Egypt's PM meets IMF chief ahead of December reviews    Egyptian pound softens slightly against dollar in early Sunday trading    Egypt warns of erratic Ethiopian dam operations after sharp swings in Blue Nile flows    Egypt's PM calls for urgent multilateral action on global crises at G20 Summit    Health minister opens upgraded emergency units, inspects major infrastructure projects    Israeli ceasefire violations escalate in Gaza as international pressure mounts for protection measures    Egypt's PM joins opening of first Africa-hosted G20 Summit as leaders push for reforms on climate, debt, global inequality    Industry ministry allocates 185,000 sqm for new industrial projects in 16 governorates    European leaders say US 28-point Ukraine peace draft needs more work, reject any change of borders by force    India delays decision on extraditing ex-PM Hasina as Bangladesh tensions rise    Entrepreneurship key to building more competitive economy at 2025 awards ceremony: Al-Mashat    Egypt concludes first D-8 health ministers' meeting with consensus on four priority areas    Egypt scraps parliamentary election results in 19 districts over violations    Health minister warns Africa faces 'critical moment' as development aid plunges    Egypt extends Ramses II Tokyo Exhibition as it draws 350k visitors to date    Egypt signs host agreement for Barcelona Convention COP24 in December    Al-Sisi urges probe into election events, says vote could be cancelled if necessary    Filmmakers, experts to discuss teen mental health at Cairo festival panel    Cairo International Film Festival to premiere 'Malaga Alley,' honour Khaled El Nabawy    Cairo hosts African Union's 5th Awareness Week on Post-Conflict Reconstruction on 19 Nov.    Egypt golf team reclaims Arab standing with silver; Omar Hisham Talaat congratulates team    Egypt launches National Strategy for Rare Diseases at PHDC'25    Egypt's Al-Sisi ratifies new criminal procedures law after parliament amends it    Egypt adds trachoma elimination to health success track record: WHO    Egypt, Sudan, UN convene to ramp up humanitarian aid in Sudan    Grand Egyptian Museum welcomes over 12,000 visitors on seventh day    Sisi meets Russian security chief to discuss Gaza ceasefire, trade, nuclear projects    Grand Egyptian Museum attracts 18k visitors on first public opening day    'Royalty on the Nile': Grand Ball of Monte-Carlo comes to Cairo    Egypt launches Red Sea Open to boost tourism, international profile    Omar Hisham Talaat: Media partnership with 'On Sports' key to promoting Egyptian golf tourism    Sisi expands national support fund to include diplomats who died on duty    Egypt's PM reviews efforts to remove Nile River encroachments    Egypt resolves dispute between top African sports bodies ahead of 2027 African Games    Germany among EU's priciest labour markets – official data    Paris Olympic gold '24 medals hit record value    It's a bit frustrating to draw at home: Real Madrid keeper after Villarreal game    Russia says it's in sync with US, China, Pakistan on Taliban    Shoukry reviews with Guterres Egypt's efforts to achieve SDGs, promote human rights    Sudan says countries must cooperate on vaccines    Johnson & Johnson: Second shot boosts antibodies and protection against COVID-19    Egypt to tax bloggers, YouTubers    Egypt's FM asserts importance of stability in Libya, holding elections as scheduled    We mustn't lose touch: Muller after Bayern win in Bundesliga    Egypt records 36 new deaths from Covid-19, highest since mid June    Egypt sells $3 bln US-dollar dominated eurobonds    Gamal Hanafy's ceramic exhibition at Gezira Arts Centre is a must go    Italian Institute Director Davide Scalmani presents activities of the Cairo Institute for ITALIANA.IT platform    







Thank you for reporting!
This image will be automatically disabled when it gets reported by several people.



