North Korea says it has no plans for talks with US    Arsenal forward Martinelli signs new long-term deal    Tokyo seeks travel curbs as new infections tops 100 for 3rd day, says NHK    Solskjaer says Manchester United can still improve and expects tight finish    India coronavirus cases hit record high amid monsoon rains    Australia's Victoria reports 108 new coronavirus cases, biggest jump since March    $50 bln more required for middle-and low-income Arab countries to recover from COVID-19: ESCWA    Global coronavirus cases rise to more than 11 million    GERD talks between Egypt, Ethiopia and Sudan to continue Saturday    Egypt's controversial winger Amr Warda extends deal with Greek side PAOK    GERD talks between Egypt, Ethiopia and Sudan resume on Friday    Rudolfo Anaya, 'godfather' of Chicano literature, dies at 82    Egypt and Jordan's Foreign ministers discuss annexation of West Bank    Saudi-led coalition destroys four Houthi drones over Yemen: Saudi Press Agency    France's PM Philippe resigns ahead of Cabinet reshuffle    Lebanon's negotiations with IMF on hold pending start of reforms – minister    Japan seeks extradition of Americans accused in Ghosn escape    Gulf economies to shrink 7.6% due to coronavirus, decline in oil prices: IMF    Ex-FDA official says the worst of the U.S. coronavirus outbreak to end in January    Moderna delays coronavirus vaccine trial – report    Egypt developing four WHO-registered vaccines to treat coronavirus patients    Greece starts clearing ground for Athens property plan after long delay    313 tourists from Switzerland, Belarus arrive in Egypt following flight resumption    Ethiopia intransigent on GERD issue: ECES seminar experts    ABB, Hitachi launch $10bn joint power venture    Qalaa Holdings records 191% y-o-y increase in revenues during Q1 of 2020    NCW calls for investigating harassment and rape allegations discussed on social media    Egypt's National Election Committee to announce Senate election details    Egypt is developing 4 vaccines, 3 drugs against COVID-19: Higher Education Minister    Egypt's parliament Oks supplementary spending bill for FY20    Italy's Eni unveils new gas discovery off Egyptian Nile Delta coast    Egypt's Zamalek to continue training Thursday, but domestic league participation unclear    Liverpool boss Klopp happy with African Nations Cup postponement    Deadly protests erupt in Ethiopia over killing of popular Oromo singer    Egypt's cultural activities to resume mid-July    At 99, CPC governance legitimacy shines brighter in time of global uncertainty    Federation of Egyptian Banks denies funding GERD: eletreby    Saudi development authority starts executing phase I of giant cultural project    30 June Revolution preserved Egyptian identity from hijack: Al-Sisi    Don't miss Al-Hadra troupe's two concerts at El-Sawy Culturewheel    Egypt's President Sisi opens Baron Empain Palace, two int'l airports    Inauguration of Baron Empain Palace important for Egypt's tourism sector: official    President Al-Sisi inaugurates new national project developments in Cairo    11 coronavirus cases detected at Egyptian Premier League clubs – EFA    Egypt to host World Handball Championship on time despite COVID-19: EHF President    Liverpool's Egyptian winger Salah fit for Crystal Palace clash – coach Klopp    Egypt's parliament Oks amendments to House law amid differences over election    CAF draws timeline for resumed continental championships amid COVID-19    







Thank you for reporting!
This image will be automatically disabled when it gets reported by several people.





