Egypt held at home by Kenya in Nations Cup qualifiers' opener    Egypt issues longest-term international bond with maturities of 40 years    Al-Azhar grand imam arrives in Rome to attend summit promoting child dignity    Egypt has the political well to improve human rights conditions: Experts    Egypt to launch $600 million Africa export credit guarantee firm –    Big production Mamalek El-Nar to scan Ottomans' history on Saudi MBC    Suez Canal Bank's financial position grows 5% in Sep. 2019    Bridging East and West: Egyptian musicians Abdallah Abozekry and Ali Baghdady in Paris concerts    Egypt's textiles salvage plan reveals backing for state sector    UAE, Egypt launch $20 billion joint investment fund    Power struggle in Bolivia: Anez at home vs Morales in exile    Six people killed, 16 injured in fuel pipeline explosion in Behaira    Battle lines harden as Trump impeachment goes public    Volume of non-oil trade exchange between Egypt, UAE reached 24.5 billion dollars within 5 years: UAE economy minister    Brexit Party's Farage dismisses calls to stand down in Labour seats    Zlatan the Conqueror to leave LA Galaxy    Murray faces 'Baby Fed' instead of Federer at ATP Cup    Islamic Jihad, Israel announce truce in Gaza calming worst fighting in months    Most Gulf stocks fall; Emirates NBD leads Dubai higher    Turkey: 17 hurt in explosions at ammunition depot    Insomnia symptoms increase risk of heart attack and stroke    Liverpool's forward Salah out of Egypt games with ankle problem    GERD: An ‘adaptive' agreement    A film is born    Egypt MPs meet with EU diplomats in Cairo to discuss human rights criticisms    10 tips to have your 30s starting a lifelong success    Nike to investigate its Oregon Project following Mary Cain's NYT op-ed    ‘Shining' sequel ‘Doctor Sleep' targets $25 mln opening, has Stephen King's blessing    Sisi: Egypt believes in comprehensive approach to human rights    UK University of Hertfordshire to open campus in Egypt new capital    Egypt's bourse, banks to close Sunday to mark Prophet Muhammad's birth    Egypt rejects politicised reports on human rights conditions – parliament    Egypt to vote on 3-month extension of state of emergency Monday    Jurgen Klopp gives injury update on Egypt's Mohamed Salah    Al Pacino says follows this mantra on every acting job    Remembering Mustafa Mahmoud, philosopher of his time    Court sentences six to death, 41 to lifetime imprisonment violence related case    Trump says he would release Mideast peace plan after Israeli elections    ACWA Power compares 3 bids to supply production units for Luxor power station    What do you know about gold alloying?    NBE announces EGP 2.5m prizes for handball youth teams for their world achievements    Jennifer Lopez evokes Egyptian outrage post her North Coast performance    Al-Sisi honours Egypt's scholars on Science Day    IS claims responsibility for suicide bombing killing 63 in Afghan wedding    Political parties gear up for parliamentary, senate, local elections    Unprecedented Glory: Egypt win Men's U-19 World Handball Championship    12th National Egyptian Theatre Festival fuel up public theatre art scene    Ministry of Environment has a plan for "black clouds season"    

Thank you for reporting!
This image will be automatically disabled when it gets reported by several people.

Criticisms of cybercrime law
Published in Al-Ahram Weekly on 21 - 06 - 2016

“Antagonising Technology” was the title of a report issued last week by three human rights organisations in Egypt reviewing some of the major articles of a controversial new cybercrime law that is undergoing parliamentary discussion.
In their report, the Egyptian Initiative for Personal Rights, the Support Centre for Information Technology, and the Association for Freedom of Thought and Expression strongly criticise the draft law, which they say creates an “exceptional status” in Egyptian criminal law.
The report says there is no such thing as a cybercrime and that crimes should not be classified according to the way in which they are committed.
Receiving preliminary approval by the House of Representatives Complaints and Suggestions Committee early last month, the draft law has been referred to the Communications and Information Technology Committee, another specialised committee, for more thorough discussion.
A number of government officials, including representatives from the defence and interior ministries, were present during the 10 May meeting of the Complaints Committee.
The 30-article draft law, submitted by independent MP Tamer Al-Shahawi, sets penalties ranging from arrest and fines to the death sentence for committing cybercrimes.
When presenting the draft to parliament, Al-Shahawi, explained that the aim of the legislation is to safeguard national security and to protect society from those who support terrorism and incite violence.
Al-Shahawi spent nearly 20 years in the military intelligence services before retiring in 2011.
In the report, the rights activists express their strong opposition to the law, which they view as a setback for freedom of expression and call upon parliament to turn down.
Prominent legal activist Gamal Eid said that the draft law is an attempt to silence the young opposition figures who express their views on social media outlets.
“I expected that the government would try to impose restrictions on social media outlets, but it did not cross my mind that it would ever appeal to such a scandalous law,” Eid told Al-Ahram Weekly.
The rights groups argue that the draft has been presented to parliament in a non-transparent way and that it has excluded the input of civil society representatives. The penalties set for violators in the law are very harsh and the wording of the articles loose and vague, the report says.
The authors of the report also complain that the proposed legislation violates the principle of equality before the law, as it differentiates in terms of penalties between cybercrimes and other crimes, mandating harsher punishments for committing cybercrimes.
According to Article 23 of the draft law, the crime of blasphemy carries a lifetime jail sentence if committed on the Internet, but only a five-year jail sentence if the same crime is committed on a satellite TV channel.
The report says Article 23 is the most dangerous in the draft law as it punishes actions committed on the Internet threatening public order, national unity and social peace with sentences that could reach lifetime jail terms.
“On such loose charges, hundreds of Internet users could be targeted, if, for example, they called for protests,” said Sherif Mohieddin of the Egyptian Initiative for Personal Rights.
The report criticises Article 14 of the draft law, which gives the state prosecution the right to ask the courts to block Internet content if it threatens national security. “This could be used to deprive citizens of the right to access information using ‘national security' as a pretext without giving any clear definition of it,” the report says.
Under Article 28 of the draft law the security agencies are allowed to suspend the service of any unregistered network user in cases that threaten national security.
The report also sheds light on the controversial Article 15 of the new law, which stipulates very harsh penalties for violators. The article sets a penalty of a three-year jail term and a fine of LE2 million against any Internet service provider that fails to comply with a criminal court decision to block certain websites or links.
If this failure results in the death of a person or the destabilisation of national security, the perpetrator could be sentenced to a lifetime jail term and a fine not exceeding LE20 million, the law says.
The draft has also been criticised for discriminating between the state and ordinary citizens, setting harsher penalties for those who commit crimes targeting government emails or websites.
Replying to his critics, Al-Shahawi was quoted as saying that it is unacceptable to propose a draft law that would restrict citizens' freedom or threaten their privacy. “Every citizen has the right to freely express his opinions and criticise government policies. However, he should not be allowed to incite murder through social media outlets or set up websites supporting terrorist entities,” Al-Shahawi said.
Talking to the parliament's online portal, Al-Shahawi said that cybercrime is the most serious threat facing the state. “It is our duty to take strict and deterring measures to counter such threats,” Al-Shahawi said, adding that the penalties stipulated in the draft law already exist in similar legislation worldwide and are applied in several European countries.
“This law has become a necessity, especially in the absence of a single article elsewhere that criminalises violations committed on the Internet,” Al-Shahawi concluded.
In February 2015, the cabinet started working on a draft cybercrime law, but no steps have been taken towards issuing it.

Clic here to read the story from its source.