Trump says ceasefire in Syria is holding despite few skirmishes    Johnson faces perilous Brexit ratification after Brexit deal vote blocked    China's economic growth could fall below 6% in 2020: IMF    Salah returns to Liverpool's trainings on Monday, says Egypt's coach    Lebanon set to cut ministers' pay in bid to defuse protests    Banks weigh on Saudi stocks ; other Gulf mixed    Match abandoned in latest blow to Mexican football    Tennis: Murray beats Wawrinka to win first title since hip surgery    Spanish PM to visit Barcelona, criticises regional chief    EBRD bank praises Egyptian reforms efforts – official    Sisi: Russia-Africa Summit reflects historic friendship ties    Parliament committee to address problem of stray dogs in Egypt    Shell Egypt to sell assets in Western Desert to focus on offshore exploration    WHO hails 'triumph' as Ebola vaccine gets European green light    Current and ex smokers may lower lung cancer risk with exercise    Lebanon agrees final budget with no taxes to appease protesters    Egypt's Sisi praises SCC's role in protecting justice, rights, freedoms    France's President Macron receives Egypt's Coptic Pope Tawadros II at Elysee    Egypt inks deal with Euroclear Bank to upgrade public debt management    Egypt's Cooperative Insurance Society to cover NGOs clients' loans    After a young pupil dies of meningitis in Egypt, tips to help prevention    Egypt's PM urges US's ADTRAN Inc. to invest in communications equipment    French President Macron receives Egypt's Coptic Pope Tawadros II at Elysee    'Passports should be valid for six months,' Egypt's foreign ministry advises citizens planning travel abroad    Grand Nile Tower Arts & Cultural Centre launches second round    Egypt's coach Hossam El-Badry satisfied with winning start despite technical problems    Luxor's new discoveries    Moroccan film Nomades scoops awards in Alexandria Film Festival    Toshiba's JV with Egyptian Elaraby opens regional HQ in South Africa    Six authors vie for Booker prize 2019, Atwood in the lead    In Photos: A sneak peek into rehearsals for the Cleopatra ballet world premiere    Sisi, Ethiopia's PM to meet in Moscow to discuss GERD issue    Sisi: army engaged in attrition phase against terrorism in Sinai since 2013    10K fans to attend Egypt's friendly against Botswana in Alexandria: EFA    Sisi, Ethiopia's PM agree to overcome obstacles in Nile dam talks    Farwell to Egyptian comic actor Talaat Zakaria    Court sentences six to death, 41 to lifetime imprisonment violence related case    Trump says he would release Mideast peace plan after Israeli elections    ACWA Power compares 3 bids to supply production units for Luxor power station    What do you know about gold alloying?    NBE announces EGP 2.5m prizes for handball youth teams for their world achievements    Jennifer Lopez evokes Egyptian outrage post her North Coast performance    Al-Sisi honours Egypt's scholars on Science Day    IS claims responsibility for suicide bombing killing 63 in Afghan wedding    Political parties gear up for parliamentary, senate, local elections    Unprecedented Glory: Egypt win Men's U-19 World Handball Championship    12th National Egyptian Theatre Festival fuel up public theatre art scene    Ministry of Environment has a plan for "black clouds season"    

Thank you for reporting!
This image will be automatically disabled when it gets reported by several people.

