EGP declines vs. USD at Thursday's close    Euro area inflation rises to 2.0% in October '24 – flash estimates    IF YOU LOVE SOMEONE WHO SMOKES, GIVE THEM THE FACTS    Asian stocks slide as chip sector weakens    Egypt's Minister of Environment highlights biodiversity issues at COP16    Egypt's Agriculture Minister meets Syrian, Bahraini counterparts to boost cooperation in Amman    Al-Qassam Brigades targets Israeli vehicles in eastern Gaza    ACUD, DP World, and GAFI sign MoU to develop free zone in New Capital    Egyptian government encourages increased mutual investment with Bahrain: Finance Minister    A Tale of Two Cities: Alexandria hosts 2nd edition of exhibition celebrating Greek, Egyptian cultural ties    Egypt, Djibouti leaders discuss strengthening ties, regional issues    Egypt's FM affirms commitment to Sahel security, offers support to Niger    Egyptian banking sector support underprivileged communities in Alexandria – CBE    Afghanistan signs $163m deal for cement plant    US tightens tech investment rules for China    Biden unveils $3b investment to strengthen US port infrastructure    Military Production, Environment Ministers inaugurate banana fiber recycling plant    Luxor Museum to host exhibition on 19th century antiquities inspection tours    Nourhan Kamal Wins 2024 Helmi Sharawy Award for African Studies    Egypt observes Intl. E-waste Day, highlights recycling efforts    Egypt's military capabilities sufficient to defend country: Al-Sisi    Al-Sisi emphasises water security is Egypt's top priority amid Nile River concerns    Cairo Opera House hosts grand opening of Arab Music Festival, Conference    Grand Egyptian Museum ready for partial trial run on October 16: PM    Colombia unveils $40b investment plan for climate transition    Kabaddi: Ancient Indian sport gaining popularity in Egypt    Ecuador's drought forces further power cuts    Al-Sisi orders sports system overhaul after Paris Olympics    Basketball Africa League Future Pros returns for 2nd season    Egypt joins Africa's FEDA    Paris Olympic gold '24 medals hit record value    A minute of silence for Egyptian sports    Paris Olympics opening draws record viewers    Who leads the economic portfolios in Egypt's new Cabinet?    Financial literacy becomes extremely important – EGX official    Motaz Azaiza mural in Manchester tribute to Palestinian journalists    Russia says it's in sync with US, China, Pakistan on Taliban    It's a bit frustrating to draw at home: Real Madrid keeper after Villarreal game    Shoukry reviews with Guterres Egypt's efforts to achieve SDGs, promote human rights    Sudan says countries must cooperate on vaccines    Johnson & Johnson: Second shot boosts antibodies and protection against COVID-19    Egypt to tax bloggers, YouTubers    Egypt's FM asserts importance of stability in Libya, holding elections as scheduled    Egypt records 36 new deaths from Covid-19, highest since mid June    We mustn't lose touch: Muller after Bayern win in Bundesliga    Egypt sells $3 bln US-dollar dominated eurobonds    Gamal Hanafy's ceramic exhibition at Gezira Arts Centre is a must go    Italian Institute Director Davide Scalmani presents activities of the Cairo Institute for ITALIANA.IT platform    







Thank you for reporting!
This image will be automatically disabled when it gets reported by several people.



