Asian stocks steady on Tuesday    Oil prices hold steady on Tuesday    Egypt's central bank, Afreximbank sign MoU to develop pan-African gold bank    Abdelatty outlines Egypt's peace and development vision for Eastern Congo and Horn of Africa    Egypt to launch 2026-2030 national strategy for 11m people with disabilities    Egypt FM pledges support for African health and pharmaceutical security    Egypt, Lebanon sign deal to supply natural gas to Deir Ammar power plant    The apprentice's ascent: JD Vance's five-point blueprint for 2028    Kremlin demands Ukraine's total withdrawal from Donbas before any ceasefire    Prime Minister reviews reforms to boost efficiency of state-owned economic authorities    Health Ministry, Veterinarians' Syndicate discuss training, law amendments, veterinary drugs    Egypt completes restoration of 43 historical agreements, 13 maps for Foreign Ministry archive    Egypt's "Decent Life" initiative targets EGP 4.7bn investment for sewage, health in Al-Saff and Atfih    Egypt, Viatris sign MoU to expand presidential mental health initiative    Egypt sends medical convoy, supplies to Sudan to support healthcare sector    Egypt's PM reviews rollout of second phase of universal health insurance scheme    Egypt sends 15th urgent aid convoy to Gaza in cooperation with Catholic Relief Services    Al-Sisi: Egypt seeks binding Nile agreement with Ethiopia    Egyptian-built dam in Tanzania is model for Nile cooperation, says Foreign Minister    Egypt flags red lines, urges Sudan unity, civilian protection    Al-Sisi affirms support for Sudan's sovereignty and calls for accountability over conflict crimes    Egypt unveils restored colossal statues of King Amenhotep III at Luxor mortuary temple    Egyptian Golf Federation appoints Stuart Clayton as technical director    4th Egyptian Women Summit kicks off with focus on STEM, AI    UNESCO adds Egyptian Koshari to intangible cultural heritage list    UNESCO adds Egypt's national dish Koshary to intangible cultural heritage list    Egypt recovers two ancient artefacts from Belgium    Egypt, Saudi nuclear authorities sign MoU to boost cooperation on nuclear safety    Australia returns 17 rare ancient Egyptian artefacts    Egypt warns of erratic Ethiopian dam operations after sharp swings in Blue Nile flows    Egypt golf team reclaims Arab standing with silver; Omar Hisham Talaat congratulates team    Egypt launches Red Sea Open to boost tourism, international profile    Sisi expands national support fund to include diplomats who died on duty    Egypt's PM reviews efforts to remove Nile River encroachments    Egypt resolves dispute between top African sports bodies ahead of 2027 African Games    Germany among EU's priciest labour markets – official data    Russia says it's in sync with US, China, Pakistan on Taliban    It's a bit frustrating to draw at home: Real Madrid keeper after Villarreal game    Shoukry reviews with Guterres Egypt's efforts to achieve SDGs, promote human rights    Sudan says countries must cooperate on vaccines    Johnson & Johnson: Second shot boosts antibodies and protection against COVID-19    Egypt to tax bloggers, YouTubers    Egypt's FM asserts importance of stability in Libya, holding elections as scheduled    We mustn't lose touch: Muller after Bayern win in Bundesliga    Egypt records 36 new deaths from Covid-19, highest since mid June    Egypt sells $3 bln US-dollar dominated eurobonds    Gamal Hanafy's ceramic exhibition at Gezira Arts Centre is a must go    Italian Institute Director Davide Scalmani presents activities of the Cairo Institute for ITALIANA.IT platform    







Thank you for reporting!
This image will be automatically disabled when it gets reported by several people.