Sunni or Shia, we are all Muslim
Published in Daily News Egypt on 16 - 05 - 2008

BBC World recently aired the latest Doha Debate on the motion The Sunni-Shia conflict is damaging Islam s reputation as a religion of peace . It s a timely topic; and a very time-sensitive topic, because it is a question that can only be asked now. Not because the Sunni-Shia divide is a new phenomenon: it is an old, historical schism that emerged as a political division, which then became religious. But it is now that the political has really caused it to be so monumental.
I admit that, but I spoke against the motion in Doha, because the damage to Islam s reputation is more about the sensationalism of the media, and focusing on Muslim violence in general, rather than Sunni-Shia violence. But the motion brought up another question for me: in the midst of the Sunni-Shia conflict that exists in some pockets of the Muslim world, what are we to make of what Islam is or what Islam is not?
Let us be clear: Muslims do not agree on everything. Sunnis have their four, recognized schools of law, and the Shia have their own tradition of establishing orthodoxy. Within both groupings, there is the concept of respect for differences of opinion, which are to be celebrated and cherished within each of the groups. In inter Sunni-Shia discussions, the concept takes a different tone. The differences are grudgingly tolerated, but with an important proviso: both groupings are Muslim.
The theologians of Sunni Islam long ago established that the relied upon position for Sunnis is that the Shia are in fact a Muslim community. That status of relied upon is a particular type of orthodox stance; one that is difficult to determine, owing to the diversity within Sunni Islam. But on this issue, it was established, and it has been part of the historical orthodoxy that so characterizes Sunni Islam. On the Shia side, the same generally occurred: Sunnis might be mistaken, theologians said, and their views on Islam might be wrong, but they are still Muslims.
With the growth of the Wahhabi movement in the Najd of Saudi Arabia, tensions became more pronounced (not just for Shia, but other non-Wahhabi Muslims), but never to the point of extreme violence as we see now. Even the most puritanical of Wahhabi rulers did not ban Shia coming to Mecca and Medina on pilgrimage.
A few years ago, it became clear to the leaders of the Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan that the separation that Sunnis and Shia had mutually embraced was in danger of being abused by outside parties to justify violence, as had happened with Christians. Unlike Christendom, however, where truly religious wars took place -such as those between Christians and Protestants - the Muslim world took an unprecedented step. Seeing Al Qaeda s ideology as a threat to the co-existence of Sunnis and Shia in Iraq and elsewhere, Muslim scholars, both Sunni and Shia, came together to thwart that ideology.
Those scholars created a platform where hundreds of the most renowned scholars of the Muslim world, Sunni and Shia, including Abu Dhabi s Al-Habib Ali Al-Jifri of the Tabah Foundation, decided enough is enough . They declared that Sunnis and Shia were Muslim, and that violence should never occur between them. It was a united platform to defeat the murderous nihilism Al Qaeda was peddling. It was called the Amman Message (, and was signed in July 2005. Since then, hundreds more have signed the declaration online.
A couple of months later, Al Qaeda declared an all-out war on the Shia of Iraq, unprecedented in Muslim history. A couple of months after that, it targeted Amman in a spectacular massacre of innocents. But it failed to stop the momentum. Many around the world signed the original Amman Message, and developed their own local versions. Political leaders in the Sunni and Shia worlds spoke clearly, whether from nominally Wahhabi Saudi Arabia or staunchly Shia Iran: the two may differ from each other, but they will not allow anyone, whether Al Qaeda or anyone else, Muslim or non-Muslim, to pit Sunnis against Shia, or vice versa.
Personally, I am not particularly interested in whether Islam is defined as a religion of peace, or a religion of war, or anything else for that matter. What is important is that we get qualified and authoritative definitions. Many are trying to claim the authority to do that: American pundits, radical extremists, take your pick. But what we have to do is realize who already has that authority.
The definitions are elaborated by Islam s own specialists: its scholars, theologians, jurists and spiritualists, who renewed their attitudes through the Amman Message and said to each other: We may differ with each other, but those differences should never become the cause of violence. Al Qaeda in Iraq responded by trying to impose their own religious authority.
For all of us, the choice is simple. Do we admit that violent radicals can define Islam by their murderous rampages? Or will we send a message to them that no matter how much they try - in Amman, in the Muslim world, in New York, in London, in Madrid, and beyond - criminal extremists will never have the authority to define anything?
I know what I say to them: You will lose. Civilization will win.
The Doha Debates are archived at
Dr. H. A. Hellyeris Fellow of the University of Warwick, a member of the Oxford Centre for Islamic Studies, and founder-director of the Visionary Consultants Group, (, a Muslim world-West relations consultancy. This article is distributed by the Common Ground News Service (CGNews) and can be accessed at It was originally published in The National,

Clic here to read the story from its source.