Ahram Weekly
Albawaba
Almasry Alyoum
Amwal Al Ghad
Arab News Agency
Bikya Masr
Daily News Egypt
FilGoal
The Egyptian Gazette
Youm7
Subject
Author
Region
f
t
مصرس
Dangote refinery seeks US crude boost
Taiwan's tech sector surges 19.4% in April
France deploys troops, blocks TikTok in New Caledonia amid riots
Egypt allocates EGP 7.7b to Dakahlia's development
Microsoft eyes relocation for China-based AI staff
Beyon Solutions acquires controlling stake in regional software provider Link Development
Asian stocks soar after milder US inflation data
Abu Dhabi's Lunate Capital launches Japanese ETF
K-Movement Culture Week: Decade of Korean cultural exchange in Egypt celebrated with dance, music, and art
MSMEDA chief, Senegalese Microfinance Minister discuss promotion of micro-projects in both countries
Egypt considers unified Energy Ministry amid renewable energy push
President Al-Sisi departs for Manama to attend Arab Summit on Gaza war
Egypt stands firm, rejects Israeli proposal for Palestinian relocation
Empower Her Art Forum 2024: Bridging creative minds at National Museum of Egyptian Civilization
Niger restricts Benin's cargo transport through togo amidst tensions
Egypt's museums open doors for free to celebrate International Museum Day
Egypt and AstraZeneca discuss cooperation in supporting skills of medical teams, vaccination programs
Madinaty Open Air Mall Welcomes Boom Room: Egypt's First Social Entertainment Hub
Egypt, Greece collaborate on healthcare development, medical tourism
Egyptian consortium nears completion of Tanzania's Julius Nyerere hydropower project
Sweilam highlights Egypt's water needs, cooperation efforts during Baghdad Conference
AstraZeneca injects $50m in Egypt over four years
Egypt, AstraZeneca sign liver cancer MoU
Swiss freeze on Russian assets dwindles to $6.36b in '23
Climate change risks 70% of global workforce – ILO
Prime Minister Madbouly reviews cooperation with South Sudan
Egypt retains top spot in CFA's MENA Research Challenge
Egyptian public, private sectors off on Apr 25 marking Sinai Liberation
Debt swaps could unlock $100b for climate action
Amal Al Ghad Magazine congratulates President Sisi on new office term
Egyptian, Japanese Judo communities celebrate new coach at Tokyo's Embassy in Cairo
Financial literacy becomes extremely important – EGX official
Euro area annual inflation up to 2.9% – Eurostat
BYD، Brazil's Sigma Lithium JV likely
UNESCO celebrates World Arabic Language Day
Motaz Azaiza mural in Manchester tribute to Palestinian journalists
Russia says it's in sync with US, China, Pakistan on Taliban
It's a bit frustrating to draw at home: Real Madrid keeper after Villarreal game
Shoukry reviews with Guterres Egypt's efforts to achieve SDGs, promote human rights
Sudan says countries must cooperate on vaccines
Johnson & Johnson: Second shot boosts antibodies and protection against COVID-19
Egypt to tax bloggers, YouTubers
Egypt's FM asserts importance of stability in Libya, holding elections as scheduled
We mustn't lose touch: Muller after Bayern win in Bundesliga
Egypt records 36 new deaths from Covid-19, highest since mid June
Egypt sells $3 bln US-dollar dominated eurobonds
Gamal Hanafy's ceramic exhibition at Gezira Arts Centre is a must go
Italian Institute Director Davide Scalmani presents activities of the Cairo Institute for ITALIANA.IT platform
Thank you for reporting!
This image will be automatically disabled when it gets reported by several people.
OK
Taking a stand
Israel's involvement in desert reclamation has lo
Published in
Al-Ahram Weekly
on 11 - 04 - 2002
A boycott of
Israel
? The US, too? And by whom? Government, business or consumers? And would it work? Al-Ahram Weekly looks at the debates
When Prime Minister Atef Ebeid recently announced that the
Egyptian
government had decided to "cut off all communications with
Israel
, except those benefiting the peace process," no one in the business community was quite sure what the decision entailed.
For some business people, the decision was read as a signal from the government that the private sector should cut off any exchange with
Israel
, which included cooperation in the fields of agriculture, textiles, oil and tourism.
But those who actually do business with
Israel
, when contacted by the Weekly, dismissed the decision as "a political ploy, which has nothing to do with reality." They also said they had received no official word that they should stop their contact with
Israel
.
"What do you mean, a boycott?" asked one. "Are we playing some sort of game here? There are people's livelihoods at stake. We started business with
Israel
on the basis of a green light from the government. We cannot stop at the push of a button."
The official position on an economic boycott has been intentionally ambiguous. Official sources told the Weekly that a boycott of
Israeli
, as well as American products is "a decision made at the popular level, and does not have anything to do with official decisions." The government, continues the argument, cannot impose on private enterprises who to do business with.
The
Egyptian
Federation of Chambers of Commerce (EFCC), however, has renewed an 18- month-old decision to boycott
Israeli
products.
