Egypt partners with Google to promote 'unmatched diversity' tourism campaign    Golf Festival in Cairo to mark Arab Golf Federation's 50th anniversary    Taiwan GDP surges on tech demand    World Bank: Global commodity prices to fall 17% by '26    Germany among EU's priciest labour markets – official data    UNFPA Egypt, Bayer sign agreement to promote reproductive health    Egypt to boost marine protection with new tech partnership    France's harmonised inflation eases slightly in April    Eygpt's El-Sherbiny directs new cities to brace for adverse weather    CBE governor meets Beijing delegation to discuss economic, financial cooperation    Egypt's investment authority GAFI hosts forum with China to link business, innovation leaders    Cabinet approves establishment of national medical tourism council to boost healthcare sector    Egypt's Gypto Pharma, US Dawa Pharmaceuticals sign strategic alliance    Egypt's Foreign Minister calls new Somali counterpart, reaffirms support    "5,000 Years of Civilizational Dialogue" theme for Korea-Egypt 30th anniversary event    Egypt's Al-Sisi, Angola's Lourenço discuss ties, African security in Cairo talks    Egypt's Al-Mashat urges lower borrowing costs, more debt swaps at UN forum    Two new recycling projects launched in Egypt with EGP 1.7bn investment    Egypt's ambassador to Palestine congratulates Al-Sheikh on new senior state role    Egypt pleads before ICJ over Israel's obligations in occupied Palestine    Sudan conflict, bilateral ties dominate talks between Al-Sisi, Al-Burhan in Cairo    Cairo's Madinaty and Katameya Dunes Golf Courses set to host 2025 Pan Arab Golf Championship from May 7-10    Egypt's Ministry of Health launches trachoma elimination campaign in 7 governorates    EHA explores strategic partnership with Türkiye's Modest Group    Between Women Filmmakers' Caravan opens 5th round of Film Consultancy Programme for Arab filmmakers    Fourth Cairo Photo Week set for May, expanding across 14 Downtown locations    Egypt's PM follows up on Julius Nyerere dam project in Tanzania    Ancient military commander's tomb unearthed in Ismailia    Egypt's FM inspects Julius Nyerere Dam project in Tanzania    Egypt's FM praises ties with Tanzania    Egypt to host global celebration for Grand Egyptian Museum opening on July 3    Ancient Egyptian royal tomb unearthed in Sohag    Egypt hosts World Aquatics Open Water Swimming World Cup in Somabay for 3rd consecutive year    Egyptian Minister praises Nile Basin consultations, voices GERD concerns    Paris Olympic gold '24 medals hit record value    A minute of silence for Egyptian sports    Russia says it's in sync with US, China, Pakistan on Taliban    It's a bit frustrating to draw at home: Real Madrid keeper after Villarreal game    Shoukry reviews with Guterres Egypt's efforts to achieve SDGs, promote human rights    Sudan says countries must cooperate on vaccines    Johnson & Johnson: Second shot boosts antibodies and protection against COVID-19    Egypt to tax bloggers, YouTubers    Egypt's FM asserts importance of stability in Libya, holding elections as scheduled    We mustn't lose touch: Muller after Bayern win in Bundesliga    Egypt records 36 new deaths from Covid-19, highest since mid June    Egypt sells $3 bln US-dollar dominated eurobonds    Gamal Hanafy's ceramic exhibition at Gezira Arts Centre is a must go    Italian Institute Director Davide Scalmani presents activities of the Cairo Institute for ITALIANA.IT platform    







Thank you for reporting!
This image will be automatically disabled when it gets reported by several people.



Threats to judicial independence?
Published in Al-Ahram Weekly on 10 - 01 - 2017

During a meeting at the Judges Club in Cairo on 25 December, Egypt's judges announced their strong opposition to a new draft law that they said would threaten their independence.
“The proposed draft undermines well-established judicial principles and violates the constitution,” said a statement issued following the meeting. Several judicial authorities threatened to take escalatory measures against the proposed legislation as a result.
The law at issue, which amends the way judicial authority heads are appointed, was presented to the House of Representatives last month by Deputy Chairman of the Legislative Committee Ahmed Helmi Al-Sherif and 60 other MPs.
The drafters of the amendments insisted that as the legislative authority the parliament had the right to issue all the laws that regulate the work of the state, adding that they were ready to consult representatives of the four judicial authorities before endorsing the law.
Article 185 of the constitution obliges the parliament to take the opinions of the judicial bodies into account when drafting laws regulating their affairs.
The proposed draft includes amendments to Article 44 of the Judiciary Law, Article 83 of the State Council Law, Article 35 of the Administrative Prosecution Authority Law and Article 16 of the State Litigation Authority law.
House of Representatives Speaker Ali Abdel-Aal referred the proposed draft to the legislative committee for discussion. Following the first hearing on 25 December, the committee decided to send copies of the draft to the judicial bodies concerned in order to hear their opinions.
The proposed amendments replace the principle of seniority in appointing judicial authority heads by different criteria. According to the previous laws regulating the affairs of the judicial bodies, each authority presents the name of its oldest deputy chairman to the president, who then endorses the appointment to chairman.
Under the proposed amendments, the president would have the right to choose the next head of the judicial authorities from three nominees, the names of whom would be given by the authority concerned.
Defending the draft, Al-Sherif said the amendments did not constitute a threat to the independence of the judiciary. “The aim is to guarantee that the most efficient judge and not just the oldest will chair the judicial bodies,” Al-Sherif said.
The explanatory memorandum attached to the proposed law says that relying on the principle of seniority in some cases could result in the appointment of chairmen not capable of doing their job probably because of old age or poor health.
However, the judges have replied that if it is time to replace seniority with efficiency in appointing the heads of the judicial bodies, then this should be the task of the general assembly of each body, rather than the president.
“The president by himself cannot decide on this point unless he relies on security reports as well,” Judge Adel Farghali, a former deputy chairman of the State Council, said.
Farghali warned that the draft law would have serious repercussions if it was endorsed. “First, it will allow the security apparatus to interfere in judicial appointments. Second, some judges will feel pressure to please the executive when making judgements,” he said.
“The independence of the judiciary means that the choice of the heads of the judicial bodies should be determined by the judges without the least interference from the executive authority.”
Opponents of the draft law argue that it threatens the independence of the judicial authorities, especially the State Council, the body assigned to hear lawsuits filed by citizens contesting executive decrees.
If he is appointed by the head of the executive, the chairman of the State Council may not be neutral when making rulings in such lawsuits, the judges said.
Sources close to judicial circles claim the reason for issuing this draft law now is to ban Judge Yehia Dakrouri from becoming chair of the State Council. Last June, Dakrouri made a ruling saying that Egypt had a historical right to the Tiran and Sanafir Islands.
As the oldest deputy chairman of the State Council, Dakrouri is the sole nominee for the chairman's seat, due to be vacant next June following the retirement of the council's current chairman Mohamed Massoud.
Hamed Al-Gamal, a former chairman of the State Council, was quoted as saying that “the draft law constitutes a flagrant violation of the constitution's principles, which stress the separation of powers. As the draft makes the judiciary subject to the executive, the draft is unconstitutional.”
Nasser Amin, chairman of the Arab Centre for the Independence of the Judiciary and the Legal Profession, an NGO, said the proposed draft was an attack on the independence of the judiciary.
“It will negatively affect the credibility and neutrality of the judiciary and damage its reputation with the international community,” he said.


Clic here to read the story from its source.