Plain talk
Published in Al-Ahram Weekly on 11 - 09 - 2008


By Mursi Saad El-Din
Janice Elliot is regarded as one of the most accomplished novelists in England. She worked first as a journalist and moved into book reviewing before publishing fiction. The title of her novel about Egypt, Life on the Nile, is a play on Agatha Christie's Death on the Nile. It contains minute descriptions of Egyptian scenes and sites, buildings and characters.
Charlotte Hamp comes to Cairo with her travel-writer husband, Leo, to go on a Nile cruise. But while Leo indulges his passion for amateur archaeology she plans a more personal excavation. In 1924 her great-aunt Phoebe was murdered while living in Aswan in circumstances never fully explained. All Charlotte has are her letters home and a disturbingly incomplete journal ablaze with life and love for Egypt.
There is a sense of mortality and of mystery. In trying to find the truth about one death Charlotte discovers that here there is never a simple explanation for anything. In Cairo she meets the other members of the cruise party, including Max, who has written a book on the Old Testament and is himself stalked by death, and Nikolai, a Hampstead Russian alcoholic of melancholy charm. The cruise progresses to undertows of menace. A stone is thrown and there are rumours of rioting in Cairo.
But for Charlotte present dangers are overlain by events of over sixty years ago as Phoebe's story, and that of the turbulent independence movement of the 1920's, become as real as her own and lead to a cathartic confrontation with the past.
The author seems to have a sympathetic attitude towards Egypt and a harsh judgment of British action towards the Egyptian nationalist movement of 1919. This is expressed through Phoebe, who is strongly pro Egyptian and is used as the writer's mouthpiece.
Phoebe kept a journal, which Charlotte brings with her, together with a collection of letters. The latter are reminiscent of Lady Duff Gordon's Letters from Egypt. They contain many interesting facts and opinions. We get to know, for instance, about the role of Egyptian women in the 1919 Revolution through the Hazim family, a brother and involved in the nationalist movement who were acquaintances of Pheobe. "If you knew this part of the world where women are kept down so you'd understand these political protests are sensational, much braver than our suffragettes," she writes.
There are similarities between the present visitor, Charlotte, and her aunt. They both arrive at a time when there is a crisis, the Nationalist Movement in 1919 and the fundamentalist problems in the Egypt Charlotte visits. But Pheobe's attachment to Egypt was stronger than Charlotte's. She stayed longer in the country and made many friends.
It is through her friends Nayra, and her brother Ahmed, that Pheobe gets to know and sympathise with the Egyptian issue. She writes about Saad Zaghloul, the leader of the Wafd party, who lead the 1919 revolution. Her enthusiasm is clear about the female Wafd, as she calls the women's wing of the party. What is happening in Egypt, she says, is a revolution for women as well as for Egypt.
Pheobe's love for Egypt is clear in the letters she writes to her family in England. She feels a particular affinity for the desert and the Nile which she says make human problems look small and absurd. Life, to her, is like the Nile: for a while it runs in long smooth stretches and then suddenly there are cataracts, rush, muddle.
She deals with the Suez Canal and the role of the British in making full use of Egypt's bankruptcy. When the declaration of Egyptian independence is announced she realises the reserved points in the Declaration means "our troops will stay" and laments that with "so many points reserved it's not independence at all".
Pheobe makes sympathetic criticisms of the English women living in Egypt. They are all, she sees, trying to put aside enough money to educate their children and buy the homes they dream of in England. "They don't even want to know Egypt and do their best not to see it," she writes. "For me Egypt has become home. Hope to live and die here."
Through Nayra and Ahmed Pheobe becomes involved with the independence movement. As a result she becomes unpopular with the British community. Her involvement is her undoing and the author suspects that the British are responsible for her assassination. She learns they sent assassins after Ahmed, who is hiding in her house in Aswan, and Charlotte comes to believe that when Ahmed escapes it is these hired killers who kill Pheobe.
Pheobe's love for Egypt goes beyond her present life and beyond the Egypt she lives in. Ancient Egypt is as close to her as the modern country. She sends a head of Nefertiti to her son in England with a note saying: "She lived over a thousand years ago by the Nile and was the beautiful wife of a famous Pharaoh who worshipped the sun. Nefertiti had six daughters. The end of the story of Nefertiti and Akhenaton is sad, but while they lived they were very happy. Akhenaton wrote poetry and Nefertiti played in a walled garden with her six children."
This is the head which Pheobe's son, Charlotte's father, values to the end of his life. It stirred in him a great passion for this far off country which he never visits. He keeps the statuette on the brown stained mantel in his study, and Charlotte catches him one day holding the statuette cradled in his hands.
Through Charlotte the author gives us a picture of modern Egypt. She describes her walks in Cairo, along the banks of the Nile and in Dokki, but she also gives us the story of Akhenaton as told by their guide Adila. And though politics are relatively thin on the ground in the novel we find passages reveal about Pheobe's attitude towards the Egyptian revolution of 1991, and her niece's attitude towards Israel.


Clic here to read the story from its source.