Seeds of wrath
Published in Al-Ahram Weekly on 10 - 11 - 2005

Rasha Saad examines the Paris riots which are being closely followed for their Arab and Islamic connection
"The fires of wrath in the heart of Paris," the UAE newspaper Al-Bayan wrote in its front-page banner. Arab newspapers closely followed the riots sweeping across France, including the capital, for nearly two weeks following the electrocution of two teenagers of North African origin. Arab commentators insisted the seeds of wrath were deeply rooted in the Arab and African communities in France.
The London-based Al-Quds Al-Arabi wrote in its editorial, 'The plight of Muslim immigrants in France', "the Paris insurrection has shaken the French government and has created a state of lost confidence between the government and the immigrants, mostly Arab Muslims." This, the newspaper wrote, threatens to widen the scale of violence if not contained and its roots resolved.
"It has ignited the growing frustration in the society of immigrants who are suffering from drastic living conditions."
The editorial blamed both the French government and the rioters for the crisis. It called on the government to review its policies towards immigrants and rehabilitate them through serious programmes to integrate them in society.
On the other hand it called on the leaders of the Arab Islamic associations in France to confront extremist groups which incite violence. "Violence, sabotage and the burning of cars are not a civilised way to express injustice. What has happened is, hopefully, an electric shock that will push both sides, French and immigrants, into examining the roots of the problem and engage in a real dialogue to find a genuine solution."
The remarks by French Interior Minister Nicolas Sarkozy in which he described rebellious youths as "rabble" was a major catalyst of the firestorm. "Sarkozy committed a major sin when he described rioters as rabble," the editorial in Al-Quds Al-Arabi wrote. It added that he should have worked to cool tempers and give statements that promise a better future. "While preserving security and the sovereignty of law are important, security answers alone are not enough. There are social, political and religious roots that caused the frustration and eventually led to the explosion."
Wessam Saada in As-Safir blamed Sarkozy for much of the escalation. "Sarkozy bears maximum responsibility for the crisis. The scene of hundreds of burning cars indicates the futility of every policy that gives priority to only the criminal aspect of social and sectarian problems."
Saada described what happened as civil strife facilitated by security flaws that has left entire neighbourhoods without one policeman and under the authority of drug dealers and criminals. "As security is sometimes missing in this social sectarian ghetto, here come the men of suppression in a restraint operation of a poor neighbourhood without distinguishing between the guilty and the innocent. For them they all have one feature and one dialect."
Ahmed Al-Robei in the London-based Asharq Al-Awsat put much of the blame on the immigrants. He wrote of the need to have an inter-dialogue among activists in Arab groups in France before they have a dialogue with the "other".
"They [Arabs in France] should have a dialogue before speaking about a social crisis in the French community.
"There are no powers that play the role of leadership and exercise restraint, and there are no real NGOs that can form and move public opinion within these minorities. The French of Arab origin have not organised themselves in a civilised way in order to realise achievements in political, economic, cultural and academic fields."
Al-Robei called on French people of Arab origin "to act as French citizens and prove to the rest of the community that they are part and parcel of it."
Abdel-Wahab Al-Afandi offered his personal experience living as an Arab Muslim in France. "The Intifada of the youth in Paris may have surprised the world but it did not surprise those who have seen matters on the ground in France," Al-Afandi wrote in Al-Quds Al-Arabi. "When it comes to French immigrants [of Arab-African dissent] their share of freedom is less than that of the average man, their share of equality much less, and their share of fraternity barely exists."
Al-Afandi wrote that what shocked him most while living in France during the 1980s were the racist sentiments in the French community and in particular what seemed to him segregation in housing between immigrants and the rest of French citizenry.
He was also shocked by the ease with which young immigrants, especially from North Africa, resort to violence. He said the circumstances might lead to another French revolution. "We might be witnessing today the real beginnings of a genuine French revolution that leads in reality and not metaphor to freedom, fraternity and equality."
In the Jordanian newspaper Al-Raai Sultan Al-Hattab also predicted the emergence of another French revolution. "Is France living a new revolution and are the cries that surrounded the Bastille being renewed?"


Clic here to read the story from its source.