Veteran Egyptian filmmaker Samir Seif passes away at 72    Hurghada, Cairo among world's 100 most visited cities in 2018    Egypt's FM Shoukry, Pompeo follow up on GERD talks, bilateral relations, regional developments    Here is the full list of Golden Globes 2020 nominations    Egypt's central bank launches industrial initiative to raise GDP to 7.5% annually: CBE deputy governor    Russia banned four years from Olympic Games over doping scandal    Only natural for Leicester to be overlooked, says Rodgers    Socceroos skipper Milligan announces international retirement    China says hopes it can reach trade agreement with U.S. soon    New IMF plan needed to reduce debt service costs: Jordan finance minister    Markets in Europe to open lower amid weak Chinese data    Saudi restaurants no longer need to segregate women and men    1 dead, many more missing in eruption of New Zealand volcano    Egypt's President Sisi urges improving ways to identify sport talents    Health insurance system to be launched in Upper Egypt, South Sinai in March    Biden campaign attacks Trump policy on Saudi Arabia, North Korea    Quake in Florence area disrupts Italy's national train network    Sisi reviews Egypt's new capital relocation scheme    Egypt's Sisi directs further efforts to develop higher education    Egypt's parliament speaker slams justice minister over 'inaction' in fighting corruption at notary offices    'The Irishman' draws 17 million U.S. viewers on Netflix, Nielsen estimates    Art Alert: King Lear on Cairo stage four times in December    Half of lymphoma patients alive three years after new cell therapy treatment: Study    Rocket hits Iraqi cleric's home following deadly Baghdad attack    Egypt's Sisi reviews anticipated New Administrative Capital relocation plan    Criminal court sentences 4 to death for killing 3 policemen in 2016 robbery    Even being big, burly one needs his mother    Egypt's Cabinet denies reports on increasing Jan. train fares    Egypt Zamalek's new coach eyes winning start in Champions League against 1º de Agosto    WHO decries "collective failure" as measles kills 140,000    Mohamed Salah, Zamalek's Hamed represent Egypt in shortlists for CAF awards    Rate of HIV infections in Egypt around 0.02% – minister    Adam Sandler threatens to make ‘so bad' movie if he doesn't win Oscar    Egypt's Tahrir Square among top Reuters photos of a decade    Egypt names 16 new governors ahead of anticipated Cabinet reshuffle    Egypt's MPs back potential return of information minister post in expected reshuffle    Court sentences six to death, 41 to lifetime imprisonment violence related case    Trump says he would release Mideast peace plan after Israeli elections    ACWA Power compares 3 bids to supply production units for Luxor power station    What do you know about gold alloying?    NBE announces EGP 2.5m prizes for handball youth teams for their world achievements    Jennifer Lopez evokes Egyptian outrage post her North Coast performance    Al-Sisi honours Egypt's scholars on Science Day    IS claims responsibility for suicide bombing killing 63 in Afghan wedding    Political parties gear up for parliamentary, senate, local elections    Unprecedented Glory: Egypt win Men's U-19 World Handball Championship    12th National Egyptian Theatre Festival fuel up public theatre art scene    Ministry of Environment has a plan for "black clouds season"    

Thank you for reporting!
This image will be automatically disabled when it gets reported by several people.

AUC research papers suggest progressive tax scale, other reforms to reduce income inequality in Egypt
Published in Ahram Online on 01 - 02 - 2018

