Policeman shot dead in Egypt's Sinai    Investment Minister meets Greek ambassador to Egypt    In Pictures: Two tunnels discovered, destroyed on North Sinai border, Egypt    Putin praises Pope Tawadros II and relations with Egypt    UN Security Council approves Egypt's resolution on terrorism    545 tourists visit Saint Catherine over past 24 hours    "Bambah" and "Ballerinas of Cairo" bring retro magic to the streets of Cairo    Sinai Trail: Explore nature and spiritual atmosphere    Egypt arrests members of Hasm Muslim Brotherhood-linked extremist cell    On Trump's visit to KSA: Right Hand Diplomacy    Suez Canal's official: Investment certificates are completely secure    Egypt's former Grand Mufti to women: You are the true heroines    Al-Sisi discusses refugees issue, situation in Libya with Austrian chancellor    Egyptian, Russian negotiations about flight resumption still suspended: Okulov    Bylaw amendments in companies law are issued to encourage investments: Nasr    Labour Ministry interferes to solve issues of 265 workers with company in Ismalia    Egypt rejects Al-Bashir's accusations of supporting rebels in Darfur    Financial analyst: Egypt's rate rise was smart decision    Hansi Flick joins Hoffenheim's management    Dortmund's Kagawa opens up about bus attack on blog    Germany's Gabriel sees 'deal' with China on e-car quota    In Pictures: Four Egyptian stolen artifacts retrieved from Britain    Lack of maintenance, low facility management skills wastes EGP 20bn    Where are Europe's best bathing sites?    Manchester City's Leroy Sané withdraws from Germany's Confederations Cup squad    Crossing borders musically: Dresdner Sinfoniker will not be silenced    High Administrative Court questions constitutionality of Emergency Law articles    Court accepts Ahmed Nagi's appeal, sentences a retrial    Army destroys two tunnels beneath Egypt-Gaza border    After tribal clashes, is Sinai militancy turning into proxy war?    Al-Bawaba News holds seminar in tribute to late Egyptian thinker El-Sayyid Yassin    To promote tourism... Cristiano Ronaldo's family visits pyramids    "Clash" keeps its success chain in de Cinéma Vues d'Afrique    Family of football player Ronaldo visits Pyramids & Egyptian Museum    Hong Kong Science Museum to showcase Egyptian mummies    Egyptian team adds 5 new medals at 4th Islamic Solidarity Games    مباشر – مانشستر يونايتد 0-0 أندرلخت    بارترا يتحدث بعد "أطول 15 دقيقة في حياته"    Newsreel    New Year routine    Imminent cabinet reshuffle    Footballer furore    In quest of national consensus    ‘Protecting the weakest'    Briefs    IMF open to scrutiny    Art heist goes wrong    All the fun of the Book Fair    

Thank you for reporting!
This image will be automatically disabled when it gets reported by several people.

HRW Calls on Egypt to Stop Using Shoot-To-Kill against African Migrants in Sinai
Published in Almasry Alyoum on 13 - 11 - 2008

Human Rights Watch (HRW) has criticized Egypt for using “shoot-to-kill” against African migrants and refugees that attempt to cross into Israel along the porous Sinai border.
It also criticized the Israeli government for forcibly returning those migrants to Egypt, which is considered an "unsafe country for migrants", as HRW put it.
Egyptian border guards have shot and killed at least 33 migrants since July 2007, and Israel forcibly returned 139 migrants to Egypt of which we know nothing till now, HRW said in a report released on Wednesday in Cairo.
Joe Stork, Human Rights Watch's deputy Middle East director, said: "Officials in Egypt justify those accidents on the ground that they are unintended errors because the policeman who stands alone in Sinai fears from any unnatural movement, especially as Sinai is a dangerous place and full of terrorists."
"We can justify killing if it was a single accident, but with this great number, the matter seems as a policy. I'm sorry to say that I did not find any kind of change in the Egyptian government's way of thinking or assessing the issue."
"It seems that there is an announced policy to shoot the migrants to stop them although this imposes danger to their lives," he added.
In fact, the Sinai border is a perilous region rife with weapons and drug smugglers. The Egyptian government has long been criticized by Israel for failing to prevent weapons smuggling to Gazan militants through Sinai tunnels. 
“We recognize that Sinai is a dangerous place," Van Esveld said, "but in the cases we investigated, there was no threat being posed by the people who were shot at.”
"Unfortunately, Cairo does not know how the issue is dangerous," he said, adding that during his meeting two days ago with the Egyptians they said: "What such people can expect in an area like Sinai. It is a dangerous place and migrants should know that they would be exposed to danger as they can be exposed to danger in New York for example."
The report also slammed the Egyptian government for not allowing African refugees to make asylum claims, for trying them in military courts and for deporting hundreds of them to conflict zones.  
The report, titled “Sinai Perils: Risks to Migrants, Refugees and Asylum seekers in Egypt and Israel,” also criticizes Israel for returning African refugees and asylum seekers back to Egypt.
“Both Egypt and Israel have responded to this cross-border flow with policies that violate fundamental rights,” said the report.
“Despite the violations of refugee rights on the Egyptian side, Israel had returned many people back to the custody of the Egyptian border police,” added Van Esveld.
The report emphasized that Egypt began a shoot-to-stop policy following a meeting between the Israeli prime minister and Egyptian President Hosni Mubarak in late June 2007. In the meeting, the two leaders discussed the flow of refugees into Israel from Egypt.
“We are not saying that Israel ordered Egypt to kill people; there is no evidence of that,” explained Van Esveld, “but what we are saying is that it seems that Egypt has responded to Israeli pressures with this policy of lethal force.” 
For his part, Michael Kagan, professor with the American University, voiced disappointment over the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees' silence and not taking any steps to protect the refugees and migrants. "We thought that Egypt and Israel will be the safe shelter for the refugees, but this image has been shaken," he added.
"I had two choices, the first was going to Europe through Libya and in this case I might drown. The second choice was going to Israel and in this case I might be shot. I preferred to be shot rather than drown," a Sudanese migrant, who lived in Egypt for a long time, said.

Clic here to read the story from its source.