"Narrative Summit" Releases 2025 Recommendations to Cement Egypt's Position as a Global Tourism Destination    Egypt, S.Arabia step up trade ties through coordination council talks    Egypt reviews progress on $200m World Bank-funded waste management hub    Egypt urges Israel to accept Gaza deal amid intensifying fighting    Egypt, ADIB explore strategic partnership in digital healthcare, investment    SCZONE, Tokyo Metropolitan Government sign MoU on green hydrogen cooperation    Egypt welcomes international efforts for peace in Ukraine    Al-Sisi, Macron reaffirm strategic partnership, coordinate on Gaza crisis    Contact Reports Strong 1H-2025 on Financing, Insurance Gains    Egypt, India's BDR Group in talks to establish biologics, cancer drug facility    AUC graduates first cohort of film industry business certificate    Egyptian pound down vs. US dollar at Monday's close – CBE    Egypt's FM, Palestinian PM visit Rafah crossing to review Gaza aid    Egypt prepares unified stance ahead of COP30 in Brazil    Egypt recovers collection of ancient artefacts from Netherlands    Egypt harvests 315,000 cubic metres of rainwater in Sinai as part of flash flood protection measures    Egypt, Namibia explore closer pharmaceutical cooperation    Fitch Ratings: ASEAN Islamic finance set to surpass $1t by 2026-end    Renowned Egyptian novelist Sonallah Ibrahim dies at 88    Egyptian, Ugandan Presidents open business forum to boost trade    Al-Sisi says any party thinking Egypt will neglect water rights is 'completely mistaken'    Egypt's Sisi warns against unilateral Nile measures, reaffirms Egypt's water security stance    Egypt's Sisi, Uganda's Museveni discuss boosting ties    Egypt, Huawei explore healthcare digital transformation cooperation    Egypt's Sisi, Sudan's Idris discuss strategic ties, stability    Egypt to inaugurate Grand Egyptian Museum on 1 November    Greco-Roman rock-cut tombs unearthed in Egypt's Aswan    Egypt reveals heritage e-training portal    Sisi launches new support initiative for families of war, terrorism victims    Egypt expands e-ticketing to 110 heritage sites, adds self-service kiosks at Saqqara    Palm Hills Squash Open debuts with 48 international stars, $250,000 prize pool    On Sport to broadcast Pan Arab Golf Championship for Juniors and Ladies in Egypt    Golf Festival in Cairo to mark Arab Golf Federation's 50th anniversary    Germany among EU's priciest labour markets – official data    Paris Olympic gold '24 medals hit record value    A minute of silence for Egyptian sports    Russia says it's in sync with US, China, Pakistan on Taliban    It's a bit frustrating to draw at home: Real Madrid keeper after Villarreal game    Shoukry reviews with Guterres Egypt's efforts to achieve SDGs, promote human rights    Sudan says countries must cooperate on vaccines    Johnson & Johnson: Second shot boosts antibodies and protection against COVID-19    Egypt to tax bloggers, YouTubers    Egypt's FM asserts importance of stability in Libya, holding elections as scheduled    We mustn't lose touch: Muller after Bayern win in Bundesliga    Egypt records 36 new deaths from Covid-19, highest since mid June    Egypt sells $3 bln US-dollar dominated eurobonds    Gamal Hanafy's ceramic exhibition at Gezira Arts Centre is a must go    Italian Institute Director Davide Scalmani presents activities of the Cairo Institute for ITALIANA.IT platform    







Thank you for reporting!
This image will be automatically disabled when it gets reported by several people.