Egypt's tax system has many flaws that not only limit its contribution to boosting economic growth, but also deepen inequality, with most of the burden being shouldered by those on lower incomes.
Tax revenue represents only 12.5 per cent of GDP, as compared to 20 to 25 per cent on average in countries within the same income group. And while there are five income-tax brackets ranging from LE7,200 to LE200,000 annually, these brackets are not organised on a progressive scale.
This results in a single tax rate of 22.5 per cent for those with an annual income ranging between LE200,000 and LE621,000, considered the highest-income stratum in Egypt.
As a result, the contribution of those in the highest income brackets is only 1.3 per cent of the total tax revenue. Indirect taxes such as consumption taxes, the bulk of which come from lower-income brackets, contribute 40 per cent of the total tax revenue.
While there is no reliable data on how wealth is distributed in order to know how fair the tax system is, the annual Global Wealth Report issued by the Swiss Credit Suisse Research Institute includes Egypt among 12 countries with extreme inequality and one of the nine countries with the most rapid growth in inequality of wealth.
Working on policies that aim at striking a balance between economic growth and equitable development, Alternative Policy Solutions, a one-year-old American University in Cairo (AUC) research project, has issued two papers on how to reform the tax regime in a way that increases revenues while adopting fairer taxation for different income brackets.
“The sharp and rapid concentration of wealth in the higher-income brackets has the negative consequences of hindering economic growth, increasing speculation, and prompting imbalances in the balance of payments, in addition to the social consequences of the widening gap among social classes,” states a paper entitled “Towards a Wealth Tax in Egypt”.
The paper highlights recommendations by the IMF and the Organisation of Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) to impose a tax on net wealth (after deducting debt), including movable assets such as securities, as a means to overcome problems with the tax system.
This wealth tax, imposed on both movable and immovable assets, would replace the current property tax which in its current form has failed to meet projected yields. The actual collected revenues of the property tax in 2015/2016 came in at only 68 per cent of the projected figures. On average, this tax represents only one per cent of GDP.
“Following a progressive tax rate that starts at one per cent for the segment that owns more than $1 million, and then grows until it reaches five per cent for the segment that owns more than a $1 billion, could generate triple the current property tax revenue,” notes the paper.
On the road to achieving this policy, Egypt should start reforming existing taxes on profits, the most important of which is the real estate tax. Real estate represents 68 per cent of total wealth in Egypt, and such taxation would not impact growth or productive investment.
The paper calls for adopting more transparent and practical criteria for the valuation of properties, establishing a unit to resolve disputes over valuations, and replacing tax exemptions with tax credits (deductions in taxes rather than in taxable income).
The paper also recommends reinstating the inheritance tax, which was annulled in the mid-1990s. For the authors of the paper, this is a more equitable tax than that on real estate as the tax burden is distributed on heirs and changes according to their numbers rather than by the size of inherited assets.
Another paper issued by the AUC project is entitled “The Stock Market: Efficiency and Equitability” and calls for increasing taxes on stock-market transactions. According to the paper, capital gains and dividends from stocks are not currently taxed, despite being included under taxable sources of income under the income tax law. In March 2017, the cabinet froze the imposition of a capital-gains tax until May 2020.
This was due to the belief that the stock exchange is one of the primary channels through which investors' money is transferred to the real economy. It was assumed that lowering tax rates would stimulate this channel, the paper said.
“The aim of low taxes is to encourage economic growth, but they don't do this,” Samer Attallah, an advisor to the Alternative Policy Solutions project, said. “Low taxes on transactions encourage speculative activities and do not help to direct investments and capital to the real economy.”
To reverse this situation, the paper calls for imposing a unified capital-gains tax on profits as a means to discourage hot money transactions. It also calls for imposing a stamp duty even when capital-gains tax is imposed. This would be while leaving room for the possibility of calculating the duty as a deductible acquisition cost in the medium and long term when calculating taxable profits.
“We need to attract long-term investment while increasing the cost of speculative activities,” Attallah said. Egypt introduced a 10 per cent tax on capital gains in July 2014, but suspended it for two years in 2015. It then extended the freeze for another three years in 2017. Last year saw the introduction of a stamp duty on stock-exchange transactions for both buyers and sellers. Investors have to pay LE1.25 duty on each LE1,000 worth of transactions in the first year, rising to LE1.5 in the second year and LE1.75 in the third.
“The stock-exchange taxes do not aim at limiting investment but at directing it to activities with better developmental and economic outcomes, as well as limiting the negative effects of speculation,” Attallah said.
* This story was first published in Al-Ahram Weekly

Clic here to read the story from its source.