"The decision, taken by the EFCC board, which represents 3.5 million
Egyptian
traders, has been in effect since the beginning of the Intifada in September 2000, but the EFCC has decided to renew it," said EFCC Chairman Khaled Abu Ismail.
However, the EFCC realises it has no means of enforcing the decision. Ismail said that the boycott decision is "not obligatory" for traders, counting, instead, on consumers. "Those who still deal with
Israel
will lose, since their consumers will refuse to buy any
Israeli
products," he asserted.
In the business sector, as well as among the wider public, feelings of anger at
Israel
are inseparable from resentment towards the US's apparent condoning of its policies.
According to Ismail, the
Egyptian
business community, headed by the EFCC, the Federation of
Egyptian
Industries and other business associations presented a statement to the US ambassador to
Cairo
in which they expressed their concern about "US double standards" in dealing with current events in the Middle East.
The businessmen also expressed their fear that US support for
Israel
"might lead to a negative impact on its economic cooperation with
Egypt
."
Only time will show the depth of the initiative taken by
Egyptian
businessmen to boycott
Israeli
products and stop all forms of normalisation with
Israel
, says Wagih Shindy, an international business and legal expert, and minister of investment and tourism in the 1980s. "In this case, trade between both countries should be revised on a quarterly basis to see whether or not the volume of trading is dwindling. If not, the initiative will prove nothing but mere clichés," said Shindy.
Shindy argues that Arab states should have an influential economic role to play in stemming
Israel
's attempts to grow into the most influential country in the region.
"What have Arabs done to grow into one integrated, influential economic bloc? Nothing," said Shindy. "Unfortunately, each of the Arab countries is living in its isolated island. The only way out of the dilemma is for Arabs to define a set of common strategic and economic goals and to put aside their political issues," he said.
While Shindy believes that action should be taken by Arab governments, Gouda Abdel- Khaliq, professor of economics at
Cairo
University and chairman of the economic affairs committee of the leftist Tagammu Party, confirms that now is the time for the general public to assert its will.
"If the
Egyptian
government is tied up by the peace agreement it signed with
Israel
, the people, on the other hand, have signed no accords and they can freely and effectively boycott both
Israeli
and American products in different ways," said Abdel-Khaliq.
Abdel-Khaliq provides many suggestions for an effective boycott. "Imagine if workers at
Egyptian
airports refuse to provide any services for El-Al planes, for example, or if workers in ports refrain from unloading containers that carry American or
Israeli
products. This, I believe, will be a stronger message to both countries than all condemnation remarks on the part of the government," he said.
In this phase, it is the business associations, trade unions and political parties that have a dramatic role to play to keep up the momentum. "Talking in my capacity as a member of an opposition party, these entities remain widely absent," said Abdel-Khaliq.
But Abdel-Khaliq praised action taken by the Syndicate of Pharmacists, which, in its latest meeting last week, listed US medicines that have a local equivalent or can be imported from other countries, in an attempt to limit the import of medicine from the US.
"It is necessary to define the list of products and the networks for their distribution so that the boycott can be organised effectively," said Abdel-Khaliq. He argues that American movies should be boycotted as well as household equipment and vehicles.
"The boycott is a tool the US can hardly misinterpret. It can barely argue the eligibility of such a tool as an effective weapon," Abdel- Khaliq said. "The US has successfully used this tool an infinite number of times. It was used against the former Soviet Union, Yugoslavia and
China
. It is now used against
North Korea
,
Iran
,
Sudan
,
Libya
and
Iraq
. Unfortunately, these stances demand a high rate of awareness on the part of the majority of the people and the number of
Egyptian
businesses that may be harmed is high. "We cannot say that such an awareness exists, yet, but the intensity of
Israeli
violations in the Palestinian territories has triggered a sense of patriotic enthusiasm that has been dormant for a long time," he added.
Although Abdel-Khaliq agrees that
Egyptian
- US relations are important, he contends "that this is the time to reassess the terms upon which this relation is based," adding that
Egypt
should have a better appreciation of its role as a strategic country in the region. He also remarked that "it is humiliating for a society to grow widely dependent on the aid given by another country,
Egypt
has to understand that American aid is given according to strategic calculations that can hardly be achieved without
Egypt
's consent."
However, while Abdel-Khaliq argues that an
Egyptian
boycott of US products could be effective, Aviv Ezra, officer in charge of economic affairs at the
Israeli
Embassy in
Cairo
asserts that an
Egyptian
economic boycott of
Israel
is "not a tool to make a difference."
"The size of trade [between
Egypt
and
Israel
] is the equivalent of what an
Israeli
software company exports to the US," Ezra said.
During the period of January-September 2001,
Israel
imported around $15 million worth of merchandise from
Egypt
. This is a drop from the previous year's figure of $16 million. During that same period in 2001,
Egypt
imported $35 million worth of
Israeli
merchandise compared to $46 million during the same period in 2000, a drop of 20 per cent.
These figures exclude oil which represents the bulk of
Israeli
imports. Ezra puts the size of
Israeli
oil imports at approximately $100 million annually. A major gas deal, under which
Egypt
would supply a third of
Israel
's energy needs, came near to fruition last year but was later put on hold.