As controversial as ever
Published in Al-Ahram Weekly on 30 - 03 - 2006

Tempers flared after Egyptian and French investigators provided differing conclusions for the 2004 Flash Airlines crash. Amirah Ibrahim reports
With families of the victims in the audience, a press conference announcing the results of investigations into a 2004 Flash Airlines crash near Sharm El-Sheikh, that killed 148 people, turned tense this week, as French and Egyptian investigators gave differing explanations for the tragedy.
Leading Egyptian investigator Shaker Kelada said none of the four technical failure hypotheses to explain the plane's sudden sharp veering had been conclusive. "Those scenarios focused on technical failure at the right wing, the auto pilot, the control wheel or auto pilot indicators," Kelada said. He formally ruled out "external intervention" such as sabotage. "The final report found that the automatic pilot system had not functioned properly, and that the pilot subsequently suffered from "spatial disorientation" when the plane crashed. No single scenario of the four could be determined to be the one that caused the crash, but it was [definitely] one of them."
Spatial disorientation -- estimated to cause 15 to 20 per cent of aviation accidents -- is a frequent problem for pilots, particularly when they lose sight of visual landmarks. According to the French investigators, it was the main cause for the plane's demise. "The plane remained pilotable at all times, and we consider that pilot spatial disorientation led the plane to go right" instead of left, said Paul- Louis Arslanian, who heads the French Civil Aviation Investigation and Analysis Bureau.
Arslanian's dismissal of the Egyptian investigations stunned the Cairo press conference. "It has to be said clearly that the accident was due to a technical failure, and not the pilot's fault," said the father of co-pilot Omar El-Shafei who perished in the crash. Dressed in black, and wearing a pendant with a photo of her son, she also demanded that Kelada clearly and officially absolve the crew of any responsibility.
A visibly affected Kelada said, "we have attached Mr Arslanian's report, in which he agreed to two of the four scenarios. The point of difference between us is that he wanted to put the human factor as a main cause, which we did not see any proof of."
Other family members thought both sides were wrong. "If the investigations suggest four previously unknown technical failures, and if it took the plane only 17 seconds to crash," asked the father of one of the pilots, "how can you ask the pilots to deal with unknown problems in such a short time?" He said the blame needed to be shifted to Boeing, the plane's manufacturer.
The plane's problems began two minutes after takeoff, as the autopilot was turned on for just three seconds before being disconnected. Kelada spoke of an unspecified "event" that distracted the cockpit crew between the moments when the pilot asked for autopilot activation and when the co-pilot remarked that the plane was heading toward the right.
Investigations revealed a series of motions, including a right banking and subsequent right turn. For a few seconds, it seemed both pilots could not understand why the plane suddenly started to turn. The captain tried to turn the autopilot on again but it did not respond.
As the bank angle continued to increase, the airplane reached its highest altitude of 5,460 feet. The captain ordered the autopilot turned on, and the co- pilot responded positively, but no autopilot engagement was recorded. Several attempts by the crew to turn on the autopilot ended in failure. The crew then attempted to retard power in order to retain control over the plane, and both engine throttles were moved to idle. The nose down pitch, however, continued.
"We found indications that the crew could have been deceived by wrong auto pilot indicators," Kelada said. While the crew attempted to control the plane, thinking the autopilot was not working, the plane was in fact under the control of the autopilot. When they discovered the false indicators and actually succeeded in putting [the plane in] the right position, it was too late."
Marc Chernet, head of the group defending the interests of the victims' families, said they were "satisfied with the conclusions" of the 1,300-page Egyptian report, "even if they are not forthcoming about the precise cause of the accident." In any case, he said, "we do not believe at all that the crew suffered from spatial disorientation."
Chernet did ask, however, why the report did not feature a clear condemnation of Boeing -- the plane's manufacturer -- or include a firm recommendation to ground the Boeing 737-300 and review suggested technical failure of the wings and autopilot.
"We recommended a review of those problems, but we cannot judge a whole fleet on just one case," Kelada said.
Although there were no Boeing officials in attendance at the press conference, reporters found out that several of the families had already settled with the aerospace giant. Families of five US- French victims had obtained $1 million in compensation for each victim, while Boeing had also reached a settlement with families of 13 Egyptian victims, each of whom received $200,000 in compensation. The majority of French families had filed a lawsuit -- still ongoing -- against Boeing.
"This kind of divergence is common in this type of investigation," Arslanian said at a press conference in Paris on Sunday. He said the pilot's "lack of sleep", and the speed with which he had moved from military aviation to civil flights, had to be considered. "I will not talk of lies by the Egyptians, but of differences of assessment," he said.
Kelada's reply was that the pilot, an ex-air force pilot, already had a professional record as a commercial pilot. Arslanian and Kelada had both gone to France to present the final report to the families of the victims there.
The remains of 16 French victims returned to France on Monday. Those of 67 others were already sent home last October. Some family members have chosen to bury their loved ones at a memorial site in Sharm El-Sheikh near the scene of the crash.


Clic here to read the story from its source.