What Copts fear
Published in Al-Ahram Weekly on 08 - 12 - 2005

Are the concerns of Copts following the gains the outlawed Muslim Brotherhood made in the parliamentary elections justified? Gihan Shahine finds some answers
That the Muslim Brotherhood (MB) has doubled the number of its seats in parliament, forming the largest opposition bloc, concerns apparently not just members of the ruling National Democratic Party (NDP). Many Copts, not to mention secularists and liberals, have also expressed fear that the group's rise to power will ultimately turn Egypt into a conservative Islamic state where Copts will be treated as second-class citizens and women would be discriminated against.
Only one out of 50 Coptic candidates who ran in the parliamentary polls won a seat -- probably for no reason other than being a minister -- increasing speculation that a growing sectarian environment is sweeping the country where voters cast their ballots according to religious rather than political affiliations. The speculation found expression in a recent controversial US-based conference which called for greater US pressure on Egypt, and restrictions on Washington's aid to Cairo, in light of alleged persecution of the nation's Coptic Orthodox Christians.
Prominent Coptic thinker and urban planner Milad Hanna was one of the first to express Coptic fears out loud when he told the local press, "If the Muslim Brothers come to power, Egypt will be an Islamic state like Iran and Sudan."
Hanna was quoted saying, "The day the Muslim Brothers win more than 50 per cent, the rich Copts will leave the country and the poorer Copts will stay. Perhaps some of them will be converted... I hope I die before this happens."
He reiterated his assertion that "Copts are Egyptian to the core and their ties with Muslims will remain as strong as ever."
Prominent Coptic thinker Rafiq Habib said the Coptic elite and businessmen, as well as secularists and liberals, are the ones most worried that the rise of the Brotherhood to power would put their interests at stake. "The vagueness of the Brotherhood's agenda and the fierce campaign the state and secular media are waging to distort their image has further boosted widespread misconceptions about the group," Habib explained. "Many Copts, for instance, confuse between [the discourse of] the Brotherhood and [that of] militant Islamists, although the two are totally different," Habib added. "There are many extreme edicts that Copts mistakenly think were issued by the Brotherhood."
Many analysts speculate that the NDP has been blowing up such fears to garner the support of Coptic voters and to persuade the United States that the rise of the Brotherhood "would lead to the persecution of the country's Coptic community the US claims to defend," Habib added.
Leading MB member Abdel-Moneim Abul- Futuh argues, "Those whose interests run counter to [the Brotherhood] use [the banned group] to scare Copts," a plan that Abul-Futuh insists "has largely failed to fool the public who have direct contact with members of the Brotherhood." Abul- Futuh mentioned Brotherhood candidate Saad El-Hosseini who reportedly received the support of Coptic voters in the constituency of Mehalla. "We always had a clear stance towards our Coptic brothers which puts them on an equal par with Muslims in all rights and duties of citizenship," Abul-Futuh said.
For many Copts, however, the Brotherhood has been using what is described as "elastic" and "vague" terminology that may imply sinister intentions.
"Up until now the Brotherhood has not declared any real or clear political agenda," said key Kifaya Party member George Isaak . Not that Isaak is worried. "I can't be happier about the gains the Brotherhood made in the [parliamentary] polls because its performance in the parliament will clear up much of the vagueness surrounding its discourse and show its real capabilities and influence now that it need no longer act as the martyr of the nation."
The group's slogan -- "Islam is the solution" -- has been a major bone of contention. Many Copts were incensed, believing the slogan implied they were being treated as second-class citizens who would be forced to succumb to Islamic Shari'a law in a predominantly Islamic nation. The Brotherhood, for its part, repeated assertions that its slogan meant that Islamic civilisation is the reference of a "non-discriminatory" agenda, which gives precedence to citizenship.
Copts insist the use of the word "Islam" makes them feel excluded and, as Hanna argued, "would immediately mean giving precedence to religion over citizenship.
"Egypt should be a secular country where all citizens are treated equally regardless of their religious affiliations," Hanna insisted.
Sameh Fawzi, managing editor of the weekly Watani newspaper, argued, "Citizenship as a term was largely absent in the Brotherhood's official statements, which instead referred to Copts as Ahl Zimma (non-Muslims enjoying the protection of Muslims).
"This Islamisation of the state would reduce both Copts and Muslims to single blocs succumbing to a unified Islamic project and such radical edicts like those published in the group's official magazine in 1980 which nearly banned Copts from establishing churches and joining the army," Fawzi said. Although the edicts were reportedly issued more than two decades ago, Fawzi remains worried that the same person who issued them, Abdullah El-Khatib, "still holds a prominent position in the group".
Abul-Futuh, however, countered that the group had "made it clear in an official statement issued in 1994 that citizens are the source of power and are equal in all rights and duties regardless of religion and gender.
"No law, no matter how divine, can be enforced without the public's consent," Abul-Futuh told the Weekly. "We respect the Christian creed and would never impose any law that would prohibit Copts from practicing their religious rituals." He mentioned the fact that three Copts had been working in the political office of the group's founder Hassan El-Banna as further proof that the Brotherhood was never anti-Coptic.
That said, however, Habib insisted the Brotherhood "now has a bigger responsibility to make its well-intended principles known to the public and declare a clearer, more specific agenda using terms which do not confuse.
"Copts, for their part, should engage in a dialogue with the Brotherhood to get a clearer picture of their beliefs and agenda away from antagonist media propaganda," Habib said.


Clic here to read the story from its source.