Israeli
imports from
Egypt
include chemical products, agricultural, mineral products, as well as food, vegetables and paper products.
Israel
also exports to
Egypt
chemical products, textiles and machinery.
Israeli
investments in
Egypt
stand at a few tens of million, in the textiles sector. Until recently there were
Israeli
investments in the MIDOR refinery in
Egypt
, but these have been pulled out.
"Business between
Israeli
and
Egyptian
business people could have been much better. It could have meant prosperity for both sides, but the business climate is not making it possible," Ezra said. "
Egyptian
businessmen can make a lot of money if there is greater cooperation. The level of trade is small but the potential is large."
Many
Egyptian
consumers, realising there are few
Israeli
products to boycott, have turned their anger to where they think they could most be effective: the American fast-food chains which do multi-million dollar business in
Egypt
. Calls to boycott the US chains have been circulated on the Internet, apparently winning support: a general tour around these outlets revealed that business was unusually quiet during the past week.
However, when contacted by the Weekly, many of the chains denied that a public boycott was affecting business. Caroline Greiss, marketing manager of McDonald's
Egypt
, said a slow- down could be attributed to "other factors such as seasonality, exams etc."
"We are an
Egyptian
joint-stock company, not involved in any political issues," Greiss said. "We are part of the community. These are
Egyptian
investments employing
Egyptian
workers. McDonald's
Egypt
is a supporter of the campaign to raise funds for the Children's Cancer. Those who boycott us are doing an act that will affect only
Egyptians
."
Hisham Fahmy, executive director of the American Chamber of Commerce in
Cairo
, agrees.
"They're trying to boycott
Israeli
products, but since there aren't many, they are going to what they think is the next best thing. Unfortunately, they are taking it out on (US) brands that exist in the
Egyptian
market through
Egyptian
investments and are operated by
Egyptian
workers. We need to get our voice heard, but we need a more effective way. We do not want to shoot ourselves in the foot."
But according to Shafik Gabr, head of
Egypt
's International Economic Forum, and a former president of the American Chamber of Commerce in
Egypt
, boycotting US products is not an effective way of pressuring the US to take a more pro-Palestinian stance.
"History has proven that boycotts and economic sanctions don't work," said Gabr. "If we want to have an effect, we must influence the decision-making process. We need to ask ourselves why Jewish lobbies [in the US] are more influential. This is a process that requires resources, planning, careful implementation and an understanding of the US decision-making process."
He adds: "The effect of any boycott is temporary and its execution is more emotional than practical," Gabr said. "Emotions should not overcome proper thinking."
Establishing
Egyptian
and Arab economic relations with
Israel
has always been a bumpy ride. In the early 1990s, following
Egypt
's example, other Arab countries overcame their reluctance to establish economic ties with
Israel
as the peace process unfolded. The
Madrid
Middle East peace conference, launched in October 1991, under the co-sponsorship of the US and
Russia
, opened talks between
Israel
and Arabs including the Palestinian Liberation Organisation (PLO). At that time, Arabs' economic boycott of
Israel
was showing signs of crumbling.
The establishment of a Palestinian self rule area and prospects of a more comprehensive resolution of the Arab-
Israeli
conflict raised hope for the emergence of a giant market of an estimated 200 million consumers, stretching from the Atlantic ocean to the Gulf.
In October 1994, senior officials, donor countries, financial institutions and representatives of the private sector met in
Casablanca
for the "Middle East North Africa Economic Summit" (MENA) to draw up an agenda for regional cooperation. The conference hosted business people from Saudi Arabia,
Israel
,
Morocco
,
Jordan
, United Arab Emirates,
Kuwait
,
Egypt
,
Bahrain
and Palestine plus corporate executives from more than 40 other countries. This was the first attempt at bringing Arab and
Israeli
businessmen together after the breakthrough in regional peace brought about by the
Israeli
-Palestinian
Oslo
agreement.
But the MENA summit, scheduled to be held in
Tunis
in 1998, was cancelled in the light of the deterioration of the peace process at the hands of
Israeli
Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu.
Originally, MENA was the brainchild of
Israel
's former prime minister, Shimon Peres, who was keen to integrate
Israel
's economy with those of the Arabs in an attempt to end its regional isolation.
The high expectations with which the first MENA summit was held were short-lived. In 1996,
Egypt
refused to host MENA at the summit level and insisted it be downgraded to a lower-level conference. Since then, all the outcomes of MENA -- a regional bank, a tourism organisation and a private sector forum -- have ceased to operate.
Recommend this page
Related stories:
Boycott
Israel
? Not so simple (economy)
Who will hurt first? (economy)
Autumn, 1973 (economy)
See: Invasion
Invasion 4 -10 April 2002
© Copyright Al-Ahram Weekly. All rights reserved
Send a letter to the Editor
Clic
here
to read the story from its source.
Related stories
Back to the dust
Rage at Ebeid
Ministers in muddles
Ebeid sees a silver lining
Iraq in parliament
Report inappropriate advertisement