Divestment, no
Published in Daily News Egypt on 25 - 03 - 2008

WASHINGTON-In April, the United Methodist Church s General Assembly will vote on whether or not to divest its holdings in companies that do business with Israel. The Methodists divestment campaign is not the only one of its kind. There are hundreds of efforts throughout the world which have as their goal ending investment in Israel or terminating relationships between local universities and Israeli universities.
These efforts all have one thing in common-the belief that Israel s behavior in the West Bank/Gaza is so heinous that pressure has to be applied directly to Israel s people, all of them. It is argued that crippling the Israeli economy, which is the goal of divestment, will cause all Israelis to suffer and lead them to rise up against the occupation to protect their jobs, their incomes, or their profits. (Funny, how economic pressure does not cause suffering Palestinians in Gaza to turn on Hamas, however.)
Proponents of divestment argue that, like South African apartheid, the occupation can be brought down by economic pressure. The analogy, however, is specious and not because there is anything good to say about the occupation. There isn t.
It has been in place for 41 years and there is little evidence it will end soon. Settlements continue being expanded. Checkpoints-obstacles to movement not on the Israeli-Palestinian border but deep inside the West Bank-keep going up despite promises to take them down. And innocent Palestinians keep dying as collateral victims of Israeli retaliations or targeted assassinations.
The occupation has been a curse on Palestinians and Israelis both. The best thing that could happen for both peoples would be if it ended tomorrow.
I could, at this point, discuss all the suffering Israelis have experienced at the hands of the Palestinians since peace talks broke down in the summer of 2000. I won t because the issue here is the actions of the Israelis, not of the Palestinians.
I don t want to create one of those hokey balance sheets where we measure one side s suffering against the others. And, frankly, I do not use the same yardstick to judge the actions of the Israeli government and Palestinian terrorists. It s not the Palestinian Authority that is inflicting terror on Israelis but terrorists, suicide bombers, and thugs. Forgive me, if I will not judge the state of Israel by the same standard I apply to Palestinian Islamic Jihad or the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine. I hope I never do.
However, it is fair to compare Israel s actions to our own country, the United Methodist Church s own country: the United States.
Most of the world, including a clear majority of Americans, thinks that the US invasion of Iraq was a disaster, that it was unjustified, and that it has caused untold suffering among Iraq s people. Some make the case, and it s not hard to make, that the US invasion of Iraq essentially destroyed that country and that it will be many, many years before Iraq is reconstituted as a nation in which its people live with any sense of security. Additionally, the international community made its opposition to the US invasion clear before it began. The United States government was indifferent to world opinion.
The war began and it continues. Like the Israeli occupation, there are few signs that it will end anytime soon.
Does that mean that American citizens and businesses should be boycotted? Does that mean that righteous EU countries should divest from the United States to show opposition to the war? Should all Americans be punished because our policies in the Middle East are so destructive? Frankly, I have never heard that proposed by anyone.
The United States of America, and its people, is considerably more than the sum total of its various policies. So is Israel. And, even in countries where we choose our leaders, ordinary people should not be punished for the sins of their government, except in very rare cases, like the case of South Africa.
Apartheid permeated every aspect of South African life. There was not a city, village, or township that was not permeated with apartheid. It is no accident that the nation of South Africa was called the apartheid regime because that is what it was. From top to bottom, there was no escaping it.
Without apartheid, in fact, there was no South African state. The collapse of apartheid produced an entirely new state.
That is not the case of the occupation and Israel. There is an Israel, a breathing, legitimate, Israeli state that exists independent of the occupation. Not only would Israel not collapse if the occupation ended, it would be infinitely better off.
Israel is a whole lot more than the occupation. It is the nation of Yitzhak Rabin, Tel Aviv, and the kibbutzim, not just the settlements and Jewish Settlers Only West Bank roads. It is the home of a million survivors of the Holocaust and their progeny. It is the only place in the Middle East where women and gays have equal rights under the law (obviously any gay Palestinian is safer in Israel than in Palestine or in any other place in the entire region). Israel s media is one of the freest in the world; in fact criticism of Israeli policies that are considered off-limits here are regularly presented in Israel s mainstream press.
But divestment would punish all Israelis - opponents of the occupation, civil rights activists, crusading journalists, ordinary people - for policies inflicted on the country by a powerful minority.
Former President Jimmy Carter was widely criticized, viciously in some quarters, for writing a book called Palestine: Peace, Not Apartheid.
Segments of the pro-Israel community called him anti-Semitic for suggesting that Israel was comparable to apartheid South Africa.
But that is not what he said. He said in dozens of interviews and speeches, The book is about Palestine, the occupied territories, and not about Israel. The word apartheid, Carter said, does not apply to Israel although, in his view, it does apply to the West Bank.
Carter has no reservations about condemning the occupation. But he distinguishes between the occupation and Israel.
The divestment campaign seems not to recognize that distinction. The goal is to punish all Israelis. It s a terrible idea.
The way to end the occupation is through negotiations. Our role as Americans should be to promote those negotiations and to play the role of honest broker in them rather than simply acting as Israel s lawyer.
Divestment makes sense only if one s goal is not to end the occupation but to dismantle the Israeli state (as apartheid was dismantled).
Surely that is not the goal of the mainstream Protestants promoting divestment. They should shelve the idea.
MJ Rosenberg is the Director of Israel Policy Forum s Washington Policy Center. This article is distributed by the Common Ground News Service (CGNews) and can be accessed at www.commongroundnews.org.


Clic here to read the story from its source.